- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper explores the problem of whether a specific skill is useful for a specific task. The paper proposes a framework SkillAlign. It is a task-aware framework for modeling what a task requires and what a skill provides. SkillAlign represents tasks through 6 functional capability requirements and skills through 6 structured quality dimensions. It checks whether a specific task matches a skill using task-specific information. The calculated score supports skill ranking and selection. SkillAlign is aligned across WebShop, ALFWorld, SWEbench, and WebArena. The experimental results show some experimental findings that may be useful for improving LLM skills and downstream performance.
Critical strengths
- The research problem about whether a skill is useful for a specific tasks is an important research problem.
- Experimental results are conducted on 4 datasets with comprehensive details.
Critical weaknesses
- The method this paper uses to decide whether a skill is useful for a specific task may not be effective. Many dimensions on judging this problem is set fixed and arbitrarily, without convincing justifications. Many hyperparameters such as alpha and beta are also arbitrarily. It is unknown if such adhoc design can be truly effective given that many technical aspects seem not very solid, or if such framework can scale to more complex settings where more dimensions about the properties of skills and tasks need to be considered for evaluation.
- The related work section is relatively weak, and does not convincingly distinguish this research from prior research.
- The notations used in this paper is messy and should be improved.
- Experiments contain sufficient details, but many settings such as which LLM model to use, or which setting of the dataset should be used, are set arbitrarily without convincing justifications.
- Insufficient baseslines are compared with this research.
Questions for authors
Please try to address the weaknesses.
4 comments
Thank you for your response, which provides some clarifications on technical details, but does address the concern on the effectiveness of the proposed method, considering its adhoc nature, lack of designing principles, and scalability concerns.
We thank the reviewer for the follow-up feedback. We understand that the central concern is not merely the choice of dimensions or hyperparameters, but whether the framework has a sufficiently principled and empirically reliable basis. To address this concern more directly, we conducted several additional experiments beyond those reported in our original submission. The detailed experimental results have been included in Appendices L–M of the revised manuscript.
1. Design reliability and evaluator consistency
To examine whether the proposed dimensions and mappings depend excessively on subjective judgments, we conducted an independent evaluation with two researchers, covering 8 tasks, 11 skills, and 36 capability–quality mappings. Each researcher's scores were independently propagated through the complete SkillAlign pipeline.
| Component | ICC(2,1) | 95% CI | Kendall's τ_b |
|---|---|---|---|
| Task Profile | 0.927 | [0.874, 0.958] | 0.855 |
| Skill Quality | 0.919 | [0.871, 0.949] | 0.709 |
| C–Q Mapping | 0.805 | [0.651, 0.895] | 0.600 |
| Final Alignment | 0.627 | [0.099, 0.883] | 0.600 |
Despite relatively lower agreement in C–Q mapping and final alignment, the resulting Top-5 selections overlap by 4 out of 5 skills (Jaccard = 0.667). These results demonstrate reasonable reproducibility of the underlying assessments, while acknowledging some evaluator sensitivity in the final scores.
2. Effectiveness against an external evaluation framework
We additionally compared SkillAlign with NVIDIA SkillEvaluator v0.9.0, an open-source framework for structured Skill quality assessment. We evaluated 53 Skill documents across WebShop, ALFWorld, and SWE-bench.
| Benchmark | Metric | SkillAlign | NVIDIA SkillEvaluator |
|---|---|---|---|
| WebShop (n=6) | Spearman's ρ | 1.000 | 0.257 |
| ALFWorld (n=6) | Spearman's ρ | 0.883 | 0.147 |
| SWE-bench (n=30) | Pairwise accuracy | 93.3% (28/30) | 76.7% (23/30) |
For SWE-bench, the corresponding 95% Wilson confidence intervals are [77.9%, 99.2%] for SkillAlign and [54.9%, 89.4%] for NVIDIA SkillEvaluator. These results provide direct quantitative evidence that task-conditioned alignment can offer advantages over an existing structured evaluation framework.
3. Scalability and cross-domain generalization
Expanded Skill libraries. We evaluated SkillAlign on substantially expanded libraries using GLM-5.3-Flash.
| Metric | WebShop | ALFWorld |
|---|---|---|
| Candidate skills | 116 | 59 |
| Spearman's ρ (score vs. reward) | 0.857 | 0.895 |
| Kendall's τ | 0.741 | 0.785 |
| Top-20% mean reward | 0.6332 | 0.9314 |
| Bottom-20% mean reward | 0.3510 | 0.8215 |
The strong score–performance associations and the consistent performance gap between the top and bottom skill groups provide evidence that SkillAlign remains effective on expanded candidate libraries. We acknowledge that systematic ranking-stability analysis under progressively increasing library sizes and thousand-scale evaluation remain open directions.
Cross-domain transfer. We further conducted experiments on WritingBench across nine writing domains, retaining the original six-capability framework and frozen capability–quality matrix without domain-specific recalibration.
| Metric | Result |
|---|---|
| Writing domains | 9 |
| Top-1 selection accuracy | 66.7% (6/9) |
| Pairwise ranking accuracy | 76.9% (10/13) |
We also evaluated downstream writing quality across three independent runs:
| Run | Original | Optimized | Improvement |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 8.603 | 8.692 | +0.089 |
| 2 | 8.538 | 8.697 | +0.159 |
| 3 | 8.649 | 8.797 | +0.149 |
| Mean | 8.596 | 8.729 | +0.132 |
Importantly, the six capability definitions, capability–quality matrix, and aggregation parameters remained frozen across all nine writing domains, with only task profiles adapted to domain-specific requirements. These results provide preliminary evidence that the original mapping can transfer beyond the evaluated agent benchmarks.
