- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies physical field reconstruction under authentic missing observations. To address the limitation that conventional random or block-wise masking strategies cannot adequately capture realistic occlusion patterns, the authors propose Observation-Aligned Mask Priors. Specifically, a BFN is first trained to learn the distribution of authentic observation masks, and guidance is applied during sampling to generate masks aligned with the current observation pattern. The intersection of the generated mask and the original observation mask is then used as the context, while the remaining observed entries serve as queries for training the physical field reconstruction model. Theoretically, the method guarantees that each valid observed location has a non-zero probability of being selected as a query. Experiments on three oceanographic datasets show that the proposed method outperforms several baselines in terms of MSE and PSNR.
Critical strengths
- The paper identifies an important limitation of existing context-query partitioning strategies: handcrafted random or block-wise masks may fail to reflect authentic, structured occlusion patterns in real-world observations.
- The paper provides substantial theoretical analysis. In particular, the authors theoretically establish the positive query probability property of the proposed mask partitioning strategy, providing justification for avoiding spatial locations that never receive reconstruction supervision.
- The authors evaluate the method on three oceanographic datasets, where the proposed method achieves consistently competitive or improved reconstruction performance.
Critical weaknesses
The experimental validation is insufficient.
Questions for authors
- The number of comparison methods is limited. The authors only compare with DINDiff, Ambient Diffusion, and MissDiff.
- There is no analysis of inference latency. Since the proposed method relies on an additional BFN to learn the mask distribution, it is unclear whether the additional complexity is necessary.
- The experimental scenarios are relatively limited, as all three datasets are from oceanographic settings.
- If the missingness depends on the underlying physical state, is modeling the mask topology alone sufficient to capture the MNAR missingness emphasized in the paper?
4 comments
Dear Reviewer qB9z,
We hope our responses have addressed your concerns. We would greatly appreciate it if you could take a moment to share your thoughts when you have time.
Thank you for your consideration and efforts.
I thank the authors for their detailed response and additional experiments. The newly included baselines and the evaluation on MOD11A1 substantially address my concerns regarding experimental comparisons and generalizability. The clarification that BFN is used only during training also resolves my concern about additional inference latency.
I appreciate the clarification regarding the data–mask independence assumption. I encourage the authors to explicitly state this assumption and distinguish structured observation missingness from state-dependent MNAR throughout the revised manuscript. Additionally, reporting the training-time overhead of BFN would help provide a more complete picture of the computational cost.
Overall, the rebuttal has adequately addressed my main concerns, and I will maintain my positive rating of 3 (Weak Accept).
Thank you for your time and effort.
We appreciate the reviewer's positive recognition of our work.
We sincerely thank the reviewer for your constructive feedback.
Q1. Additional Baseline Comparisons
To further strengthen our empirical evaluation, we have additionally included two more baselines: MSM (Park et al., 2026) and DINEOF (Beckers and Rixen, 2003), covering both recent diffusion-based approaches and classical oceanographic reconstruction methods. Our method consistently outperforms both newly added baselines, further demonstrating the effectiveness and robustness of our method compared with both modern diffusion-based approaches and classical oceanographic reconstruction methods.
[1] Park, C. Y., Shoushtari, S., An, H., and Kamilov, U. S. (2026). Measurement Score-Based Diffusion Model. International Conference on Learning Representations (ICLR).
[2] Beckers, J.-M., and Rixen, M. (2003). EOF Calculations and Data Filling from Incomplete Oceanographic Datasets. Journal of Atmospheric and Oceanic Technology, 20(12), 1839–1856.
Q2. Additional Cost
An important clarification is that BFN is only used to generate context-query partitions during training and is not required at inference time. Once the imputation model is trained, reconstruction is performed directly using the learned imputation model, without any BFN sampling or guidance computation. Therefore, our framework introduces no additional inference latency compared with the same imputation backbone.
We acknowledge that online BFN sampling introduces additional training-time cost. However, this is largely an engineering choice and can be eliminated by pre-generating a diverse pool of observation-aligned masks for each sample and randomly selecting them during training, bringing per-iteration costs close to conventional masking with negligible expected impact on performance. Moreover, learning binary mask priors requires only a lightweight BFN network, whose pretraining cost is quite small relative to the training of main imputation model. Thus, computational cost can be substantially reduced through implementation choices without compromising our core methodology.
Q3. Additional Experimental Domain
To further evaluate the generalizability of our framework beyond oceanographic applications, we have conducted additional experiments on NASA's MOD11A1 dataset, which provides daily satellite observations of land surface temperature and emissivity at 1-km spatial resolution. Our method also achieves strongest reconstruction performance on this non-oceanographic dataset, demonstrating that the benefits of observation-aligned mask priors are not limited to oceanographic fields. These additional results provide further evidence of the generalizability of our framework across different physical domains and observation patterns.
Q4. Clarification on MNAR
We believe this concern stems from a misunderstanding of our problem setting. Following Incomplete Data, Complete Dynamics: A Diffusion Approach (Zhou et al., 2025), our theoretical framework adopts the data–mask independence assumption, rather than explicitly modeling state-dependent missingness. Zhou et al. (2025) have already established that strictly positive query probability enables unbiased conditional-expectation learning from incomplete observations under mask-data independence assumptions. Building upon this foundation, our work focuses on how to achieve this essential property in real-world applications characterized by complex and structured observation patterns.
Importantly, if a coordinate's missingness is determined by its own underlying physical state, that state may consistently prevent the coordinate from being observed (Mi=0). In such cases, the physical state and its missingness are inherently coupled: the true value remains permanently unobserved and cannot be learned from the available data, making unbiased reconstruction impossible without additional assumptions, which falls outside our problem setting. Instead, we address authentic, structured observation gaps arising from factors such as cloud cover, satellite trajectories, and geographical constraints, which are poorly captured by heuristic masking.