- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents ChronoMesh, a two-stage practical approach to age editing while preserving facial identity and compatibility with conventional mesh-based rendering pipelines. The proposed approach separates facial aging into macro-scale geometric deformation and fine-scale material editing. The framework is trained and evaluated using FFHQ-UV-Intrinsics, with experiments demonstrating age-conditioned facial deformation and wrinkle synthesis across a wide range of target ages. Quantitative and qualitative comparisons suggest that the method achieves improved identity preservation and age control under its primary evaluation metrics while producing editable 3D mesh assets with explicit wrinkle-normal details.
Critical strengths
The paper addresses an practical problem in 3D character creation by enabling age editing directly on mesh-based head assets. Unlike image-based or neural-rendering-based aging methods, the proposed framework produces geometry and UV-space material maps that can be used in conventional rendering pipelines. This representation is particularly valuable for applications requiring explicit geometry, editable materials, and consistent relighting.
Also, the two-stage formulation provides a reasonable solution to the optimization interference between macro-scale shape deformation and high-frequency wrinkle synthesis.
Critical weaknesses
The proposed framework primarily combines existing techniques, including FLAME-based geometric deformation, StyleGAN2 latent editing, pivotal tuning inversion, differentiable rendering, and age-estimator-based supervision. In particular, Stage 1 employs a relatively straightforward residual prediction network in FLAME shape space, while Stage 2 largely extends the existing SAM framework to UV-space intrinsic maps using separate generators. Although the proposed two-stage training strategy and normal-map supervision are practically meaningful, the technical novelty of the individual components beyond their integration appears somewhat limited. The paper would benefit from a clearer distinction between its methodological contributions and existing approaches to geometric age transformation and latent-space face editing.
Although the proposed method achieves the lowest age error under MiVOLO, which is also used for training, its performance under DEX is weaker than that of several existing methods. Furthermore, the qualitative results do not consistently demonstrate clear improvements over the baselines, particularly considering that some of these methods operate in different domains and are not directly comparable to the proposed approach.
Questions for authors
Could the authors provide additional evaluation of a human perceptual study to demonstrate that the generated appearances accurately reflect their target ages?
Could the authors clarify what is meant by "consistent relighting" in Figure 1? The figure does not present results under different lighting conditions, making it difficult to assess whether the proposed method achieves consistent appearance across varying illumination settings.
3 comments
Follow-up on Q1: human perceptual study
We have completed a human perceptual study, and the latest revised PDF includes it (Sec. 4.2, App. J). This replaces our answer to Q1 above, in which we wrote that we had not been able to complete such a study. The full summary is in our comment "Update: human perceptual study added to the revision"; in short:
- Setup. Nineteen participants compared our method with the two 3D editing baselines, GaussianAvatar-Editor and FaceG2E, on 28 subjects and four target ages (10, 20, 60, 80). For each result, they estimated the age change relative to a render of the input mesh, and they ranked the three results by identity.
- Identity. Our method is ranked first in 64% of the answers (GaussianAvatar-Editor 33%, FaceG2E 3%) and higher than both baselines (p < 0.0001). By target age, it is ranked first most often at 10 and 20 (86% and 99%), about as often as GaussianAvatar-Editor at 60 (48% vs. 51%), and less often at 80 (24% vs. 68%).
- Age. The mean absolute errors are 17.2 years (ours), 18.4 (GaussianAvatar-Editor), and 27.1 (FaceG2E). Ours and GaussianAvatar-Editor do not differ significantly (p = 0.21), and both are lower than FaceG2E (p < 0.0001). Our results look 12.0 years younger than intended on average, which agrees with the DEX and Qwen3-VL results rather than with MiVOLO (cf. W2).
- Caveats. The subjects were selected by the quality of the GaussianAvatar-Editor results, which may favor GaussianAvatar-Editor, and none of them is 50 or older.
While the overall direction is reasonable, the contribution and maturity of the manuscript are not yet sufficient for acceptance.
I believe the authors could further develop the methodology and provide more rigorous experiments to make the paper ready for a future venue.
Response to Reviewer LBXV
Thank you for the review. The new evaluation (a second estimator, Qwen3-VL, and two additional 3D baselines) is summarized in the general response.
W1: novelty beyond the integration of existing techniques
We agree that the individual components are established, and the revision now says so. Sec. 5 separates what is reused from what is specific to our method.
W2: weaker results under DEX, and baselines from different domains
Age accuracy. We agree. MiVOLO is our training supervision, so its low error is not evidence of age accuracy. With DEX and with the newly added Qwen3-VL, neither of which is a training loss, our error is about 15 years, and several methods are more accurate in age. The revision states this in Sec. 4.2 and Sec. 6, and Table 2 no longer highlights our MiVOLO value. What our method retains is the highest identity similarity of all methods, also with ArcFace, which is not used in our training.
Different domains. To our knowledge, no existing method edits an existing mesh together with its diffuse, normal, and specular UV maps, so no baseline operates in exactly our domain. Sec. 4.2 now describes the baselines as three groups: (i) image-based editors applied to renders of the input mesh, which show what is achievable in image space but do not produce 3D assets; (ii) meshes reconstructed from the SAM and FADING outputs with ID-Sculpt; and (iii) two 3D editing methods, FaceG2E and GaussianAvatar-Editor, which are now part of the quantitative comparison. Among the 3D methods, GaussianAvatar-Editor and SAM+ID-Sculpt have lower age errors than ours but much lower identity similarity (ArcFace 0.467 and 0.209 vs. 0.786), and FaceG2E, whose identity similarity is closest to ours (0.741), has about twice our age error. FaceG2E and GaussianAvatar-Editor also require a separate optimization per subject and target age (about 1.5 and 7.7 hours per subject for 11 target ages, vs. about 1.6 minutes for ours).
Qualitative results. The comparison in Sec. 4.2 now reports the trade-off above instead of an overall "best" claim. Fig. 4 and Figs. 8 to 13 show the corresponding differences between the methods.
Q1: human perceptual study
We agree that a human perceptual study would provide valuable complementary evidence. Prior work has shown that human age judgments exhibit systematic biases and variability across observers and stimuli (Voelkle et al., 2012; Clifford et al., 2018). A study suited to our rendered faces therefore requires careful design and pilot testing to account for these effects. We were unable to complete such a study in time for this revision. Instead, we added an evaluation with Qwen3-VL, which was not used in training, to examine whether the age edits generalize beyond the training estimator. This additional automatic evaluation does not replace human perceptual validation, which remains a limitation of the present work.
Q2: "consistent relighting"
We meant that, because wrinkles are stored in the normal maps rather than baked into the diffuse map, the edited asset can be rendered under new lighting with a standard renderer and the shading of the wrinkles follows the light. We agree that the term was unclear. The revision replaces the term with "relightable" (Sec. 1, Sec. 4.2) and adds Fig. 17 with App. I, which show the edited assets of Fig. 1 rendered in Blender under four lighting conditions at target ages 10, 20, 60, and 80.
We would be glad to clarify any remaining points.
References