- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2(+1)
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes SpanWorld, a remote-sensing world model that learns vegetation dynamics from satellite observations and advances its latent spatial state through weather-conditioned transitions. It introduces a partitioned-path learning mechanism that uses observed target images to supervise predictions made by continuing from model-generated intermediate states. On GreenEarthNet, this reduces subsequent-prediction MSE by approximately 11% relative to a same-architecture control, while direct-prediction errors remain similar.
Critical strengths
SpanWorld maintains endpoint accuracy close to direct prediction under unseen temporal partitions, supporting the effectiveness of its shared variable-span transition.
Critical weaknesses
-
The writing is overly abstract, while key architectural details and comparisons with baselines are deferred to the appendix, making the main text insufficiently informative. These should be summarized in the main text to clarify the method and its performance.
-
In the metrics reported in Appendix B.2, SpanWorld underperforms Contextformer 6M, whose architecture it adopts for its history encoder, in terms of forecasting metrics across all four splits.
-
Deep-OSG already includes a training formulation that supervises both direct and composed predictions using observed endpoint states. The paper should clarify the methodological novelty of partitioned-path learning beyond adapting this idea to weather-conditioned vegetation forecasting.
Questions for authors
1.What distinguishes SpanWorld as a world model from a conventional vegetation forecasting model? Beyond this terminology, could you clarify the specific architectural and training contributions introduced over Contextformer?
2.Why does SpanWorld underperform Contextformer 6M, as reported in Appendix B.2? What benefits do the proposed modifications provide that justify this loss in forecasting accuracy?
3.In what application scenarios is a model supporting both direct forecasting and continued prediction from generated intermediate states particularly advantageous? How should one choose between these two prediction modes across different scenarios?
4.How does partitioned-path learning differ from Deep-OSG’s training formulation that supervises both direct and composed predictions using observed endpoint states?
5 comments
Response to Reviewer tFYa — Part 2/3: Forecast accuracy and Deep-OSG
Standard accuracy and the role of the added design
In the metrics reported in Appendix B.2, SpanWorld underperforms Contextformer 6M, whose architecture it adopts for its history encoder, in terms of forecasting metrics across all four splits. Why does SpanWorld underperform Contextformer 6M, as reported in Appendix B.2? What benefits do the proposed modifications provide that justify this loss in forecasting accuracy?
Thank you for asking how standard forecasting accuracy relates to the benefits of the proposed design. To address the accuracy concern, we refined the training configuration and the representation of seasonal and weather conditions within the original state-evolution framework and partitioned-path supervision principle, retrained the models, and evaluated them on the same test splits using the same scoring protocol. The updated three-seed results show that SpanWorld's mean RMSE is close to Contextformer's on all four splits, with relative gaps of approximately 0.4%–2.3%. Full metrics and standard deviations across seeds are reported in Appendix B, Table B2.
The benefit of the proposed design lies in the subsequent use of model-generated states. In the architecture-matched comparison across three paired seeds, SpanWorld has lower mean continuation MSE than the direct-endpoint supervision control on all three evaluated paths, with an 11.94% reduction on the training-unseen 15+35-day path (Table 1). This comparison holds directly supervised dates and additional endpoint images fixed, providing concrete evidence that the supervision path improves continued prediction from generated states.
These two comparisons characterize standard forecasting performance and state-continuation benefits separately; they cannot be directly combined into a single accuracy trade-off. We have not established the specific source of the standard forecasting gap to Contextformer through controlled experiments and therefore do not attribute it to state evolution or partitioned-path training. The revised results show that, at an RMSE level close to Contextformer's, SpanWorld additionally provides a capability for continued prediction from generated states validated by matched experiments. We summarize standard forecasting performance in Section 4.1 and report the core continuation comparison in Section 4.2 and Appendix C.
Relationship to Deep-OSG
How does partitioned-path learning differ from Deep-OSG’s training formulation that supervises both direct and composed predictions using observed endpoint states?
Thank you for raising this comparison. Deep-OSG studies evolution operators for autonomous dynamical systems and includes a formulation that supervises direct and composed predictions using observed endpoint states. SpanWorld differs in its state formulation: it infers latent spatial states from incomplete satellite observation histories, drives a shared variable-span transition with the ordered weather for each interval, and trains the subsequent use of generated states through image prediction. Supervision is applied to the complete image prediction combining the state readout and baseline forecast, while latent intermediate states receive gradients from endpoint-image errors through subsequent transitions.
Partitioned-path learning incorporates this use of states into training. It retains direct supervision at every target date and samples paths with different segment counts and boundaries, training the shared transition to use previously generated states. This design addresses our central question: when all target dates already receive direct supervision, is that sufficient for states generated through partitioned rollout to support accurate subsequent prediction?
