- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes SkillAdm, an oracle-free framework for online test-time skill learning in frozen LLM agents. It uses verified environment knowledge and task-specific, progress-aware rubrics to guide skill distillation, followed by admission through validation on constructed skill-specific tasks and independent verification on relevant future tasks. The evaluation covers three benchmarks and three LLM backbones, with analyses of admission quality, rubric design, and cross-backbone skill transfer.
Critical strengths
- The paper highlights an important limitation of existing validation task pools. As discussed in Appendix A.2 and Introduction, source tasks, historical tasks, and fixed validation pools may provide limited coverage of the capability targeted by a candidate skill. Constructing executable, skill-specific validation tasks is a useful response to this limitation. This perspective is particularly relevant to continual learning, where historical tasks may also become unavailable.
- The empirical analysis examines both overall performance and the mechanisms underlying skill admission. The component ablations and rubric comparisons provide evidence for the benefits of verified environment knowledge, progress-aware evaluation, and the significance criterion. The appendix further illustrates the distillation and admission pipeline through a concrete case study, while the cross-backbone experiments support the transferability of the learned skills.
Critical weaknesses
The methodological novelty appears limited relative to the integration of established components. Hypothesis-driven exploration appears conceptually related to curiosity-driven exploration, while LLM-based scoring and contrastive distillation resemble established ideas in LLM evaluation and preference learning, including RLHF/RLAIF. Section 2.3 also explicitly builds on prior contrastive skill distillation. Although the distinction between constructed skill-specific validation and independent future-task verification is useful and empirically supported, I am not yet convinced that this decomposition constitutes a substantial methodological advance beyond combining and adapting existing ideas.
Questions for authors
- Rubric construction and prompting. Section 2.3 describes the rubric structure, and Appendix D/Table 5 provides an example. Could the authors provide the actual prompt or template used by the Judge to generate these rubrics, including the required inputs, constraints on criterion construction, and output schema? This would clarify how the illustrated rubric is produced reproducibly.
- Performance relative to oracle-assisted baselines. In the settings where SkillAdm outperforms GRASP and HDSO in Table 1, what accounts for the advantage despite their access to ground-truth outcomes? In particular, how should these gains be attributed to progress-aware evaluation versus differences in skill generation, validation tasks, and admission procedures?
- Outcome matching and robustness in knowledge validation. In Section 2.2, how is an observed transition determined to “exhibit” the expected outcome or the contradictory outcome ? Is this based on exact matching, semantic judgment, or another operational criterion? How are partially matching or ambiguous observations handled, and how robust is the supporting/refuting classification to observation noise or judgment errors?
5 comments
Response to Reviewer YQ6B (2/2)
Q2: Performance improvements and attribution to individual components.
Thank you for raising this important question. We attribute SkillAdm's performance gains to two key contributions: task-specific, progress-aware rubrics and a two-stage skill admission mechanism.
First, regarding the underlying mechanism, access to ground-truth outcomes provides reliable task-level feedback, but does not necessarily ensure that the validation tasks adequately assess a candidate skill's intended capability. Existing oracle-assisted methods such as GRASP and HDSO rely on historical tasks or pre-allocated validation pools, which may not sufficiently exercise the capability targeted by each skill. In contrast, SkillAdm constructs skill-specific validation tasks to directly assess candidate utility and further verifies whether this utility transfers to relevant future tasks. Meanwhile, progress-aware rubrics capture intermediate task progress and final goal completion, providing fine-grained evaluation signals even without oracle access. These mechanisms help SkillAdm outperforming methods with access to ground-truth outcomes.
Second, regarding experimental evidence, we conduct controlled ablation experiments to examine the contributions of these components. Table 3 (Section 4.2) reports the relevant results.
| Variant | ALFWorld | ScienceWorld | BabyAI |
|---|---|---|---|
| Full | 78.47 | 32.16 | 22.00 |
| w/o-Rubric | 74.09 ↓ 4.38 | 30.18 ↓ 1.98 | 20.50 ↓ 1.50 |
| w/o-SkillVal. | 72.99 ↓ 5.48 | 26.70 ↓ 5.46 | 19.00 ↓ 3.00 |
| w/o-FutVerif. | 67.88 ↓ 10.59 | 27.36 ↓ 4.80 | 20.50 ↓ 1.50 |
| w/o-BothVerif. | 61.31 ↓ 17.16 | 23.19 ↓ 8.97 | 16.75 ↓ 5.25 |
Removing rubric-based evaluation consistently reduces task performance, while Table 4 (Section 4.4) further demonstrates that progress-aware rubrics achieve better alignment with official benchmark outcomes than Direct-Judge and Goal-Only evaluation. Moreover, removing either admission stage degrades performance, with the largest declines occurring when both stages are removed. These results support the contributions of progress-aware evaluation and two-stage skill admission to SkillAdm's effectiveness.
Q3: Outcome matching and robustness in environment knowledge validation.
