- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper addresses text-guided object counting by transporting dense probes toward object-centered semantic confluences, followed by crowding-adaptive DPP enumeration. The method combines SAM3-based grounding, learned probe dynamics, and point-supervised training. Experiments are conducted on CLOC-v1.1, KubriCount, and MixCount to evaluate the proposed method.
Critical strengths
- The motivation is reasonable and clear. Separating evidence grouping from enumeration provides a coherent approach to duplicate suppression, and DPP offers a mechanism for balancing competition and coexistence among nearby probes.
- The proposed method achieves outstanding counting performance.
- The authors provide diagnostic analyses, including per-object inclusion mass, probe contraction, explicit dense-scene failure analysis, and informative investigation of probe-resolution limitations.
Critical weaknesses
- Some results contradict the metric definition. For instance, the values of NAE and SNAE(2) of ConfluxCount on NWPU-VHR-10 in tab. 10 seem to violate according to Appendix A.1. The authors are recommended to verify these values and clarify whether global and spatial metrics are computed consistently.
- The pure-shared DPP ablation appears inconsistent with the stated parameterization. Under the 64-rank setting in Appendix A.3, setting yields , implying . Using the count-bin minima and test-sample frequencies in fig. 8, the conservative full-test MAE lower bound is approximately 12.26, exceeding 6.89 reported in tab. 6. Does this ablation retain a nonzero diagonal component, change the factor rank, or use a different evaluation protocol? Otherwise, the reported result is incompatible with the stated formulation.
- The native DPP localization readout shows limited practical advantage. With the model and predicted count fixed, tab. 7 shows that greedy DPP underperforms marginal-ranked NMS in F1, R@8, and GAME1, matching the localization error. This may limit the demonstrated benefit of the proposed localization decoder.
- The training protocol underlying the headline results is insufficiently documented. (1) The main tables use joint training, whereas Appendix A details the CLOC-only recipe. The authors are encouraged to provide exact training splits, dataset-mixing ratios, and the joint optimization schedule. Although the CLOC-only results provide a useful control, comparisons on matched training data would better isolate methodological gains on the supporting benchmarks. (2) Appendix B.3 attributes mismatch robustness partly to empty-set supervision, but the construction, sampling frequency, and loss treatment of mismatched training pairs are unspecified; the in-batch contrastive objective alone does not establish this supervision.
- Canonical-probe coverage introduces an unquantified supervision bottleneck. Appendix A.3 allows GT objects with empty probe Voronoi cells to lack a canonical representative for both the DPP and coverage losses. Consequently, the exact-set likelihood may favor a target of size , while the count loss still targets the full count . This potential supervision mismatch may contribute to dense-scene undercounting. Reporting the uncovered GT fraction across local densities and lattice resolutions, alongside density-stratified per-object inclusion mass, would help distinguish supervision limitations from inference capacity.
- The paper involves numerous components, including semantic flow, instance memory, basin pyramid field, probe dynamics, a crowding gate, DPP, and multiple loss functions. The main text is dense with exposition and notation, and is difficult for readers to quickly identify which components or designs are truly essential.
Questions for authors
Please refer to the weaknesses above.