acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

LEARNING RELIABLE ADAPTIVE REGION-OFATTRACTION REPRESENTATIONS FOR NONLINEAR DYNAMICAL SYSTEMS

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Learning regions of attraction (RoAs) of nonlinear dynamical systems remains challenging because existing approaches often rely on a single global representation, creating a tradeoff between expressiveness, constructability, and scalability. Moreover, many practically relevant controllers are designed or learned primarily for control performance rather than jointly with an RoA certificate, motivating post-training RoA analysis without modifying the given controller. We propose a hybrid framework that learns and represents the RoA through complementary local components. A quadratic Lyapunov representation derived from closed-loop linearization is refined under the nonlinear dynamics to obtain a trusted local core. Starting from this core, the framework learns convergent states, lifts them into continuous regions through locally validated geometric representations, and augments residual regions using flow-informed patches. The resulting hybrid representation is independently evaluated through finite-sample boundedness and reach-to-core validation, providing explicit statistical reliability without requiring the RoA to conform to a single global certificate. The framework applies to fixed closed-loop nonlinear systems, requires no controller retraining or certificate-aware controller synthesis, and is independent of the controller representation. Experiments on CartPole and six-dimensional quadrotor systems demonstrate substantial expansion beyond the trusted local core while establishing 99.9% reliability at 99.9% confidence.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
Region of attraction, nonlinear systems, Lyapunov methods, reachability analysis, representation learning, statistical validation, closed-loop systems

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_syFYOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes a sampling-based pipeline for estimating the region of attraction (RoA) of a fixed closed-loop system, applied to small neural controllers on CartPole (4D) and quadrotor attitude (6D). A quadratic Lyapunov function from the linearization gives a small seed set, which is enlarged into a "trusted core" by checking that boundary samples reach the seed within a horizon. Convergent states found by uniform or pullback sampling are covered with Euclidean balls or ellipsoids, plus flow-based patches for the leftovers. A patch is kept if a Clopper–Pearson bound on its rollout failure rate is below 1%. The final union is validated on 8,192 fresh samples from the added region (zero failures, bound 8.43×10−48.43\times10^{-4} at 99.9% confidence). The represented region is 7.8× (CartPole) and 6.0× (quadrotor) the core's volume within the DoI, and random sampling with balls gives the largest region on both systems.

Critical strengths
  1. The setting is practical. Analyzing a given controller after training, without retraining it or assuming a particular controller structure, is often what is needed in practice, and the reach-to-core idea is simple and works with any simulator.

  2. The final statistical check is done properly: the validation samples are independent of seed learning and patch construction, the reported bound is correct (1−0.0011/8192≈8.43×10−41-0.001^{1/8192}\approx 8.43\times10^{-4}), and the authors are upfront that this is not a formal certificate. The 2×2 ablation showing that seed coverage does not predict represented volume is a useful observation.

Critical weaknesses
  1. There are no baselines and no ground truth, so the results can't be judged. The only reference point is the authors' own quadratic core. We don't know whether 16.45% of the CartPole DoI is most of the true RoA or a small part of it; since the controller was trained on this DoI, I would expect much of it to converge. This is cheap to check: uniform rollouts over the DoI (200,000 were already run for random exploration) give a Monte Carlo estimate of the RoA volume, and the method's region should be reported as a fraction of it. Comparisons under the same final validation are also needed, e.g., the largest V0V_0 sublevel set that passes the same reach-to-core test, a classifier (kNN or a small MLP) trained on the rollout labels, and a post-hoc neural Lyapunov/Zubov method for a fixed system (e.g., Liu et al. 2025, which the paper cites). The learning contribution is also thin for ICLR: the pipeline is a set of sampling and covering heuristics, and the representation is a union of roughly 1,400 balls that does not generalize beyond the sampled seeds.

  2. The reliability claim is weaker than it reads. (a) Everything depends on Ω^0\hat\Omega_0 lying inside the RoA, yet the core is checked only on its boundary (4,000 + 8,192 boundary rollouts reaching Ωseed\Omega_{seed}, which in turn is checked only by sampled boundary decrease). Interior points of the core are never tested, and the final validation samples only the added region. For the quadrotor, c0/cseed≈402c_0/c_{seed}\approx 402, so the core is about 20× the radius of the part with any Lyapunov evidence. (b) The "99.9% at 99.9% confidence" figure is simply the zero-failure Clopper–Pearson bound for n=8192n=8192. It is identical for every configuration and only says that the failure volume under uniform sampling of the added region is below about 0.08%; thin failure sets inside accepted patches would go unnoticed. (c) Fig. 2(e) appears to show accepted quadrotor patches extending to ∣θ∣≈2.5|\theta|\approx 2.5 rad, beyond ±π/2\pm\pi/2 where the Euler kinematics in Eq. (21) are singular and far outside the DoI (∣θ∣≤0.35|\theta|\le 0.35), so part of the "validated" region is where the model is not well defined.