Thank you for this question. We have provided the detailed evidence assessment procedure in Appendix A and the corresponding Explorer prompt and output schema in Appendix D.2.
First, outcome matching. For each record that directly tests a hypothesis, the Explorer checks whether the initial observation matches the hypothesis context, whether the expected outcome was absent before the action, and whether the environment successfully executed the proposed action. Only after these conditions are satisfied does the Explorer compare the resulting observation with the expected and contradictory outcomes specified by the hypothesis. Specifically, these assessments rely on LLM-based semantic judgments.
Second, ambiguous observations. Each evidence record is classified as supporting, refuting, or inconclusive. A record is supporting only when the observation explicitly demonstrates the expected outcome, and refuting only when it explicitly demonstrates the contradictory outcome under valid test conditions. Partially matching, ambiguous, or insufficient observations are classified as inconclusive rather than being treated as positive or negative evidence. The Explorer prompt requires the judgments to be grounded in observations before and after the action.
Thank you for the clarifications and additional evidence. I find the clarified methodological contribution acceptable and appreciate the general task-construction guidance in Appendix D.8. The component ablations and rubric-evaluation results sufficiently address my concerns about the utility of the proposed designs: both admission stages contribute to performance, and progress-aware rubrics improve alignment with benchmark outcomes, particularly intermediate progress in ScienceWorld.
My remaining questions concern implementation and reliability. Could the authors provide concrete task-construction and feasibility-checking procedures for ScienceWorld and BabyAI, including how generated objectives and initial states are instantiated and how goal reachability is checked? It would also be helpful to outline practical principles for adapting this procedure to a new environment, including the required environment capabilities and any environment-specific components. Finally, while the semantic matching rules and treatment of ambiguous evidence are now clearer, quantitative robustness evidence would strengthen the response—for example, supporting/refuting/inconclusive classification accuracy and repeated-judgment consistency under observation noise, paraphrasing, and incomplete or ambiguous observations.
Response to Reviewer YQ6B (1/2)
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the careful evaluation and constructive feedback. We appreciate the recognition of our motivation and experimental analysis. We hope the following responses clarify our methodological contributions and implementation details.
Thank you for raising this concern. We acknowledge that some individual components of SkillAdm are related to established ideas in prior research. However, our contribution goes beyond combining existing techniques: we address two fundamental challenges in skill admission, namely, reliable utility assessment without oracle outcomes and skill validation beyond existing task pools. Our methodological contributions are as follows
First, task-specific, progress-aware rubrics. Unlike direct LLM correctness judgments, our task-specific rubrics evaluate both intermediate task progress and final goal completion, rather than relying solely on binary correctness judgments. They are constructed from task specifications, initial observations, and verified environment knowledge, providing fine-grained evaluation signals without official outcomes. As shown in Table 4 (Section 4.4), our rubric design substantially improves alignment with official benchmark outcomes, achieving gains of 9.67, 16.33, and 10.87 percentage points in pairwise accuracy over direct LLM judgment on ALFWorld, ScienceWorld, and BabyAI, respectively.
Second, skill-specific validation task construction. Unlike existing methods that rely on source tasks, historical tasks, or pre-allocated validation pools, SkillAdm constructs executable validation tasks tailored to each candidate skill using its description, supporting trajectory evidence, and verified environment knowledge. This enables direct assessment of skill utility in scenarios designed to exercise the skill’s intended capabilities, rather than limiting validation to existing tasks. The importance of this stage is supported by Table 3 (Section 4.2): removing Skill-Specific Utility Validation decreases performance by 5.48, 5.46, and 3.00 points on ALFWorld, ScienceWorld, and BabyAI, respectively. We have further clarified these methodological distinctions in Section 2 and added Table 1 to compare representative skill admission methods. Together, these designs address the challenges of oracle-free utility evaluation and skill validation beyond existing task pools, rather than simply combining established components.
Thank you for this question. We have provided the complete rubric construction prompt and output schema in Appendix D.4. Beyond rubric construction, to further improve the reproducibility of SkillAdm, we also provide the prompts and corresponding output schemas for all five roles in Appendix D.
First, rubric construction. The Judge receives the task goal, initial observation, and verified environment knowledge. The Judge generates up to three ordered progress criteria and one goal criterion. To ensure that the progress criteria capture meaningful intermediate progress, each must be observable, directly relevant to the task goal, distinct from the others, and strictly weaker than complete task achievement. Accordingly, progress criteria must capture meaningful progress toward the task goal, rather than generic activities that may occur during task execution, such as navigation, searching, or inspection. In contrast, the goal criterion specifies the complete task objective, preserving all original requirements regarding the target objects, required actions, and final destination.
Second, output format. The Judge returns a structured list of criteria, each containing its role, name, description, and references to relevant environment knowledge. Importantly, the Judge does not receive the candidate skill during rubric construction, ensuring that the rubric is independent of the skill being evaluated.