- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper identifies Task–Skill Misalignment (TSM), where task descriptions focus on objectives while skill documents provide procedural guidance. To address this issue, the authors propose SkillDreamer, which generates pseudo skills to improve retrieval and explicit reasons about capability requirements to guide skill invocation. Experiments on multiple benchmarks demonstrate improvements in skill retrieval and downstream task execution.
Critical strengths
- The paper identifies a practical problem with agent skill identification and provides a unified framework for both skill retrieval and invocation.
- Experiments across multiple benchmarks and model backbones demonstrate consistent retrieval improvements and gains in downstream task performance.
Critical weaknesses
- Limited novelty. The main contribution of SkillDreamer lies in integrating existing retrieval enhancement and agent prompting strategies into a unified skill identification pipeline, rather than introducing a fundamentally new skill retrieval or invocation mechanism.
- Insufficient evidence for the necessity of Prospective Skill Generation. The ablation results in Table 3 show that Pseudo-Skill Retrieval performs worse than Direct Retrieval. These results do not demonstrate that generating skill-like procedural guidance is necessary. The reported improvements may primarily come from other components rather than the proposed core mechanism.
- Insufficient evidence supporting Task–Skill Misalignment (TSM). The paper demonstrates differences between task descriptions and skill documents, as well as a correlation between explicit capability requirements and higher skill invocation rates. However, these observations are insufficient to establish that TSM directly causes performance degradation.
- Limited novelty of Capability-aware Skill Invocation (CSI). CSI primarily relies on additional prompting instructions and periodic capability checks. Its effectiveness may largely result from stronger prompting rather than a new capability-aware invocation mechanism.
Questions for authors
- Table 3(a) shows that Pseudo-Skill Retrieval alone performs worse than Direct Retrieval. Could the authors provide additional experiments to demonstrate that generating procedural guidance is necessary for the reported improvements?
- The proposed Prospective Skill Generation shares similarities with existing hypothetical document generation methods, such as HyDE and Query2doc. Could the authors include comparisons with these methods to better establish the novelty and effectiveness of their approach?
- CSI introduces capability reasoning, explicit skill-use instructions, and periodic runtime checkpoints. Could the authors conduct separate ablation studies on these three components to clarify their individual contributions?
- SkillDreamer introduces additional computational overhead from LLM-based capability inference, pseudo-skill generation, and capability checks during execution. Could the authors report the corresponding token consumption, inference latency, and computational costs?
8 comments
part two
2. Methodological Novelty in Agentic Execution: Capability-Aware Skill Invocation (CSI)
We respectfully argue that methodological novelty in agentic systems is not restricted to updating model weights or retraining policies. Much like foundational paradigms such as ReAct [C] and in-context learning [D], significant novelty lies in formulating a principled reasoning structure that governs how an agent decomposes decisions. In our method, unlike standard execution prompting that maps interaction history directly to actions or skills, CSI introduces an explicit subgoal → capability gap → skill matching bottleneck prior to action selection to resolve invocation-side TSM. We intentionally instantiate this mechanism via prompting so that it can be validated directly on frontier LLMs in a training-free manner, without modifying model weights or restricting applicability to fine-tuned backbones.
To verify that CSI’s gains stem from this capability-aware invocation mechanism rather than generic execution prompting, we compare full CSI against a controlled baseline retaining only generic execution guidance (e.g., output verification, failure avoidance, and periodic checkpoints) on SkillNet-Gym using DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash-1017 across three runs:
| Setting | Pass (%) | Total LLM tokens (k/task) |
|---|---|---|
| No-skill | 67.80 ± 1.69 | 351.72 |
| No-skill + skill-execution-agnostic guidance (generic guidance + checkpoints) | 68.36 ± 5.18 | 399.55 |
| GT-skill | 66.10 ± 3.39 | 400.58 |
| GT-skill + skill-execution-agnostic guidance (generic guidance + checkpoints) | 67.80 ± 3.39 | 445.31 |
| GT-skill + CSI (skill-execution-oriented mechanisms and skill-execution-agnostic guidance) | 71.19 ± 4.48 | 420.40 |
While generic guidance yields only marginal gains (+0.56 pp under No-skill and +1.70 pp under GT-skill), full CSI further improves mean Pass by 3.39 percentage points (67.80% → 71.19%) with lower token usage, confirming the distinct contribution of capability-aware skill matching and invocation.