We test this question with a matched direct-endpoint control, holding architecture, initialization, training update count, all-date direct supervision, and additional endpoint images fixed, while applying the additional supervision to direct versus partitioned paths. This comparison separates target-date coverage from training generated states through their subsequent use, testing the role of the supervision path within our model.
Results across three paired seeds further validate the effectiveness of this design: SpanWorld achieves lower mean continuation MSE on all three evaluated paths, with an 11.94% reduction relative to the direct-endpoint control on the training-unseen 15+35-day partition (Table 1). The supplementary seed-42 analysis in Appendix C further shows smaller error increases relative to each model’s own direct predictions on all three paths, indicating greater stability in continued prediction from generated states.
In the revised manuscript, we have clarified the relationship to Deep-OSG in Related Work and made the second contribution explicit: training weather-driven state evolution through the subsequent predictive use of generated states.
Response to Reviewer tFYa — Part 3/3: Prediction modes
Direct and continued prediction modes
In what application scenarios is a model supporting both direct forecasting and continued prediction from generated intermediate states particularly advantageous? How should one choose between these two prediction modes across different scenarios?
Thank you for asking about application scenarios and mode selection. The two modes allow SpanWorld to support both target-date queries and continuation of a simulated trajectory within the same model. Direct prediction obtains a target-date forecast from the history-initialized state; continued prediction reuses a generated intermediate state and advances it with the weather for the subsequent interval.
One potential application is staged weather-scenario analysis: several trajectories share historical observations and an initial weather sequence, then consider different subsequent conditions, such as persistent drought or rainfall recovery. With direct prediction, each scenario is evaluated from the initial state using its full weather sequence up to the target date. With continued prediction, the latent spatial state formed through the common preceding evolution can be reused and advanced under each subsequent weather sequence. This makes the preceding evolution a reusable simulation result and places subsequent evolution under different weather scenarios on the same generated-state starting point.
Accordingly, direct prediction is appropriate for obtaining target-date outputs under given conditions, whereas continued prediction is appropriate for extending an existing simulation or branching subsequent trajectories from a common state. Our experiments use subsequent real satellite observations to evaluate the predictive ability needed for such state reuse, and matched controls to study how partitioned-path training affects this ability.
Response to Reviewer tFYa — Part 1/3: Architecture and contribution
Thank you for your specific comments on the method description, standard forecasting performance, and positioning relative to prior work. We have clarified the connections among state initialization, weather-driven transitions, and prediction outputs, and summarized standard forecasting performance. We also clarify the relationship to Deep-OSG and the respective uses of direct and continued prediction. Below, we address these points with the empirical evidence.
Architecture and empirical contribution
Thank you for pointing out that the main text does not make the architecture and performance sufficiently concrete. A key distinction between SpanWorld and Contextformer is that SpanWorld explicitly constructs and advances a spatial state that can be reused for subsequent prediction, in addition to producing forecasts at target dates from historical inputs. Historical observations establish the initial state; weather over the specified interval drives a shared variable-span transition; and the generated state can then enter the same transition again to predict later observations. The state readout and the baseline forecast jointly form the complete output.
This distinction motivates the central question stated in the Introduction: when training already supervises direct predictions from the same initial state at every future target date, is this sufficient for states generated through partitioned rollout to support accurate subsequent prediction? Equivalently, with direct supervision at all target dates, does the state-transition path through which supervision is applied still affect continued prediction? We therefore evaluate both direct forecasting accuracy and the predictive usefulness of intermediate states formed through different partitions, using subsequent real satellite observations as targets. This explicit modeling and evaluation of state evolution and reuse underlies our world-model framing.
Partitioned-path training retains direct supervision at every forecast date and propagates observed endpoint-image errors through generated states and their subsequent transitions. The matched direct-endpoint control uses the same architecture, initialization, common training settings, and additional supervision endpoints, focusing the comparison on the supervision path. This design distinguishes supervision of a target date from training the generated states along a path through their subsequent predictive use.
Results across three paired seeds further support this design: SpanWorld achieves lower mean continuation MSE on all three evaluated paths, with an 11.94% reduction relative to the direct-endpoint supervision control on the training-unseen 15+35-day partition (Table 1). With directly supervised dates and additional endpoint images held fixed, these results demonstrate improved subsequent prediction from generated states through partitioned-path training, providing concrete empirical support for our state-modeling contribution.
In Section 3.1 of the revised manuscript, we have clarified the connections among historical encoding, state initialization, weather-driven transitions, and the complete prediction output, and added a standard forecasting summary in Section 4.1. Across three seeds, SpanWorld achieves lower mean RMSE on all four test splits than the weather-conditioned ConvGRU and the adapted evaluation of released EO-WM weights. The main text thus presents the concrete method and main findings; full metrics and between-seed variability are provided in Appendix B, and implementation details in Appendix A.