- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates the potential undercounting problem caused by embedded occluders in crowd-counting datasets. The authors categorize occlusions into three types: atmospheric, barrier, and embedded occlusions. The proposed framework separately predicts human and occluder density maps, estimates the density of people potentially hidden behind occluders, and integrates these representations to obtain the final crowd count. The problem is interesting, but several aspects remain unclear.
Critical strengths
The paper provides a comprehensive solution including problem identification, model development, corrected ground-truth annotations, and the construction of a dedicated occlusion-aware dataset.
Critical weaknesses
-
If the original benchmark annotations count only identifiable or visible heads, introducing estimates for fully occluded people changes the prediction target rather than correcting annotation errors. The authors should more clearly justify why such hidden individuals should be included in the ground-truth count and explain how comparisons with existing crowd-counting methods remain fair under this modified target definition.
-
The proposed model primarily considers umbrellas and picket signs as embedded occluders. However, other common occluders in crowded scenes, such as flags, banners, boards, are not evaluated.
-
The presence of an occluder does not necessarily imply that people are hidden behind it. It is therefore unclear whether the model tends to predict hidden people whenever such occluders are present. For example, would an image containing a sign but no person behind it lead to a nonzero hidden-human density or an overestimated crowd count? Additional analysis or controlled experiments would help clarify this behavior.
-
The computational cost of the proposed method is not reported. In addition, it is unclear whether the method is restricted to (512*512) inputs.
Questions for authors
Minor: The roles of S_b and C_b in reconstructing the density map should be explained more clearly. The manuscript should also specify how the different predicted density maps are fused to produce the final output.
In Figure 2, the values 228.4 and 24.4 are reported together with a final count of 263.7. However, the relationship among these values is unclear, since the first two values do not directly sum to the reported final count. The authors should explicitly explain how the final count is computed.