- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1(−1)
Read review
Paper summary
ECHOSAT introduces a spatio-temporal framework using multi-source satellite remote sensing data. The framework is designed to generate annual global 10m tree height maps for the period 2018–2024, while capturing height variations driven by forest growth and disturbances.
The authors developed a Swin Transformer-based spatio-temporal U-Net architecture, integrating data from Sentinel-1/2, ALOS PALSAR-2, and TanDEM-X, while utilizing GEDI LiDAR measurements as training labels. A key methodological contribution is the introduction of "Growth Loss"—a technique that generates pseudo-labels by applying piecewise linear regression (constrained by growth rates) to initial tree-height predictions. This approach enhances the temporal consistency of annual predictions while still allowing for abrupt height changes caused by forest disturbances.
The authors have compared ECHOSAT with 4 existing global canopy-height products and further assessed prediction accuracy using independent airborne LiDAR data from the NEON network. Testing against 2020 GEDI data revealed that ECHOSAT achieved a Mean Absolute Error (MAE) of 5.85 m, outperforming the best-performing baseline (6.85 m). The authors also evaluated the impact of Growth Loss on temporal consistency through regional case studies, analyses of annual height-change distributions, and ablation experiments.
Critical strengths
The GEDI data is sparse in both space and time, this paper propose one solution, which name is "Growth Loss" function that incorporates ecological constraints, thereby improving the temporal consistency of predictions. This is valuable for large-scale forest monitoring. The underlying concept—integrating physical constraints into model design—serves as an effective approach for handling sparse remote sensing data.
Critical weaknesses
I have listed 2 weaknesses:
- Lack of independent quantitative validation for year-to-year changes in canopy height.
The experiments in the paper primarily validate the prediction accuracy of canopy height for a single year. Regarding temporal dynamics, the authors rely on evaluating predicted growth rate distributions, qualitative case studies, and temporal consistency analyses; however, there is a notable absence of independent quantitative validation using diverse LiDAR datasets (ULS/MLS/TLS) or ground-based forest plot observations. Given that annual growth increments are typically much smaller than the prediction error for any single year, demonstrating that the results are "smoother" or consistent with predefined growth patterns does not prove that the model has accurately captured actual changes in forest height. Consequently, the paper’s most significant contribution—the modeling of temporal dynamics—remains insufficiently validated.
- A lack of comparative experiments to clearly demonstrate the method's contributions.
The proposed architecture is a combination of existing components—Swin Transformer and U-Net—while the "Growth Loss" is based on piecewise linear regression with predefined constraints. The current experiments compare the model primarily against static canopy height products; there is a lack of direct benchmarking against other single-year or time-series models using identical input data and training conditions. Furthermore, ablation studies indicate that single-year prediction accuracy remains virtually the same whether or not the "Growth Loss" is applied. As a result, it is unclear to what extent the performance gains stem from the proposed spatiotemporal modeling approach itself, which complicates an assessment of the method's true innovation and practical contribution.
Questions for authors
Q1. Question on similar products
The Monitoring 10 m product by Kanop, in its 2024 release, provides global annual canopy height estimates (covering both "canopy height" and "tree height") at a 10 m resolution, dating back to 2017. Could the authors further clarify the primary differences between ECHOSAT and this existing product?
Q2. Disentangling "Growth Loss" from the Contributions of the Spatiotemporal Model Architecture
Appendix Table 4 indicates that there is virtually no difference in single-year prediction accuracy between a model incorporating "Growth Loss" and one without fine-tuning. While "Growth Loss" does improve temporal consistency, this improvement appears to stem primarily from the predefined growth constraints. Do the authors have control experiments—such as a comparison between independent single-year prediction models and a joint spatiotemporal model—conducted under identical input data and experimental conditions to demonstrate the performance gains attributable specifically to the spatiotemporal modeling framework? Furthermore, is there independent evidence to ensure that "Growth Loss" does not lead to the over-smoothing of actual height changes, particularly in the case of smaller-scale forest degradation events? As Growth Loss is key contribution of this work, I want to know these additional results.
Q3. Dependence of model predictions on future observations
Based on the model architecture, satellite imagery from 2018–2024 is fed into the model collectively to generate canopy height predictions for all seven years simultaneously. For a given year—for instance, 2019—does the model utilize information from imagery acquired in 2020–2024? If so, these annual height maps effectively constitute a "retrospective reconstruction" that relies on future observations, rather than independent estimates that could have been generated at the time for each respective year. Could the authors clarify this point, and explain its implications for the paper’s stated application of annual forest monitoring?
