- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes DeCA for partially view-aligned Clustering (PVC), aiming to address the neglect of intra-view geometric topology in existing methods and the potential false-negative repulsion caused by aligning unpaired samples. To preserve intra-view structural information, DeCA employs a dual-decoder Graph Autoencoder. For aligned samples, DeCA employs cross-view contrastive learning to establish semantic anchors. For unaligned samples, it combines intra-view neighborhood contrastive learning with pseudo-label-guided conditional MMD to achieve cross-view distribution alignment without explicit sample correspondences. Finally, a decoupled feature fusion strategy is introduced to prevent the direct fusion of mismatched representations. The reported experimental results on ten benchmark datasets show competitive clustering performance against eight existing PVC baselines.
Critical strengths
-
The consideration of intra-view structural information is a reasonable design choice. DeCA employs a dual-decoder GAE to reconstruct both feature attributes and graph topology, incorporating intra-view structural information into representation learning.
-
The experimental evaluation covers a relatively broad range of settings. The paper includes ten multi-view datasets with varying scales and eight representative PVC baselines, providing a comprehensive performance comparison.
Critical weaknesses
-
The paper exhibits serious issues in scientific rigor and academic presentation. The first sentence of the Introduction incorrectly claims that unsupervised representation learning heavily relies on multi-view clustering, misrepresenting the relationship between these research areas. Additionally, Sections 2.2 and 2.3 have identical titles and substantially overlapping content. These issues raise concerns about the rigor of the paper.
-
The experimental results contain multiple repetitions, raising serious concerns about their reliability. In Table 4, the "w/ MLP" and "w/o Decoupled Fusion" variants report identical results across all six entries. Furthermore, in Tables 2 and 3, three baselines (BIN, DWInfoNCE, and RMCNC) report exactly the same ACC, NMI, and ARI values on Fashion under different unaligned rates. These repetitions across different experimental settings raise serious concerns about the reliability of the reported experimental evidence.
Questions for authors
-
Why do the "w/ MLP" and "w/o Decoupled Fusion" variants in Table 4 report identical results across all six entries? Furthermore, why do BIN, DWInfoNCE, and RMCNC report exactly the same ACC, NMI, and ARI values on Fashion under different unaligned rates in Tables 2 and 3? Explain these repetitions and verify the reported results.
-
What is the scientific basis for the claim that unsupervised representation learning heavily relies on multi-view clustering in the opening sentence of the Introduction? Why do Sections 2.2 and 2.3 have identical titles and substantially overlapping content?
-
In Table 4, simultaneously removing (L_{\mathrm{cscl}}) and (L_{\mathrm{lpca}}) yields higher ACC than removing either loss individually on both datasets. In particular, on NoisyMNIST-tune, all three metrics (ACC, NMI, and ARI) are higher when both losses are removed. Please explain the reason for this phenomenon.
-
Section 3.4 states that the template view is selected based on clustering silhouette quality, whereas Section 4.3 specifies that the first view is used as the template view. Please explain this inconsistency and analyze how different template-view selection strategies affect clustering performance.
-
How are the global cluster centers used for pseudo-label generation initialized and updated during joint training? The authors should explain how inaccurate pseudo-labels and empty pseudo-classes are handled.