- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies multi-view gaze estimation using PrismGaze, a dataset of over three million images that captures continuous head-pose variation for the same gaze targets. It proposes PrismFusion, which masks complementary image regions across views during training to encourage cross-view feature integration. The evaluation examines camera configuration, target location, viewing depth, and unseen viewpoints. The results suggest that well-positioned cameras can compensate for poorly observed views, while PrismFusion remains robust to depth changes and unseen viewpoints.
Critical strengths
This paper is easy to follow and well-written. The studied Multiview gaze estimation is an interesting and important problem.
Critical weaknesses
In this work, the authors claimed three contributions including one collected dataset, one multi-view feature fusion framework and one broader evaluation framework. Yet the above claimed contributions are insufficient for an acceptance of top-tier conferences with the following concerns. The first one is the collected dataset. The authors need to report the comparisons with the existing Multiview dataset such as Lian et al. 2019 published in TNNLS 2019. They need to report the comparisons in number of images, participants, to support their collected dataset’ advantages and necessity. The second one is the proposed method. The multi-view feature fusion framework might be lack of contributions and novelty, with an incremental combination of existing modules, such as shared encoder, cross-view fusion. They even used AI to draw the framework figure. The third contribution is the broader evaluation framework. However, the claimed evaluation framework is just ablation studies. It’s over-claimed.
Questions for authors
see weakness.
Since no response is provided, I keep my rating of reject.