4. Overall clarification
We agree that the six-dimensional taxonomy is not theoretically guaranteed to be exhaustive or optimal. Our claim is instead that it provides a functionally motivated and empirically useful abstraction. The additional experiments strengthen this claim through independent human assessment, external baseline comparison, expanded Skill libraries, and cross-domain validation.
We also acknowledge that further work is needed to evaluate thousand-scale libraries, hierarchical Skill dependencies, and substantially different domains such as robotics.
We hope these additional results help address the reviewer's concerns about the framework's design reliability, effectiveness, and scalability. We would be grateful if the reviewer could reconsider their assessment in light of this new evidence.
Not convinced, method still feels adhoc and ineffective.
We thank the reviewer for the constructive comments. Concerns (1), (4), and (5) are addressed by the derivations, robustness analyses, cross-model experiments, and baseline families already reported in the paper. For (2) and (3), we have pointed to the relevant sections below, and we will gladly consider revisions if the reviewer can indicate specific passages or symbols that remain unclear.
Dimensions, hyperparameters, and scalability
Each dimension and hyperparameter has an explicit basis and is tested for sensitivity.
The six capability dimensions are derived from recurring functional mechanisms in representative agent architectures (goal maintenance, state modeling, planning, execution, verification, feedback-driven adaptation; Sec. 3.2). The six quality dimensions capture complementary properties of a Skill intervention (Table 1). The full scoring rubric is given in Appendix K.1–K.2.
The mapping is independently assessed, aggregated across evaluators, and frozen before candidate evaluation (Sec. 3.4). Perturbing it with 1,000 random mappings per noise level leaves the main predictions stable (Fig. 4). The default hyperparameters were fixed before the sweep over α, β, η, and k (Sec. 4.6, Appendix I). Figs. 5–6 show a broad stable region: eight neighboring (α, β) settings achieve ρ ≥ 0.99 on WebShop and ρ ≥ 0.88 on ALFWorld.
Regarding scalability, the six dimensions are intended as a validated abstraction for the evaluated benchmarks rather than an exhaustive taxonomy for all future environments. More complex settings can introduce additional capability or quality dimensions through the same profiling-and-mapping procedure, although the extended taxonomy and mapping would require separate validation. Sec. 4.7 explicitly identifies this as a scope for future evaluation.
Related work
Existing skill evaluation either binds a skill to a specific model and measures downstream performance, as in SWE-Skills-Bench and SkillsBench, or assigns task-independent quality scores using fixed rubrics, as in SkillNet. These paradigms leave a gap between intrinsic quality and execution utility: a well-written skill may not address a task’s bottlenecks, while a specialized skill may still be highly effective. SkillAlign fills this gap by separately modeling skill quality and task requirements, then evaluating their alignment before execution. We will revise the related-work section to make this distinction more explicit.
Notation
We will unify the notation: T (task), S (skill), c(T) (task-capability vector), q(S) (intrinsic skill-quality vector), M (fixed mapping), F(T,S) (final score), with separate indices for task and skill dimensions, a notation table, and one summary algorithm. We will add a notation table and revise visually similar symbols such as CT, Ck, and ck(S).
Experimental settings
Sec. 4.1 report sthe benchmarks, backbones (GPT-5.4 and GLM-5.3-Flash, temperature 0, four runs), evaluator, step caps, and statistical procedures, and Appendix J (Table 15) provides more details. Evaluation uses the standard 500-task WebShop test set, all 134 ALFWorld tasks, all 300 SWE-bench Lite instances, and 764 WebArena single-domain tasks. The 30-pair SWE-bench study is a prespecified diagnostic, documented in Appendix E.
Not dependent on a single model. Downstream results use two agent backbones. Evaluator robustness is tested with DeepSeek-V4-Flash, Qwen3.7-Plus, and Kimi-K3 under identical frozen inputs (Appendix G.2): WebShop rankings reach Spearman 0.943–1.000 and Kendall 0.867–1.000 (Tables 12–13), and strict HQ-selection on the 30 pairs is 90.0–93.3% (Table 14).
If the reviewer has a specific concern about potential bias, an unfair comparison, or a result that may not hold under an alternative setting, we would appreciate the specific example and will carefully consider addressing it in the revision.
Baseline coverage
We evaluate two settings, each with baselines corresponding to its principal alternatives.
For pre-execution Skill evaluation, Fig. 2c compares SkillAlign with Direct LLM, Validated Rubric, and Raw Q Mean. These represent holistic judgment without structured decomposition, structured evaluation without task-conditioned alignment, and uniform linear aggregation of the same frozen quality scores. This comparison tests the contribution of the complete task-conditioned matching and aggregation mechanism over direct judgment and task-agnostic quality evaluation.
For Skill optimization, Table 2 compares No Skill, Origin Skill, General Optimize, Skill-Creator, and SkillAlign-guided optimization. These controls test whether the observed improvements arise merely from using a Skill, retaining the original Skill, applying generic LLM revision, or using an existing external Skill-development procedure. The comparisons cover four benchmarks, two downstream backbones, and four runs per configuration.