- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper propose a physics aligned neural architecture designed for ocean forecasting. It embeds structural constraints into the modules. It focus on physical inconsistent scenarios such as land sea mixing and unrealistic vertical transport. The experiments shows that the depth is an important feature dimension about representations.
Critical strengths
- The experiments includes coastal errors, vertical profiles and long-rollout diagnostics with standard prediction errors.
- The paper models explicitly depth-dependent ocean support and adjacent-layer interactions in its arthitecture.
Critical weaknesses
- I am not convinced that all five inventories in Table 8 should have zero residual and assumption in Sec. 5.2. Because dissolved oxygen and nutrients have biogeochemical transformations. Please clarify which source or boundary-flux terms are included in the budget and justify this assumption about interpreting the residuals as conservation errors.
2, I have a concern about Table 8 and Table 10. Both tables report different (positive and negative) drift sign for the same held-out interval, i.e., 2D-GNN nitrate drift is +152% per century in Table 8 but -1.25*10^18 per century in Table 10. What's the reason?
- The 2D-GNN ablation study changes depth represenation, geometry and vertical interactions. Thus it didn't isolate the proposed physical constraints.
Questions for authors
Please see the Weaknesses section and consider each point as a question.
Thank you for your time and the constructive review. Each point is answered below, with new ablations in point 3.
1. The zero-residual assumption: oxygen and nutrient inventories are not conserved on their own. Oxygen has biological sources and sinks and air-sea exchange, nutrients cycle through biological pools, and our column ends at 3220 m. The Table 8 residual included none of these terms, so it measured the monthly inventory tendency, not conservation error. We now evaluate it against the reference budget: at each monthly step, the change in the model's global inventory minus the change in the GLORYS12/BIOMER inventory over the same domain.
Mean |R - R_ref|, % of inventory per century, 191 monthly intervals of the 2010–2025 held-out integration, all 20 levels.
Salt is negligible in both models. For phosphate and nitrate, our model tracks the reference budget 3x and 15x more closely. For oxygen and silicate, BIOMER gains inventory over the period while our model's inventory declines. BIOMER is a free-running hindcast that the producer's quality document (Copernicus Marine, GLOBAL_MULTIYEAR_BGC_001_029) describes as not yet at steady state below the surface, so this residual measures agreement with the hindcast rather than with the ocean. Observational constraints are the reference that would settle it, which we state as a limitation.
2. Opposite signs in Tables 8 and 10: the nitrate case you cite (+152% per century) traces to post-processing, not to the model. The 2D-GNN stores its 20 levels as feature channels, and the Table 8 calculation integrated only the surface layer. Over the full column, its nitrate drift is -5.08% per century and its phosphate drift -2.04%, both now matching Table 10 in sign. A variable-indexing error in post-processing also affected our own oxygen and silicate entries in Table 10; recomputed, they match Table 8 in sign. Table 8 reports the endpoint change of the inventory and Table 10 a linear trend fitted to the monthly series; with the corrections, the two agree in sign for every inventory except salt, whose endpoint drift is below 0.1% per century in both models. The revision reports both, defined in the captions, from the same integration and domain.
3. What the 2D-GNN isolates: the depth-dependent geometry, the interface fluxes and the surface-only forcing all require an explicit depth axis. Without one, there is no per-level wet domain to follow the bathymetry, no interface on which to place a flux, and no surface layer to which forcing can be restricted. Removing depth as a structural axis therefore removes all three together, so the 2D-GNN tests the depth-resolved design as a whole. It also follows the design the field already uses, from global weather prediction (Lam et al., 2023) to its ocean adaptation (Holmberg et al., 2024), in which depth levels are stacked as feature channels.
To isolate the constraints within the depth-resolved model, we retrained three variants under the same protocol as the full model:
θ: temperature skill against persistence at 192 months; variance ratio to reanalysis (1 is ideal); residual as in point 1; e-folding: depth at which the warming falls to 1/e of its surface value.
Each constraint has a measurable cost when removed. Without vertical exchange, a +3 °C surface warming never leaves the top layer and skill halves; forcing every level drives the warming 2.7x deeper and inflates variance; an unconstrained vertical operator loses about 15% of the skill and damps variance. The full model leads on skill, variance and budget tracking.
The conclusions rest on internally consistent, measured numbers: positive skill against persistence through 16 years of held-out integration (Table 7), preserved variance and spectra (Table 6), closer tracking of the phosphate and nitrate budgets than the 2D-GNN, and a measurable contribution from each constraint (point 3). These address the three points you raised, and we would be grateful if you would consider whether they change your assessment.