- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
WindMiL introduces a dataset of 462 building-flow simulations covering 66 geometries and seven wind directions. It also proposes a graph model that combines representations of original and reflected geometries to enforce reflection symmetry. The experiments examine pressure and load prediction across random and geometry-extrapolation splits.
Critical strengths
The dataset is a useful contribution. I appreciate the effort involved in generating the LES cases and evaluating both mean pressure and pressure variability. The geometry-based splits also make the evaluation more informative by testing how well models handle shapes outside the training region.
The physical motivation is sensible, and the pressure results are encouraging. Reflection symmetry is appropriate for the setting considered here. WindMiL achieves the lowest reported mean-pressure RMSE across all three original test splits. On edge extrapolation, the improvement over augmented GraphSAGE is about 7.9% (Table 1).
Critical weaknesses
!) It is unclear how much the proposed averaging strategy adds beyond a simpler alternative. A straightforward comparison would average a baseline’s predictions on the original and reflected inputs. This would also enforce exact reflection consistency. Without that comparison, it is difficult to tell how much benefit comes specifically from averaging learned representations. Results across multiple training seeds would also help establish whether the accuracy improvements are consistent.
-
I could not reconcile the descriptions of the load-prediction experiment. Section 4.2 suggests that Table 2 shows improved pressure predictions translating into better integrated loads. Appendix A.4, however, describes separately trained graph-level predictors. These support different conclusions: accurate force predictions from a separate model do not establish that integrating the predicted pressure field gives accurate forces. The construction of force-standard-deviation targets and the hitrate thresholds also need clarification.
-
The authors have not benchmarked their approach against state-of-the-art neural solvers such as transolver/++, abupt, geotransolver, etc. I see this as the biggest limitation and therefore a reason for rejection.
Questions for authors
-
How does WindMiL compare with averaging the original/reflected outputs of GS and GSDAG? How consistent are the gains across training seeds?
-
Does Table 2 use integrated pressure predictions or separately trained load predictors? Are force-standard-deviation labels calculated from LES force time histories, and what numerical hitrate thresholds are used?
-
Appendix A.1 lists 361 training/validation cases and 105 test cases, totaling 466 rather than 462. Could you clarify the correct split counts?