- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes PE-TA-ViT for global surface and near-surface ocean forecasting. The framework predicts daily increments at 1° resolution, bilinearly interpolates them to 1/4°, and adds them to the previous high-resolution state. The paper reports improvements over persistence and several learned baselines over a nine-day forecast horizon, together with vorticity, geostrophic-current, and spectral diagnostics.
Critical strengths
- The application is meaningful, and the framework is straightforward to understand and offers a plausible engineering approach to practical ocean forecasting problem.
- Promising reported forecasting results. Tables 1–2 show improvements over persistence across all six ocean variables, while Table 4 includes multiple learned baselines and GLONET. The evaluation also considers spatial and physical diagnostics beyond aggregate RMSE, which is useful for this application (Sec. 4; Appendix D).
Critical weaknesses
- While the application is meaningful, and the framework offers a plausible engineering approach. However, I am not convinced that the submission establishes a sufficient ML methodological contribution and provides sufficiently controlled evidence for its central claims. In particular, the experiments do not adequately distinguish preservation of initial fine-scale structure from successful prediction of its subsequent evolution. The work currently looks more like a specialized ocean-forecasting application than as a sufficiently validated contribution to machine learning community.
- Preserving high-resolution structure is not sufficient evidence of forecasting its evolution. Under Eqs. (1)–(3), every update to the high-resolution state is an interpolated coarse-grid increment. Consequently, changes remain restricted to the range of this fixed interpolation-and-masking operator, while components outside that range are inherited from the initial condition. Although Sec. 5 acknowledges limitations in generating new eddies, the issue also concerns the evolution of existing structures.
- Temporal cross-attention may reduce to simple additive conditioning. If each temporal embedding in Eq. (10) is a single key/value token, its attention weight is always one, making the output independent of the spatial query. Since the gating weights also depend only on time, TAFEv2 would reduce to a shared, date-dependent additive correction. The authors should clarify token dimensions and explain what this adds beyond standard temporal conditioning (Sec. 3.2.3; Eqs. 10–13). Please also see Question 2 below.
Questions for authors
-
Can the authors quantify forecasting skill at different spatial scales and compare eddy displacement or temporal vorticity changes against persistence and simpler residual predictors?
-
Can the authors provide individual module-removal ablations and compare TAFEv2 with simple additive calendar embeddings? In Eq. (10), does each temporal embedding constitute a single key/value token? If so, standard attention over one key has weight one and is independent of the spatial query. What additional functionality does the cross-attention formulation provide?
-
How does Eq. (24) support a claim about cross-scale energy transfer rather than spectral-content retention?
-
What causes the 33.792°C SST error of the direct-interpolation baseline? Does the advantage remain after using mask-aware interpolation and evaluating both approaches on the same coastal and offshore subsets?