5 comments
Retrospective vs live product
This is correct. The prediction for the year 2019 is based on all years, including 2020-2024. Our goal, guided by input from domain experts, is to produce the best canopy height map possible, which also means including every data point that could increase the accuracy. Nevertheless, we would like to provide results for causal masking and report the results on the same set as for Table 1. As we can see, the results do not differ by much, sometimes even improving. Further, one can run the pipeline every year to get an updated version.
| Method | MAE | MSE | RMSE | MAPE | R² | R²_all | r | r_all |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Causal masking | 5.802 | 118.284 | 10.876 | 29.285 | 0.233 | 0.576 | 0.592 | 0.772 |
| Ours | 5.854 | 118.074 | 10.866 | 30.201 | 0.234 | 0.577 | 0.588 | 0.770 |
Comparison to Monitoring 10m product by Kanop
Kanop is a commercial platform based on proprietary models. To the best of our knowledge, its methodology, training data and validation are not publicly documented or peer-reviewed, and its maps are only available through paid access. We therefore could not include it in our benchmark, which uses openly available global products. Methodologically, it is unclear whether Kanop models temporal dynamics or applies per-year predictions. ECHOSAT learns them directly via its spatio-temporal architecture and growth loss, without post-processing. ECHOSAT is also fully documented and will beopenly released (code: Apache 2.0, maps: CC-BY 4.0).
If you would like further clarifications, please do not hesitate to ask.
Dear Authors,
Many thanks for your feedback, I will provide responses based on your response.
- Temporal change validation
I have read the response to reviewer HuEN; the results highlight two significant issues:
- Severe Underestimation of Change Magnitude: ECHOSAT’s estimates of tree height change are compressed by a factor 4–8, this is a strong number.
- Inadequate Detection of Declines: In where ALS data indicates a decrease in tree height, the median change predicted by ECHOSAT remains positive (this is realted to no negative setting of the model).
This new validation reveals a systematic bias in the magnitude of change; the model has no reliable capability for quantifying tree height changes at the pixel level.
Also, the authors do not specify how many sites are covered by the NEON test.
While I acknowledge the ongoing multi-year LiDAR validation datasets in global scale, NEON is a good start.
UCL, Ghent University, and UMR AMAP in France have made ALS/TLS data publicly available for regions in South America, Africa, and Southeast Asia—for instance, through projects like Weighing Trees with Lasers and ForestScan. I suggest to do test in the authors' study for validation.
- Contribution of GrowthLoss and model architecture
I understand that the "Growth Loss" component is intended to improve temporal consistency; however, temporal consistency is not synonymous with temporal accuracy.
I think this work have not demonstrated that the "Growth Loss" approach recovers actual forest dynamics more accurately than a model without such fine-tuning. In fact, it may smooth out genuine declines in tree height that fall below the threshold for disturbance detection.
Maybe using NEON ALS and other LiDAR data to compare the prediction errors of tree height change—as well as the capacity for disturbance detection—both before and after applying the "Growth Loss" fine-tuning can help to calrify the contribution of the model.
We thank the reviewer for the feedback. We would like to point out that the GrowthLoss is not our only contribution: The main asset of our paper is the ECHOSAT map itself in our optinion.
Below, we have tried to address the four concerns raised by you.
Temporal change validation
We fully agree with your concern. Validation of the temporal changes is important for downstream users, however globally stratified repeated LiDAR observations are needed for such a validation. To the best of our knowledge, no such dataset exists. As you rightly point out, growth increments are typically much smaller than the prediction error for an individual year. This limits the usefulness of competing approaches that treat each year independently and was a key motivation for developing GrowthLoss. Nevertheless, although it is only for a local region (USA), we have done some analysis using the repeated NEON sites, which you can find in our response to reviewer HuEN.
Contribution of GrowthLoss and model architecture
We believe it is important to distinguish three aspects of this comment: the contribution of the GrowthLoss, the contribution of the model architecture, and the extent to which GrowthLoss may oversmooth the predicted heights.
Contribution of the GrowthLoss: You are correct that Table 4 does not show any differences, which is consistent with the intended behavior of the loss. We developed the GrowthLoss to obtain more realistic temporal tree heights, while not degrading the single-year performance. The reference head and the prediction head share exactly the same backbone architecture and data. Table 3 shows that the the GrowthLoss leads to fewer spurious height decreases, and Figure 9 shows that the piecewise design matters to deal with disturbances.
We are not able to provide any quantitative evidence for the contribution of the model architecture in this short (rebuttal) time frame, as training the global model takes substantial computational efforts (8 NVIDIA H200s for 1 week). During the development we started with single-year baselines, such as the one provided by Pauls et al. (2025) or Kacic et al. (2023), however we noticed that there are still unrealistic height fluctuations. To be able to use a loss function across all years (like with the GrowthLoss), our model needs to be able to process all years at once, and we developed the spatiotemporal architecture accordingly. Nevertheless, we evaluated the model on a sample of our validation set, when certain inputs are zeroed out:
Thank you for your comment. We will update the paper to emphasize that the accuracy gain comes from the full pipeline (data, model archticture, training, preprocessing, ...)
[1] Pauls et al. (2025): Capturing Temporal Dynamics in Large-Scale Canopy Tree Height Estimation. Proceedings of the 42nd International Conference on Machine Learning
[2] Kacic et al. (2023): Forest structure characterization in Germany: novel products and analysis based on GEDI, Sentinel-1 and Sentinel-2 data. Remote Sensing, 15(8), 1969.