- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces Group-Individual Object Counting (GIC), a task that requires models to count either individual objects or semantic groups according to the specified counting unit. To facilitate research on this task, the authors construct BunchCount, a benchmark containing 1,330 images with paired individual- and group-level annotations and explicit group-individual containment relations.
The authors further propose GICount, a framework built upon CountGD that incorporates counting-unit prompt decomposition and relation-based supervision. Specifically, it constructs positive and negative sets of individual queries based on annotated group membership, aggregates their representations using a Transformer, and aligns them with group-structure semantics through a contrastive objective. Experiments demonstrate improved group-level counting performance while maintaining competitive individual-level counting accuracy.
Critical strengths
The paper identifies an interesting aspect of visual counting by distinguishing between individual instances and semantic groups. BunchCount provides paired annotations and explicit containment relations, making it a potentially valuable benchmark for investigating counting across different semantic units.
Critical weaknesses
The proposed method largely extends CountGD, which does not appear to introduce a substantially new mechanism for group-individual counting.
The reported improvement in group counting is overwhelmingly concentrated in the fixed-cardinality subset, where the MAE decreases from 58.22 to 8.11. Improvements in the remaining group structures are relatively modest, and performance even slightly deteriorates for spatial aggregation.
Questions for authors
Why is the overall improvement primarily driven by the fixed-cardinality subset?
Can the method generalize to previously unseen group structures, rather than only unseen object categories?
2 comments
Thank you again for your comments. Our rebuttal presents further analyses of relation modeling and the gains on fixed-cardinality groups, together with a new structure-holdout experiment evaluating generalization to unseen group structures. As the discussion period is nearing its end, we would appreciate your assessment of whether these results address your concerns. Please let us know if any points require further clarification.
Thank you for recognizing the value of the task and benchmark. Below, we address the methodological contribution, the gains on fixed cardinality, and generalization to unseen organizational forms.
Response to Weakness 1: Methodological contribution
GICount adds explicit group–individual relation supervision to the CountGD backbone. We choose CountGD for its strong counting performance. We introduce a relation module that aligns instance combinations with counting-unit semantics using annotated group-individual containment relations (§5.2–5.3 and Figure 4). The ablations in Table 2 directly evaluate this design.
Relation supervision strengthens group recognition, while the counting-unit prompt enables this supervision to improve both individual and group counting. The full model adds only 1.1% parameters, and the relation module is used only during training (§5 and Table 2; Appendix D).
Response to Weakness 2: & Question 1: Gains on fixed cardinality
The aggregate gain is dominated by fixed-cardinality groups, where jointly trained CountGD incurs exceptionally large errors. Fixed-cardinality groups form a whole through a conventional or functional number of constituent instances, such as a pair of shoes or two lenses forming a pair of sunglasses (Appendix A.2). Such groups are defined by semantic pairings or combinations, rather than by spatial proximity or a shared boundary. Existing counting methods do not explicitly model these group-unit semantics, making fixed cardinality a challenging test of counting-unit understanding. Appendix Table 4 reports results for the four structures. We add GroundingREC results below; each entry reports group-level Test MAE / RMSE:
Both baselines incur their largest errors on fixed cardinality. Supervision from group-individual relations teaches GICount how constituent instances form counting units, and its substantial improvement on this subset reflects a better semantic understanding of group counting units. On the other three group structures, GICount also achieves substantial relative improvements or remains competitive, demonstrating the value of relation modeling across different group structures.
Response to Question 2: Generalization to unseen organizational forms
GICount’s gains extend to organizational forms excluded from BunchCount training. We hold out 9 organizational forms: strings and bracelets (physical connection); baskets, bowls, and buckets (spatial aggregation); sets (fixed cardinality); and rows, columns, and lines (structural arrangement). This yields 1,032 training images and 298 test images; both models use the original initialization and train for 20 epochs.
GICount improves both group and individual counting on organizational forms unseen during training, showing that the group representations learned through relation supervision can transfer to new organizational forms.
Thank you again for your constructive feedback and for recognizing the value of our work. We are happy to address any remaining questions or concerns.