- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes JETO, a conditional flow-matching model that learns the joint observational distribution . A single model provides treatment-specific outcome distributions, conditional average treatment effects, and propensity scores. Across six synthetic and semi-synthetic benchmarks, JETO achieves the lowest mean relative PEHE on four datasets. An architecture-matched comparison shows benefits when treatment propensity and outcome modality share covariate-dependent structure. Additional experiments examine conditional-density recovery, propensity estimation, and numerical inference.
Critical strengths
-
Competitive empirical performance. JETO achieves the lowest mean relative PEHE on four of six benchmarks, including a substantial improvement on IHDP. These results shows practical promise for treatment-effect estimation.
-
A useful controlled study. The architecture-matched comparison between joint and conditional modelling provides evidence that the assignment signal can improve estimation when propensity and outcome modality share structure. These findings support a potentially useful empirical contribution.
Critical weaknesses
-
Insufficient motivation for joint generation. Under the standard identification assumptions, the potential-outcome distribution is identified by . Joint generation models observational treatment assignment and outcomes; it does not itself specify an intervention mechanism or provide additional causal identification. Its motivation therefore rests primarily on estimation benefits, which need to be more clearly established relative to separately modeling and .
-
Limited methodological novelty. The method mainly applies standard conditional flow matching to an augmented treatment-outcome target, with treatment encoding or continuous relaxation. I find this extension incremental, and the paper does not sufficiently establish its additional methodological value beyond existing conditional generative approaches.
Questions for authors
-
Can the authors provide a capacity- and compute-matched comparison against a conditional flow-matching outcome model with a shared covariate representation and an auxiliary propensity-score head? This targeted comparison would materially affect my assessment of the contribution of joint generation.
-
Does the advantage over architecture-matched conditional JETO persist on IHDP, where the main benchmark reports the largest improvement? A paired comparison would help establish whether that improvement is attributable to the joint formulation.
We thank the reviewer for the detailed assessment and for identifying a concrete comparison that could help clarify the contribution of JETO. We would like to emphasize a distinction central to our work: while the joint distribution admits an exact factorization into propensity and conditional outcome distributions, this equivalence does not imply equivalent finite-sample estimation performance for models trained under different objectives. Our contribution lies in investigating the estimation benefits of joint generation, rather than proposing additional causal identification assumptions. To address the reviewer's concerns directly, we provide a new capacity-matched comparison with auxiliary propensity supervision and paired results on IHDP, showing that the benefits of joint generation cannot be explained solely by the additional assignment supervision in the evaluated settings.
Q1
Yes. Revised Table 2 adds a conditional outcome flow with a shared covariate representation and an auxiliary propensity head. We matched model capacity by parameter count and used the same total Monte Carlo budget. The table reports paired comparisons on the same realizations. Values below are mean rPEHE, with lower values better. The last column gives the unadjusted paired 95% t interval for the propensity-head control minus joint JETO.
Joint JETO outperforms the requested propensity-head control on all three datasets, with all three paired intervals above zero. GM-P provides the most direct test of the proposed mechanism. Adding a propensity head to the conditional flow changes mean rPEHE from 0.6273 to 0.6267, whereas joint generation reduces it to 0.5834. On GM-I the outcome-only conditional model has the lowest mean. These results locate the contribution at the level of estimation under the same causal identification assumptions.
Q2
Yes in mean rPEHE, and the advantage also holds against the assignment-supervised control requested by the reviewer. Across all 99 paired IHDP evaluation realizations, joint JETO achieves the lowest mean of the three variants. Its rPEHE is approximately 7% lower than the outcome-only conditional flow’s (0.1550 vs. 0.1667) and 10% lower than the propensity-head control’s (0.1550 vs. 0.1728). For conditional minus joint, the paired 95% interval is [−0.0007, 0.0242], leaving a near-tie compatible with the data. For the propensity-head control minus joint, the interval is entirely positive [0.0060, 0.0295]. Thus the favorable IHDP result survives a within-architecture comparison and is clearest against the very control proposed to explain it. The full comparison with external baselines and this paired ablation answer complementary questions about overall performance and the contribution of the joint formulation.