- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper argues that there are regime changes that standard monitors working with means and variances do not detect. Then, the authors propose a methodology and show that it does not work.
Critical strengths
None.
Critical weaknesses
This paper is exceptionally hard to follow. Is the paper trying to argue that current monitors are insufficient because there are meaningful situations in which regime changes are not detected? If so, the paper needs a substantial narrative change, focus on diagnosing why and evaluating it on a large selection of such monitors. If the paper is instead proposing a new methodology (F-JEPA-RD?), it should show its effectiveness. However, by the authors' own admission, this method does not work. So why should a reader care about it?
Overall, this manuscript feels like an AI generated running draft/experimental notebook (Tables 32,33 are really emblematic) and it does not meet the bar for publication, especially in a venue like ICLR.
Questions for authors
None.
2 comments
I appreciate the authors' efforts to make the manuscript more readable. I am now more convinced that the general direction has some merit.
However, in the current form, I don't think that the work is ready for publication. Despite the efforts, I still find it very difficult to read, and it still feels like an AI-generated manuscript with occasional clarity.
I encourage the authors to consider a rewrite focusing on the main points that they would like a reader to take home, and to simplify the main text and the appendix, without the usual <statement><result><caveat> form, as it often obscures the actual point.
Response to Reviewer qq4K
Insufficient monitors, or a new method? Both, as the contribution list states (p.3 l.110-129). The paper argues that monitors watching residual energy miss a class of changes. It then evaluates nine monitors under a corrected protocol, and diagnoses why they fail:
The revision adds the multi-seed evidence for C5 (Appendix Z). On the same one-step code innovation, the energy statistic stays at 0.117 and the shape statistic of Prop. 4 reaches 0.375. The paper's own readouts sit at chance because the predictor's residuals they read dilute the fourth-moment signature.
Readability and Tables 32/33. We agree the manuscript was hard to read; see the Summary of Revisions. Table 33 lists the six design predictions, each with its outcome; it is kept because the drift-robust rules of the main text are post hoc (Section 5; Appendix T, p.34 l.1805-1810). Table 32 is a reported negative result on public data. Both are condensed in the revision.