- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes GazeMixup, a feature-level augmentation method for cross-domain gaze estimation. Motivated by the observed relationship between feature magnitude and prediction error, the method separately interpolates feature direction and magnitude, and applies a similar strategy to gaze labels. GazeMixup introduces no additional trainable parameters or target-domain data. Experiments across four backbone architectures and four cross-domain settings report improvements over vanilla Mixup, with additional ablations examining feature geometry and label interpolation.
Critical strengths
1. Simple and practical design.
GazeMixup is a lightweight, parameter-free augmentation strategy that can be integrated into existing gaze estimation architectures without additional networks or target-domain data.
2. Consistent improvements over vanilla Mixup.
The method reports improvements over vanilla Mixup across four backbones and four cross-domain settings. The ablation studies also examine the contributions of feature and label interpolation.
Critical weaknesses
1. Potential inconsistency in the Error Stability (ES) metric.
Eq. 13 defines ES as the mean absolute difference of per-sample errors. However, all 24 ES values in Table 2 exactly match the absolute differences between aggregate MAEs. These are mathematically different quantities. This raises serious concerns about the correctness of the reported ES results and the corresponding claims of cross-domain stability.
2. The claimed feature–label consistency is not sufficiently justified.
GazeMixup computes feature and label interpolation coefficients independently from their respective norms, without establishing a relationship between them. Even for a linear regression head that perfectly fits the original samples, this can introduce additional residuals on mixed samples. The improvements may therefore arise from structured target perturbations rather than the proposed geometric consistency. Table 4 highlights the importance of this distinction, yet the paper lacks controlled experiments to isolate these effects.
3. The validity of arbitrary interpolation for gaze regression remains unclear.
Randomly mixing samples with substantially different gaze directions does not guarantee that the resulting feature corresponds to the interpolated label. Prior work such as C-Mixup (NeurIPS 2022) addresses this issue through label-aware sampling, but no such comparison is provided. Furthermore, the physical meaning of gaze-label magnitude is unclear, particularly if labels are represented as yaw–pitch angles rather than 3D unit vectors.
4. Weak baselines and insufficient statistical validation.
The reported GazeTR baseline (11.93°/12.87° on Gaze360 to MPIIFaceGaze/EyeDiap) is substantially worse than previously published results (7.96°/8.88°). Although evaluation protocols may differ, this discrepancy requires explanation. Moreover, several improvements over vanilla Mixup are only 0.1–0.4°, without results across independent training seeds. These issues weaken the evidence for consistent generalization improvements.
Questions for authors
1. Can the authors verify the ES calculation?
Why do all 24 ES values match the absolute differences between aggregate MAEs rather than the per-sample metric defined in Eq. 13?
2. Can the authors isolate the actual source of GazeMixup's improvements?
Please consider two controlled baselines: (a) standard linear feature–label Mixup at the same feature layer, and (b) matched target perturbation without the proposed feature interpolation. These would help distinguish geometric regularization from supervision perturbation.
3. What is the exact gaze-label representation?
Are labels yaw–pitch angles or 3D gaze vectors? What is the physical meaning of their magnitude, and how are zero norms handled? Have the authors considered spherical interpolation or gaze-angle-aware sample pairing?
4. Can the authors clarify the baseline discrepancies and statistical reliability?
Why is the reported GazeTR baseline substantially worse than published results? Please clarify the evaluation protocol and report performance across multiple independent training seeds.