acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Procedural Pretraining for Molecular Property Prediction

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Molecular property prediction is often limited by the small size of labeled downstream datasets, motivating pretraining on large corpora of unlabeled molecules. In this work, we ask whether useful inductive biases can instead be learned from abstract, procedurally generated data before a model sees any molecular data. We introduce a three-stage training pipeline consisting of procedural pretraining, molecular pretraining on SMILES, and downstream fine-tuning, and evaluate several procedural tasks spanning sequence structure, cellular automata, and graph reasoning. We find that procedural pretraining can improve molecular property prediction even after subsequent molecular pretraining: on Lipophilicity, Reverse reduces test error by 4.8%. For context, the magnitude of this improvement is roughly 90% of the performance difference between our 250K-molecule baseline and the publicly released MoLFormer checkpoint pretrained on approximately 100M molecules. Our analysis shows that the benefit is strongest under downstream data scarcity, depends on the structure of the procedural data rather than only surface-level statistics, and does not increase monotonically with additional procedural training. Instead, transfer typically peaks at an intermediate procedural budget and deteriorates as the model approaches convergence on the procedural task. We further find that, for several tasks, much of the transferable information is localized in the attention layers, while feed-forward layers can contribute to over-specialization. These results show that procedural data can provide transferable structure for molecular learning and offer a complementary route to improving performance when labeled molecular data are limited.

Primary area:
transfer learning, meta learning, and lifelong learning
Keywords:
procedural pretraining, molecular property prediction

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_8zqVOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper investigates whether procedural pretraining on synthetic tasks can improve molecular property prediction. It introduces a three-stage pipeline combining procedural pretraining, molecular pretraining, and downstream fine-tuning. The results show improvements on Lipophilicity, particularly with REVERSE, while additional analyses examine data scarcity, procedural structure, training budgets, and component-wise transfer.

Critical strengths

1. Interesting Research Direction

Applying procedural pretraining to molecular learning is an interesting extension of prior work, suggesting that useful inductive biases can be learned without molecular data.

2. Useful Experimental Analyses

The paper includes several informative analyses, including shuffled-token controls, data-scarcity experiments, procedural-budget sweeps, and attention-only versus feed-forward-only transfer.

Critical weaknesses

1. Limited Generalization of the Main Results

The strongest improvement in the full three-stage pipeline is concentrated on Lipophilicity with REVERSE pretraining (4.8%). Improvements on QM9 are modest, while FreeSolv shows no consistent benefit. The evidence is therefore insufficient to establish broad effectiveness across molecular prediction tasks.

2. Unclear Mechanism Behind Procedural Transfer

REVERSE achieves the strongest improvement despite having little apparent structural correspondence with SMILES. The paper does not sufficiently explain why this task transfers better than more structurally aligned alternatives. Furthermore, the component-wise analyses suggest where transferable information resides but do not fully establish the underlying mechanism.

3. Limited Validation in the Full Training Pipeline

Much of the analysis is conducted without molecular pretraining, whereas the main contribution concerns transfer through a three-stage pipeline. It remains unclear whether the observed training-budget and component-wise effects generalize to the full setting.

Questions for authors

Please address the concerns raised in the Critical Weaknesses section, particularly regarding generalization across molecular tasks, the transfer mechanism of REVERSE, and the applicability of the analyses to the full training pipeline.

Reviewer_q6krOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The authors suggest to use "procedural pretraining" to improve the performance of models for property prediction applications.

This procedural pretraining are simple tasks that are not directly related to the property prediction task of interest, e.g. sequence reversal.

The authors suggest that this procedural pretraining could act as a form of inductive bias.

Critical strengths
  • Improving models for property prediction is clearly a relevant and important task. And it is especially relevant to do this in a way that does not require more labeled data that is hard to obtain in chemistry
  • It is interesting to analyze how very simple tasks could be an inductive bias. looking at he paper, it reminded me of work from Andrew Gordon Wilson's team that shows that LLMs by themselves have an inductive bias for simple sequences.
Critical weaknesses
  • I am worried that the effects the authors observe are due to a particular combination of settings: The authors reduce the datasets for SMILES pretraining quite a lot, but then scale up their pretraining quite a lot - and also highlight themselves that the effects from their technique are reduced with an addition of more SMILES. Thus, this makes me worried that this technique is somehow tested in a very artificial regime: For pretraining on SMILES, there is no real data limit.
  • To this, there comes a worry about the benchmarking. The authors use three datasets (freesolv, lipophilicity, QM9) which are sometimes used for benchmarking but are certainly not the gold standards in the field. And on those benchmarks, they need to show four decimal points to be able to quantify their effect. This makes me worried (as alluded to in the first point) that some of the effects might also be due to a very particular choice of benchmarking procedure
  • In addition, there is the problem that it is not clear how novel the approach in itself is. Other programmatic pretraining tasks have been explored before, for example in https://arxiv.org/abs/2602.04696. There, the tasks are more chemically inspired and there is not a second stage of pretraining - but it is philosophically the same approach with also broader evaluation
  • The fact that this procedural pretraining sometimes hursts is a very important thing to report - but it also makes the method much harder apply in practice (where one might not know a priori if this pretraining helps or hurts)
Questions for authors
  • Can you demonstrate that the method as a meaningful effect that is not linked to your model, evals, ... and can reliably transfer to other setups (or at least state clear limits of the domain of applicability)
Reviewer_hDrUOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper adds a procedural masked-token pretraining stage before conventional SMILES pretraining and molecular property fine-tuning. It tests five synthetic tasks with MoLFormer and reports its strongest full-pipeline result on Lipophilicity, where REVERSE reduces standardized MAE from 0.4083 to 0.3885.

Critical strengths

The controlled three-stage comparison keeps the molecular pretraining data and downstream protocol fixed. Reporting negative results, including the weak FreeSolv results, is useful.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The methodological novelty is limited. The core pipeline applies an existing idea, procedural pretraining, to an existing molecular encoder, MoLFormer, using the same masked-token objective across stages. I do not see a new learning objective, model architecture, or general procedure for choosing transferable tasks. The paper's related-work section already describes procedural transfer across other domains, so applying it to molecular prediction is primarily an empirical extension. That extension would need substantially broader and more reliable evidence to constitute a strong conference contribution.

  2. The full-pipeline gains are narrow. In Table 1, the clearest improvement is REVERSE on Lipophilicity (4.8%); the QM9-gap gain is 1.91%, and FreeSolv shows no clear benefit. Most analyses of training budget and attention versus feed-forward transfer use a two-stage setting that omits molecular pretraining. They therefore do not establish that the proposed explanations hold for the three-stage pipeline highlighted in the abstract.

  3. The evidence for the headline gain needs stronger controls. Procedural task complexity and training budget are selected over a sizable grid, while most results use only three seeds. The strongest REVERSE result lacks a matched shuffled-token control in the full pipeline. The comparison with the public MoLFormer checkpoint trained on roughly 100M molecules also cannot support a data-efficiency equivalence, because it is not a controlled molecular-data or compute scaling experiment. In Figure 4, some collapsed high-budget seeds are excluded from the plotted means, obscuring instability.

Questions for authors
  1. Can the authors report a full-pipeline shuffled-REVERSE control, paired seed-level uncertainty after configuration selection, and complete results including collapsed runs?

  2. Do the attention-transfer and training-budget findings persist in the full three-stage setting?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.