- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 1(−1)
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes a learning-to-test framework to verify the stability of dynamical systems. The goal is to remove the expensive re-simulations and provide efficient stability criteria. A theoretical framework is also provided for the statistical test in the latent representation space.
Critical strengths
The idea is well-motivated to take the place of the expensive DAE simulations for stability analysis. The theory is also provided. The whole framework seems doable in some test cases.
Critical weaknesses
The first concern is about the connection to the classic stability definition in dynamical systems. The author's definition is not well recognized in the dynamical system domain. The second concern is about the effectiveness of uniform regularization and the guarantee of the invariance assumption.
Questions for authors
- In Fig. 1, the author said that under stable regime, the learned latent representation is approximately uniform. Any explanations?
- One concern is that the authors should first explain how their stability definition relates to classical stability theory for dynamical systems, including Lyapunov and asymptotic stability. Definitions 1 and 2 characterize finite-horizon chance-constraint satisfaction, which is not generally equivalent to these classical notions. Without a clearer connection, it is difficult to see what the proposed theory contributes to dynamical-system stability analysis.
- The quality of Fig. 2 needs to be improved. Some texts/formula are grey and hard to clearly identify. It’s also not easy to capture the main flow.
- The role of uniformity regularization is questionable since it does not guarantee uniformity always holds. The implemented test uses an empirical reference.
- The validity guarantee relies on class-conditional latent invariance, which the training objective does not enforce.
- The tests systems are insufficient. More realistic cases may need to be considered. Sensitivity with respect to the hyper-parameters should also be considered.