3. Problem-Level Contribution: Formulating Task-Skill Misalignment (TSM)
Beyond specific methodological designs, our problem-level contribution should not be overlooked. To be specific, prior studies largely focus on scaling query-skill similarity or training invocation policies, without diagnosing why strong retrievers and capable LLMs still miss or fail to invoke useful skills. In contrast, by formalizing TSM across both retrieval and execution stages, our work sheds light on two key directions for subsequent research: i) addressing the fundamental misalignment between tasks and skills, rather than simply adapting standard document retrieval paradigms to the skill domain; and ii) enabling explicit capability awareness in agentic execution, revealing that suboptimal task performance in frontier agents may stem from a lack of awareness of required capabilities rather than limited execution ability.
part three
W2: Insufficient evidence for the necessity of Prospective Skill Generation. The ablation results in Table 3 show that Pseudo-Skill Retrieval performs worse than Direct Retrieval. These results do not demonstrate that generating skill-like procedural guidance is necessary. The reported improvements may primarily come from other components rather than the proposed core mechanism.
Q1: Table 3(a) shows that Pseudo-Skill Retrieval alone performs worse than Direct Retrieval. Could the authors provide additional experiments to demonstrate that generating procedural guidance is necessary for the reported improvements?
Keypoints: The effectiveness of pseudo skill generation.
Effectiveness of pseudo-skill generation. We acknowledge that replacing the original query with pseudo skills reduces Recall@10 from 62.25% to 59.00% in Table 3(a), potentially because generated pseudo skills may omit some task-specific objectives or constraints. This suggests that pseudo skills alone cannot fully replace the original query as discussed in the manuscript. Therefore, SkillDreamer combines the original query’s task-specific information with pseudo skills’ procedural cues, thus improving Recall@10 from 62.25% to 69.47% in Table 3(a). To further assess the contribution of pseudo skill generation, we added two controlled comparisons:
- Raw query + BM25: Rerank raw-query dense top-20 candidates using 2:1 dense–BM25 score fusion.
- Capability-description substitution: Replace pseudo skills with their corresponding capability descriptions.
The results below support the effectiveness of pseudo-skill generation. On the one hand, reranking raw-query top-20 candidates with BM25 improves Recall@10 from 62.25% to 63.52%. The full SkillDreamer pipeline, which combines raw-query and pseudo-skill information, achieves 69.47%, outperforming this control by 5.95 percentage points. On the other hand, replacing pseudo skills with capability descriptions reduces Recall@10 from 69.47% to 67.99%. With all other HSR settings unchanged, this 1.48-point decrease supports the role of pseudo-skill generation in improving retrieval performance.
| Method | Recall@10 (%) | Total LLM tokens (k/task) |
|---|---|---|
| Raw-query retrieval | 62.25 | — |
| Pseudo-skill-only retrieval | 59.00 | 12.50 |
| Raw query + BM25, top-20 reranking | 63.52 | — |
| Replacing pseudo skills with capability descriptions | 67.99 | 4.24 |
| SkillDreamer | 69.47 | 12.50 |
part one
We sincerely thank the reviewer for recognizing the practical relevance of our work and for the constructive suggestions. In response, we have added comparisons with HyDE and Query2doc, controlled experiments on capability inference and pseudo-skill generation, and CSI ablations to clarify the contributions of our design. We also report token consumption and request latency to assess the additional computational overhead. The additional retrieval experiments are conducted on SkillUsage, while execution analyses use DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash-1017 on SkillNet-Gym. Below, we will address your questions and concerns point by point.
Thank you for the comment. We will clarify our contributions at both the problem and methodological levels. At the problem level, we identify and formulate Task-Skill Misalignment (TSM) as a fundamental bottleneck in agent skill identification. At the methodological level, our core contribution lies in formulating a principled, capability-driven reasoning structure across both retrieval and execution. Realizing this structure via prompting rather than parameter updates is an implementation choice made specifically to validate our framework directly on frontier LLMs. Below, we elaborate on these aspects with supporting controlled experiments.
1. Methodological Novelty in Skill Retrieval: Capability-Driven Proxy Generation
While SkillDreamer shares the high-level intuition of using LLM-generated texts to assist retrieval, it differs fundamentally from HyDE-style query expansion. Specifically, HyDE [A] and Query2doc [B] expand queries within a homogeneous semantic space by generating hypothetical answer passages to increase topical overlap. In contrast, agent skill retrieval faces an asymmetric gap between declarative task objectives ("what to achieve") and procedural skill documents ("how to execute"). Rather than rewriting or elaborating on the query, SkillDreamer introduces an explicit intermediate reasoning step (
task → capability → pseudo-skill) that decouples latent execution-required capabilities from task-specific semantic anchors, translating each capability into an execution-oriented retrieval proxy.To empirically verify this distinction, we conduct two sets of controlled comparisons on SkillUsage using Qwen3.6-27B as the generator:
w/ HSR), as well as outperforming sequential execution-step decomposition at lower token cost: