- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper studies the estimation of entropic optimal transport between two distributions. It asks whether using the relationship between the distributions can improve the accuracy of EOT estimation compared to estimating the two distributions separately. The authors consider this question for distributions linked by a density ratio model. The DRM-EOT method proposed by the authors estimates this density ratio and uses the pooled sample with reweighting to estimate both distributions. EOT is then computed between them. The authors derive an exact formula for the reduction in asymptotic variance compared to the standard empirical estimator and prove that, under the assumptions, their method reaches the theoretical efficiency bound. On synthetic data, the authors compare the spread of estimates across repeated experiments and check how often the confidence intervals contain the true EOT value. In the synthetic experiment with a correct model, the method reduced the variance, and the confidence intervals had coverage close to 95%. When using a model with more parameters, the variance reduction almost disappeared. In the same experiments, the authors showed that when the assumptions about the model linking the distributions are violated, the estimate can systematically differ from the true value. On the OfficeHome dataset with real data, the method reduces the overall error when the target sample is small: its mean estimate becomes closer to the reference value, although its variance is higher than that of the standard empirical estimator.
Critical strengths
The authors determine how much the spread of EOT estimates can be reduced by using the relationship between the distributions, and prove that their method reaches this limit. Under the assumptions, no other regular estimator using the same information can have a lower asymptotic variance. This shows that the proposed method makes full use of the model linking the distributions to improve accuracy, without using additional data.
Critical weaknesses
Variance reduction is demonstrated in experiments where the density ratio model holds by construction. As the authors acknowledge, the paper does not establish that this benefit can also be obtained under natural distribution shifts. This leaves it unclear in which real-world settings the main theoretical advantage can be useful.
Experimental code is not provided with the paper or the supplementary material. Although the authors describe the experimental setup, the implementation and scripts needed to reproduce the tables and figures are missing.
Questions for authors
Could you give a specific example of real data with natural distribution shifts where the density ratio model is plausible and could reduce the variance of the EOT estimate? Are there experimental results for such a case?
3 comments
I thank the authors for providing the source code and adding the dividend experiment. The variance reduction in FY2024 is substantial, and I also appreciate reporting the less clear results for FY2023. However, it is still unclear how well the linear tilt fits the data, and whether similar variance reductions can be expected in other settings.
My initial requests are mostly resolved. Given the additional concerns, I am still considering whether to keep my rating or raise it by one point.
Thank you for the follow-up. We chose a linear basis because it gives an interpretable model for how the odds of a zero-dividend proposal vary with return, volatility, and firm size. To check the fit, we added squared terms and pairwise interactions and compared the models on the same five folds within each year. Their out-of-fold log loss was nearly identical in FY2023 (both 0.567). In FY2024, the quadratic model improved on the linear model (0.560 vs. 0.570).
The 36–38% EOT variance reduction in FY2024 is specific to that cohort and sampling design. Both FY2023 variance-ratio intervals included one. Under correct specification, Theorem 1 explains why gains vary: their size depends on how much of the EOT potential contrast lies outside the chosen basis span. The theory already allows fixed nonlinear bases. A next step is to study how to select the basis from data while preserving valid inference for the EOT value.
Natural shifts (W1/Q1). We compare Chinese A-share firms with positive or explicitly zero pre-tax amounts per share in their recorded annual cash dividend proposals. The features are return, volatility, and market capitalization at fiscal year-end, before disclosure (§6.3 and Appendix J.1–J.2). To study target scarcity, we set the sample sizes at 240 for the positive group and 20 or 40 for the zero group. We sample with replacement from each annual pool and use the same 600 draws per configuration for both estimators. RMSE is measured relative to the full-pool NP-EOT value (Appendix J.3, Appendix Table 17).
Across the 14 configurations in FY2018–FY2024, the 95% pointwise Monte Carlo intervals conditional on the annual pools lie below one for 12 DRM/NP variance ratios and all 14 RMSE ratios (main-text Table 3). For FY2024, the variance ratios are 0.637 [0.550, 0.746] and 0.618 [0.555, 0.692], reductions of 36.3% and 38.2% at target sizes 20 and 40. Both FY2023 variance intervals include one. We fit feature scaling on FY2018–FY2022 and hold it fixed for the later FY2023–FY2024 evaluation cohorts. These two pools share 4,645 firms (Appendix J.1), and Appendix Table 16 gives the group counts. The dividend comparison shows finite-sample variance reduction for a naturally observed grouping under the stated annual-pool design.
We use a linear tilt as a working model for the dividend groups. With G=1 for an explicit zero proposal and λg=P(G=g) before sampling, log odds a+β⊤z yield the ratio dF1/dF0=(λ0/λ1)exp(a+β⊤z) by Bayes' rule. The likelihood uses the fixed experimental sampling fractions. We obtain fitted scores by five-fold stratified cross-validation with class-balanced, ℓ2-regularized logistic regression. The out-of-fold AUROC is 0.672 in FY2023 and 0.712 in FY2024. In both years over 99% of positive-group scores and all zero-group scores lie in [0.05, 0.95]. The diagnostic measures overlap on the fitted scale. Each EOT draw uses a separate unpenalized DRM fit (Appendix J.2). Theorem 1 concerns the asymptotic variance at a correctly specified pair under its stated conditions.
Code (W2). We prepared
anonymous_code_reviewer.zipfor the submission's Supplementary Material field. It contains the experiment scripts, frozen OfficeHome PCA features, and 8,400 pairs of saved dividend EOT estimates without firm-level features. From the extractedreproducibility/directory, after installingrequirements.txt,python scripts/verify_package.pychecks package integrity and recomputes all 14 dividend summaries and intervals from the saved pairs. The commandpython experiments/dividend/export_tables.py --out outputs/dividend_texregenerates the three dividend tables from the archived summaries. Small runs of the synthetic and both OfficeHome workflows passed. Refitting the dividend models and recomputing EOT require a separately prepared company-year feature snapshot that matches the archived checksum. Seedata/dividend/DATA_PROVENANCE.mdfor the authorized inputs and preparation steps andexperiments/dividend/README.mdfor the replay commands. With the matching features, a small replay reproduced the FY2024 reference and 10 paired estimates.