- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a denoising framework for 3D T1-weighted MRI volumes that combines DINO-based conditioning with a Latte-style latent diffusion model. By jointly restoring adjacent slices through spatial and cross-slice attention, the framework aims to preserve anatomical continuity. Experiments on synthetically corrupted AOMIC and zero-shot OASIS data report improved through-plane consistency over selected slice-wise baselines, with competitive SSIM at higher noise levels.
Critical strengths
The paper is well written and easy to follow. Using frozen DINO features from noisy slices to condition a clip-level latent diffusion model is interesting. The spatiotemporal denoiser exchanges information across adjacent slices, explicitly considering anatomical continuity rather than processing each slice independently. Experiments on synthetically corrupted in vivo images show improved through-plane consistency relative to the F=1 variant and the selected slice-wise baselines, while maintaining competitive SSIM at higher tested noise levels.
Critical weaknesses
Limited comparison with MRI-specific denoising methods. Although RDDM is included, comparisons with MRI-specific methods such as DDM², Di-Fusion, and Corruption2Self are missing. These self-supervised methods are relevant for assessing the benefit of requiring clean training targets. The authors should compare against applicable methods or explain specific incompatibilities. Di-Flow may require discussion because it exploits neighboring slices for diffusion-based denoising of a single MRA volume. A suitable 2.5D or 3D baseline would further clarify the advantage of the proposed architecture.
Unclear practical relevance to low-SNR T1-weighted MRI. All experiments use synthetic Rician noise added to reference images, leaving performance on genuinely noisy acquisitions unverified. The authors should identify the intended acquisition setting and justify whether the tested noise levels and characteristics are representative of that setting. Evaluation on genuinely low-SNR in vivo T1-weighted images would substantially strengthen the practical relevance. Evaluation on another MRI contrast, such as diffusion MRI, would additionally demonstrate the framework’s broader applicability.
Limited methodological novelty. The framework largely adapts Latte’s existing spatial–temporal attention architecture to MRI slices, with DINO conditioning and task-specific regularization. While this adaptation may be useful, the current comparisons and ablations do not sufficiently establish the added value of these modifications beyond applying an existing video diffusion backbone to volumetric denoising.
Limited validation of anatomical continuity. Reporting both T-LPIPS gap and T-ΔMAE provides useful evidence of through-plane consistency. However, these metrics do not fully establish faithful preservation of 3D anatomy: similar inter-slice perceptual distances need not imply correct anatomical transitions, and errors shared across adjacent slices can cancel in T-ΔMAE. Given that anatomical continuity is a central motivation, complementary validation—such as sagittal/coronal visualizations, inspection of sliding-window boundaries, or a structure-sensitive downstream evaluation—would strengthen the claim.
Questions for authors
See Weakness