- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The overarching goal of the paper is to reconstruct 3D chlorophyll concentration in the world's oceans with constrains from DIC and organic carbon based on modeling data. The authors decompose this problem according to traser-conservation equation, i.e., temporal change is equal to transport plus source-sink term. Chlorophyll is associated with the source-sink term. The paper modeled the chlorophyll-to-carbon ratio to consider the physiology.
Critical strengths
The paper tried to model chlorophyll-to-carbon ratio.
Critical weaknesses
The paper is based on the assumption that carbon (DIC, POC, and DOC) have denser measurements than chlorophyll, which motivates the incorporation of the data to constrain 3D chlorophyll. However, in the ocean, there are a limited number of DIC, POC, and DOC (particularly these three together). Also, the conversion between DIC and organic carbon is controlled by many factors, e.g., heterotrophic respiration which is not directly associated with phytoplankton.
Questions for authors
I would recommend the authors to get more feedbacks from ocean biogeochemists.