- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3(−1)
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper presents TOPOS for single-image-conditioned 3D head generation with uniform topology and relightable texture maps. TOPOS-VAE maps unstructured point clouds to fixed-topology meshes, TOPOS-DiT generates its latent tokens conditioned on portrait images, and TOPOS-Texture fine-tunes Qwen-Image-Edit via LoRA to produce UV textures. The reported results show improved geometric accuracy and strong texture-generation performance compared with the evaluated methods.
Critical strengths
1.TOPOS directly generates head meshes with consistent MetaHuman topology, supporting downstream rigging and character animation. The demonstrated rig-driven facial expressions show the practical value of this design for production pipelines. 2.TOPOS-Texture produces relightable and geometry-consistent UV texture maps from a single portrait image. The comparisons under different lighting conditions show high-fidelity skin textures and accurate color reproduction.
Critical weaknesses
1.The benefit of using diverse-topology meshes is not directly validated. TOPOS-VAE is trained on and evaluated on MetaHuman-topology meshes, without a separate cross-topology reconstruction test. It could be helpful to separately report the geometric fidelity of converting inputs with other source topologies to the target topology, and compare the results of TOPOS-DiT trained only on with those of TOPOS-DiT trained on the full .
2.The texture evaluation does not fully isolate the contribution of TOPOS-Texture. Table 3 compares renderings of each method’s generated geometry and textures, although geometry quality already differs substantially in Table 2. Generating textures for the same mesh using different methods could help assess the contribution of TOPOS-Texture more directly.
3.TOPOS-Texture is trained on the full , but the paper does not explain whether these assets need to have UV layouts compatible with the target MetaHuman layout. If so, how such compatibility is established.
4.There may be a minor presentation issue with the numerical formatting in the tables. or example, NC is reported as 0.6546 for MeshAnythingV2 and 0.818 for TreeMeshGPT, using different numbers of significant figures.
Questions for authors
1.How many input points are used, and how are point features extracted or encoded from the point cloud? This is not fully discussed in the paper.
2.The paper claims that its graph convolution update is more effective than previous graph convolutions with MLP update functions, but does not report a direct comparison between these two formulations. Therefore it does not directly validate the advantage of this specific design. How much improvement does this update provide over graph convolutions with MLP update functions?
8 comments
Evaluation of TOPOS-Texture
We thank the reviewer for the suggestion. We agree that the rendered comparisons in Table 3 reflect the combined quality of geometry and textures. However, different texture generation methods, especially 3DMM-based approaches, are designed for specific mesh topologies and rely on their predefined UV parameterizations. Therefore, directly generating textures for the same mesh across these methods is not straightforward without additional topology conversion or texture transfer, which could introduce extra errors and compromise the fairness of the comparison.
To better isolate the contribution of TOPOS-Texture, we also provide ablation studies in Table 3 and Fig. 10, where the geometry generation pipeline remains unchanged. These results demonstrate the effectiveness of our texture-specific designs, including the removal of VL image tokens and the gradual resolution training strategy.
UV layout compatibility of the training dataset D with the MetaHuman layout
Yes, all training textures in share the same canonical MetaHuman UV layout. Although the meshes have different topologies, their textures were originally authored to follow this unified MetaHuman UV layout. Since TOPOS-Texture directly learns the mapping from 2D images to UV textures without explicit 3D geometry conditioning, its training is independent of mesh connectivity and only requires texture maps aligned with the target UV layout. In principle, meshes with other topologies can also be used by converting their textures to the MetaHuman UV layout offline.
Benefits of Diverse-Topology Meshes
We thank the reviewer for the valuable suggestion. We actually conducted cross-topology reconstruction experiments but did not include them in the original submission due to the nine-page limit. We have now included these results in Fig. 12 (page 10) of the revised paper. As shown in the figure, TOPOS-VAE can serve as a topology unifier, converting point clouds sampled from meshes with diverse topologies into the unified MetaHuman topology while preserving geometric details and facial identity. Furthermore, we use the full dataset D instead of only DM to increase the scale and diversity of the training data, thereby improving the generative capability of TOPOS-DiT.