- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes RSR-PVC for partially view-aligned clustering. The method constructs relative semantic representations using known aligned samples as shared references to facilitate cross-view comparison. It further introduces a hard-to-soft association mechanism that combines bidirectional alignment for known correspondences with soft association and relational consistency learning for unaligned samples. Experiments on eight benchmark datasets report competitive clustering performance against seven baseline methods.
Critical strengths
- The proposed framework integrates relative semantic representation learning, cross-view association, and multi-view fusion into a unified pipeline.
- The method explicitly distinguishes between known and unknown cross-view correspondences and adopts different association strategies for each.
- The experiments cover eight benchmark datasets with different unaligned ratios. Ablation studies and additional analyses are provided to examine the contributions of individual components.
Critical weaknesses
- The paper identifies limited cross-view semantic comparability and unreliable correspondence estimation as two major limitations of existing PVC methods. However, prior works such as [A] [B] [C] have already addressed these challenges through relational matching, distribution alignment, confidence estimation, and soft association. Although these methods are discussed in the Related Work section, they are not included in the experimental comparisons, making it difficult to assess the advantages of the proposed method over closely related approaches.
- he proposed relative semantic representation relies heavily on the aligned samples used as semantic references. However, the experiments only examine varying unaligned ratios, without considering the representativeness of the reference set. Even at a fixed alignment ratio, different class distributions or limited class coverage may substantially affect the quality of the resulting relation space. This dependency remains insufficiently investigated.
- The cross-view association matrix is constructed within each mini-batch, restricting candidate correspondences to samples in the same batch. The paper does not clarify how such cross-batch correspondences are handled or how this limitation affects association quality.
[A] Wang et al. Contrastive Graph Distribution Alignment for Partially View-Aligned Clustering.
[B] Peng et al. SMART: Semantic Matching Contrastive Learning for Partially View-Aligned Clustering.
[C] Xu et al. Partial Contrastive Learning for Partially View-Aligned Multi-View Clustering.
Questions for authors
- Could the authors further clarify the key differences between RSR-PVC and the closely related methods? It would also be helpful to include direct experimental comparisons with these methods to better demonstrate the advantages of the proposed approach.
- How sensitive is the proposed relative semantic representation to the representativeness of the aligned reference samples? Could the authors evaluate its robustness under different reference class distributions or varying class coverage while keeping the alignment ratio fixed?
- How does the proposed method handle cases where the true cross-view counterparts of unaligned samples fall into different mini-batches? Could the authors clarify the impact of batch-wise association on the quality of learned correspondences, particularly for larger datasets?