  3. each configuration is run once, so rankings such as random–ball vs. random–ellipsoid (16.45% vs. 13.48%) may not be robust, and on the quadrotor the better geometry flips with the seed strategy (pullback: ellipsoid 68.5% vs. ball 27.6%). The flow layer, presented as a main component, adds 0.0009% of the CartPole DoI (about 9 of the 2202^{20} volume samples) and 0.2% on the quadrotor. The appendix algorithms are too high-level to reproduce: quantile levels, neighborhood sizes, per-patch sample counts, coverage targets, and patch budgets are not given. Fig. 2 is hard to read, and its caption calls the plots slices while Sec. 4.1 calls them projections.

Questions for authors
  1. What fraction of the DoI is in the RoA according to brute-force Monte Carlo, and what fraction of that does R^\hat{\mathcal R} cover? How does the method compare with the simple baselines above under the same validation?
  2. How do you justify that every interior point of Ω^0\hat\Omega_0 converges? Did you test any interior samples of the core?
  3. Do accepted quadrotor patches contain states with ∣θ∣≥π/2|\theta|\ge\pi/2? If so, how are they handled in simulation, and do the volume and validation numbers change when they are excluded?
  4. How much do the occupancy numbers and the ranking of the four configurations vary across random seeds?
  5. What is the total cost of the full pipeline (number of rollouts and wall-clock time), not just seed discovery?

Suggestion for future work (not required here): a study of how the number of patches and rollouts grows with state dimension would show whether ball covering remains viable beyond 6D.

Reviewer_dwE9OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes a sampling-based framework for estimating the region of attraction (RoA) of a fixed nonlinear closed-loop system. The method first constructs a local quadratic Lyapunov core, expands it through trajectory-based reachability tests, and then represents additional convergent regions using geometric and flow-informed patches. Statistical validation is used to assess the reliability of the resulting representation. Experiments are conducted on CartPole and a six-dimensional quadrotor attitude-control system.

Critical strengths

Strengths

  1. The problem of estimating the RoA of an already trained controller is practically relevant, and the proposed framework does not require modifying the controller.

  2. The paper is generally clear and provides detailed implementation descriptions. The ablation studies are useful for understanding the effects of the different components.

Critical weaknesses

Weaknesses

  1. My main concern is that the proposed framework relies almost entirely on trajectory sampling and empirical validation. The local core is expanded through sampled rollout tests, while the outer RoA is constructed by identifying convergent initial conditions, fitting geometric patches, and validating them through further sampling. Although these are reasonable components, it is unclear what new methodological insight the framework provides beyond combining existing sampling-based techniques and standard statistical confidence bounds. This concern is reinforced by the ablation results, where the simplest configuration based on random sampling and Euclidean balls achieves the largest represented regions, while the more elaborate pullback and flow-informed components provide limited benefits to the final coverage. I would encourage the authors to clarify the core algorithmic contribution and demonstrate its advantages over simpler simulation-based RoA estimation approaches.

  2. The local Lyapunov core is constructed through sampled decrease tests and boundary rollouts, rather than formal verification of the entire region. The subsequent expansion and final validation also rely on finite-horizon reach-to-core tests. Although the authors acknowledge that the guarantees are statistical rather than formal, I think the relationship between these tests and actual asymptotic convergence deserves more careful discussion. In particular, how is the reliability of the initial core established beyond the sampled boundary states? Since the outer-region validation depends on reaching this core, uncertainty about the core itself seems important when interpreting the final RoA reliability claims.

  3. The experiments show that adaptive pullback exploration finds convergent seeds more efficiently, but random sampling with Euclidean-ball representations consistently produces the largest final regions. Moreover, the flow-informed refinement contributes very little additional volume in either benchmark. These results raise the question of whether the more elaborate components provide sufficient benefits over a simpler approach based on random sampling, local balls, and statistical validation. A clearer discussion of when pullback exploration or flow-informed patches are expected to be advantageous would strengthen the paper.

  4. The method requires extensive trajectory simulations and statistical screening of numerous patches. While seed-discovery times are reported, the end-to-end computational cost of constructing and validating the complete RoA representation is unclear. Reporting total runtime, rollout counts, and represented volume versus computational budget would help assess the method's efficiency. The evaluation is also limited to four- and six-dimensional systems.

Questions for authors
  1. Can the authors clarify how the reliability of the local core supports the final claims about RoA membership, given that its construction relies on sampled boundary tests?

  2. How does the proposed framework compare with existing simulation- or trajectory-based RoA estimators under similar computational budgets?

  3. Could the authors report the complete runtime and explain the practical benefit of the flow-informed stage, given its relatively small contribution to the final represented volume?

Reviewer_hSqpOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes a post-training framework for representing the region of attraction (RoA) of fixed nonlinear closed-loop systems without modifying their controllers. It initializes a quadratic Lyapunov representation from the closed-loop linearization, refines a local core through sampled nonlinear decrease and reachability tests, and learns outer regions using convergent trajectory seeds. Random and pullback-guided exploration are combined with ball or ellipsoidal patches and flow-informed residual refinement. Patch screening and independent validation employ one-sided Clopper–Pearson bounds.

On simulated four-dimensional CartPole and six-dimensional quadrotor attitude systems, the selected random–ball configurations achieve DoI occupancies of 16.4492% and 78.68%, respectively, substantially exceeding their local cores. All 8,192 independent validation samples from each selected newly added region successfully reach the core within the prescribed horizon. The reported reliability is statistical and trajectory-based rather than a formal set-wise stability certificate.

Critical strengths
  1. A practical post-training formulation with complementary local representations.

    The method addresses an important setting in which a controller is already fixed and certificate-aware retraining is undesirable. Separating convergent-seed discovery from continuous-region construction is conceptually useful, while the reach-to-core formulation provides a common validation criterion across the different patch types. This modularity potentially offers a practical alternative to fitting a single global certificate, particularly for nonlinear neural feedback systems.

  2. Substantial measured expansion with informative internal ablations.

    The selected hybrid representations achieve 7.82× and approximately 6.00× the trusted-core DoI volume on CartPole and quadrotor, respectively (Tables 6 and 9). Independent validation is performed after representation construction, and all 8,192 sampled states in each selected newly added region satisfy the bounded reach-to-core criterion. Tables 4 and 8 also reveal a meaningful trade-off: pullback discovers seeds more efficiently, while random–ball yields the largest represented volume among the evaluated configurations.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The attracting-core assumption is not sufficiently established for the claimed RoA reliability.

    The reach-to-core argument in Section 2.3 requires the target core to lie within the true RoA. However, Algorithm 1 constructs the Lyapunov seed using sampled decrease tests on a sublevel-set boundary, then enlarges and validates the recovered core primarily through sampled boundary trajectories (Appendices B.3 and C.3). These procedures do not establish decrease, invariance, or eventual convergence throughout the complete seed or recovered core. Consequently, the 8,192/8,192 successes in Tables 6 and 9 establish statistical reliability for bounded finite-horizon entry into an empirically chosen core, not directly for asymptotic convergence from the represented region. This does not invalidate Lemma 1 as a statement about the specified event, but it leaves a consequential gap between the tested event and an RoA guarantee. Establishing a genuinely attracting local core, or appropriately narrowing the reliability claim, would materially strengthen the paper.

  2. The experiments do not establish the advantage of the hybrid representation over simpler or cost-matched alternatives.

    Tables 4 and 8 provide the full internal 2×2 comparison, but no direct post-training RoA baseline or independent reference estimate of the actual RoA is reported. More importantly, the flow-informed stage adds only 0.0009 percentage points of DoI occupancy on CartPole (16.4483% to 16.4492%) and approximately 0.20 points on quadrotor (78.48% to 78.68%). Thus, most measured expansion comes from the geometry layer, leaving the incremental benefit of the proposed hybridization unclear. The seed-discovery times also differ substantially between random and pullback exploration: 577.5 versus 160.4 seconds on CartPole and 2,298.0 versus 461.1 seconds on quadrotor. Without matched computational budgets and end-to-end costs, the volume comparison does not establish overall efficiency. A cost-matched geometry-only or trajectory-based baseline would substantially improve the evidence for the paper's contribution.

Questions for authors
  1. The attracting-core assumption is not sufficiently established for the claimed RoA reliability.

    The reach-to-core argument in Section 2.3 requires the target core to lie within the true RoA. However, Algorithm 1 constructs the Lyapunov seed using sampled decrease tests on a sublevel-set boundary, then enlarges and validates the recovered core primarily through sampled boundary trajectories (Appendices B.3 and C.3). These procedures do not establish decrease, invariance, or eventual convergence throughout the complete seed or recovered core. Consequently, the 8,192/8,192 successes in Tables 6 and 9 establish statistical reliability for bounded finite-horizon entry into an empirically chosen core, not directly for asymptotic convergence from the represented region. This does not invalidate Lemma 1 as a statement about the specified event, but it leaves a consequential gap between the tested event and an RoA guarantee. Establishing a genuinely attracting local core, or appropriately narrowing the reliability claim, would materially strengthen the paper.

  2. The experiments do not establish the advantage of the hybrid representation over simpler or cost-matched alternatives.

    Tables 4 and 8 provide the full internal 2×2 comparison, but no direct post-training RoA baseline or independent reference estimate of the actual RoA is reported. More importantly, the flow-informed stage adds only 0.0009 percentage points of DoI occupancy on CartPole (16.4483% to 16.4492%) and approximately 0.20 points on quadrotor (78.48% to 78.68%). Thus, most measured expansion comes from the geometry layer, leaving the incremental benefit of the proposed hybridization unclear. The seed-discovery times also differ substantially between random and pullback exploration: 577.5 versus 160.4 seconds on CartPole and 2,298.0 versus 461.1 seconds on quadrotor. Without matched computational budgets and end-to-end costs, the volume comparison does not establish overall efficiency. A cost-matched geometry-only or trajectory-based baseline would substantially improve the evidence for the paper's contribution.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.