- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper retains a pretrained cropped-face gaze expert as a source of privileged gaze knowledge and trains a full-frame model without explicit feature alignment.
Critical strengths
The paper addresses a useful deployment setting: removing face localization and cropping at inference without requiring target-domain gaze annotations. Transferring knowledge in gaze-output space avoids potentially inappropriate intermediate feature alignment between cropped-face and full-frame inputs.
Critical weaknesses
lack of novety. Experiments are not persuasive.
Questions for authors
- experiments setup are not clear to me, such as 'Source-only Expert', 'Teacher Pseudo Supervision'
- The methodological novelty needs sharper positioning.
5 comments
Thank you for your response. According to that, I have two more questions.
- How to ensure the comparison using PAT、G²D、MonoTAKD、SKD, are fair?
- When you distillize the student using teacher network, one import thing need to be clarify, which is the coordinates registration. The input of the teacher network is the croped face while the input of the student network is the full frame. Firstly, the coordinates registration will introduce errors. Secondly, the EyeDiap and LBW have different settings, the registrations are probably different.
Response to Reviewer u3Em
Thank you for raising these important questions.
1. Fairness of baseline comparisons.
PAT, G²D, MonoTAKD, and SKD are knowledge transfer strategies rather than specific backbone architectures, with different requirements for teacher-student compatibility. To ensure a controlled comparison, we adopt ResNet18 as the common visual backbone for all student models and use the same frozen pretrained gaze expert as the teacher. All methods are trained using identical datasets and data splits, on the same server, with the same number of epochs. We retain the default configurations of each method, with necessary adaptations to the crop-to-frame gaze estimation setting. This allows us to evaluate their respective knowledge transfer strategies under consistent backbone and training conditions.
2. Coordinate correspondence between teacher and student.
We clarify that our framework does not require explicit spatial registration between the cropped face and the full-frame image. The cropped face is extracted from the original frame using facial landmarks, while the student directly processes the corresponding full frame. Both observations are associated with the same gaze annotation, and the teacher and student predict gaze in the same yaw-pitch representation. Therefore, knowledge transfer is performed in the gaze space rather than through pixel-level or feature-level spatial alignment.
Furthermore, the datasets considered in this work provide gaze annotations based on their respective image coordinate systems. We directly use the provided annotations without introducing additional coordinate transformations between datasets. Consequently, no cross-dataset coordinate registration is required for the proposed knowledge transfer framework.
Response to Reviewer u3Em
We thank the reviewer for the constructive feedback. We further clarify the experimental settings, refine the positioning of our methodological contributions, and extend the evaluation to an independent target domain.
1. Clarification of experimental settings
We clarify the two baselines that were insufficiently described in the original manuscript.
Source-only Expert: This baseline directly evaluates the pretrained gaze expert on target-domain full-frame images without target-domain adaptation. It measures direct source-to-target transfer under the discrepancy between the teacher's cropped-face training input and full-frame evaluation input. Its LBW error is 23.43°.
Teacher Pseudo Supervision: The frozen teacher generates gaze pseudo-labels from cropped-face images of unlabeled target-domain samples. A student is then trained using corresponding full-frame images and pseudo-label regression only, without the additional relational, sensitivity, consistency, and anti-collapse objectives. Its LBW error is 17.66°.
The teacher itself obtains 16.92° when evaluated on cropped-face images. This differs from the 23.43° full-frame Source-only Expert result because the input conditions are different.
2. Methodological contribution
Our contribution is a task-specific framework for transferring gaze knowledge from a cropped-face expert to a full-frame student under asymmetric input conditions, without target-domain gaze annotations or face cropping at inference.
The framework transfers complementary knowledge through three levels: confidence-aware sample-level prediction guidance, relational transfer that preserves pairwise gaze geometry, and sensitivity transfer that captures teacher-response changes under appearance degradation. Full-frame consistency and anti-collapse regularization further constrain student learning.
The LBW ablation results demonstrate the contribution of this coordinated design:
These results demonstrate the contributions of the individual combinations and their joint optimization. The complete framework achieves 11.25°, transferring structured gaze knowledge across different input representations without explicitly aligning intermediate teacher and student features.
3. Additional cross-dataset evaluation
We introduce EyeDiap as an independent target domain with different camera positions and a smaller facial area proportion in full-frame images. HD RGB full frames are used as student inputs, while corresponding cropped faces provide privileged observations to the frozen teacher during training.
We adopt four-fold subject-independent cross-validation, using three folds for unlabeled knowledge transfer and one fold for evaluation. The same LBW-established hyperparameter configuration is applied to all EyeDiap folds without dataset-specific adjustment.
Our method achieves 13.48° on EyeDiap, outperforming the strongest transfer baseline, G²D (16.55°), by 3.07°, corresponding to an 18.55% relative error reduction. The method maintains the lowest error across both datasets despite changes in camera positions and facial area proportions. The results also demonstrate the transferability of the LBW-established configuration while retaining full-frame-only inference.