acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

PA-WAM: Progress-Aligned World–Action Model for Long-Horizon Robot Manipulation

Abstract

World–Action Models (WAMs) provide dynamics supervision for robot policies by predicting future states, but in long-horizon manipulation, a small future-representation error does not necessarily imply correct task-stage advancement.Existing future-reconstruction objectives implicitly contain stage changes in demon-strations, yet do not explicitly distinguish how different prediction biases affect task progress. We propose Progress-Aligned World–Action Model (PA-WAM), which introduces history-conditioned stage-transition supervision into LaWAM’s latent future learning. PA-WAM first aligns successful demonstrations for the same task to construct a continuous stage coordinate, and uses current manipulation evidence and multi-scale history to predict the nominal transition within a fixed horizon;then, Bidirectional Progress–Dynamics Coupling (BPDC) uses this transition to modulate the latent action query and constrains the stage change of the generated future through a frozen progress readout. The target–readout consistency objective is jointly optimized with future reconstruction and action imitation, while the readback branch is used only during training. Compared with LaWAM, PA-WAM improves the average success rate on LIBERO from 98.6% to 99.2%, with the largest gain on Long, from 97.0% to 98.2%; on MimicGen-D1, it improves from 81.8% to 84.3%. Across three RM65 real-robot tasks, the average success rate increases from 82.2% to 87.8%. These results indicate that treating task progress as an internal constraint on future generation can improve the execution capability of world–action models in long-horizon robot manipulation while preserving local dynamics modeling.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
World-Action Models, Robot Manipulation, Long-Horizon Manipulation, Vision-Language-Action Models, Latent World Models, Progress Alignment

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 9%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.50 over 4 reviews, above 9% of the others.
Reviewer_5YxzOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes PA-WAM: Progress-Aligned World-Action Model, for Long-Horizon Robot Manipulation. It essentially creates a progress "exemplar history" from task-specific demonstrations, and use that to guide the WAM to generate the new future representation token for action decoding. The core attention mechanism for modulating the latent action queries seems to be flawed. The design concept raises concerns on how generalisable this approach is, especially for challenging cases where unfamiliar progress structures or recovery behavior might be required, as PA-WAM's progress prior may become unreliable outside the successful demonstration distribution, and this is not sufficient address in the empirical evidence.

Critical strengths
  • The motivation behind the proposed method is straightforward, and reasonable. Extracting exemplar progress + transition targets from the collective demonstration trajectory and using them to guide the World model for future generation conceptually grounds the WM's future prediction be more "state-aware", hence improving the WM's capability in assimilating "dominant behaviors under similar conditions" while generating future rep tokens for a specific task.
  • The evaluation shows promising results in simulation-based benchmarks and three real-world manipulation tasks.
  • The ablation study includes a broad range of useful controls.
Critical weaknesses
  • The attention mechanism defined in Sec4.3 raises serious questions - with identical keys and values, it degenerates to a broadcast conditioning vector as the query gets cancelled in the derivation, meaning that the results of the attention is irrelevant to the input query, and every query just receives the same conditioning vector as long as C^p_t remains the same.
  • Most of the reported improvements (over strongest baselines) are modest, and uncertainty reporting is insufficient.
  • The core design principle triggers concerns over generalizability e.g. recovery after failed grasps, object displacement, etc. CALVIN ABC→D provides some evidence of environmental generalization, but does not directly resolve this concern. Would be great to have a focused experiment to validate the flexibility/generalizability of PA-WAM.
Questions for authors
  • Why replicate the condition vector as both K and V for the attention?
Reviewer_rER2OpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper introduces Progress-Aligned World–Action Model, PA-WAM, which uses a two-stage training setting to enforce consistency between progress conditions and predicted future. Experimental results on simulation benchmark such as LIBERO and three real-world tasks show improved success rates.

Critical strengths

The paper proposes a two-stage training framework that incorporates task-progress conditioning for robotic manipulation.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The paper is hard to follow, as excessive conceptual terminology obscures the technical presentation.
  2. The main paper lacks experimental visualizations, including images of the real-world setup and rollout comparisons with baselines. Besides, training hardware and computational costs, as well as analysis of inference latency for real-world deployment are missing.
Questions for authors
  1. How accurately the Stage I module estimates task progress remains unclear, and it may depend heavily on demonstration quality, for example, prolonged pauses or hesitant robot movements could distort the learned progress estimates.
  2. Despite the performance gains, the paper lacks convincing evidence that the proposed method corrects task-progress errors in predicted futures, i.e., the central problem motivating the work.
Reviewer_iyLKOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes PA-WAM, a post-training method built on a pretrained latent world-action model, LaWAM. For each task, it aligns successful demonstrations to a medoid demonstration with Soft-DTW to obtain a continuous progress coordinate. A Progress Transition Model (PTM) then predicts the current coordinate and the nominal progress change over a fixed 1.2 s horizon from short-window evidence and multi-scale recurrent memory. Bidirectional Progress–Dynamics Coupling (BPDC) uses this target in two ways: it modulates LaWAM's latent action queries, and it adds a training-only loss that requires a frozen progress readout of the generated future latent to match the target transition. Experiments on LIBERO, MimicGen-D1, CALVIN ABC→D and three RM65 real-robot tasks show improvements over LaWAM. Component ablations and hyperparameter sweeps are reported on MimicGen-D1.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper addresses an important and timely problem. Using higher-level information such as task progress to constrain the latent future of a WAM is well motivated: future-reconstruction error does not directly measure whether a predicted future advances the task, and the paper articulates this gap clearly.
  2. The method operates at the post-training stage and reuses a pretrained WAM rather than training a new one. This keeps it lightweight and relevant to task-specific adaptation and deployment.
  3. The components retained at deployment are lightweight, and no test-time search or iterative optimization is required.
  4. The ablations of the method's own components are thorough, the implementation details are clearly described, and the limitations are discussed candidly.
Critical weaknesses

W1. Evidence and generalization

  1. The gains are small. Many of the improvements are on the same order as evaluation noise. Although PA-WAM improves over LaWAM on several benchmarks, the gains are modest overall, and LIBERO is already saturated. LaWAM itself reports results on RoboTwin 2.0, which is less saturated and is commonly used to compare recent WAMs. Why is it not included?

  2. Generalization is not evaluated, even though it is commonly a main reason to build on a pretrained WAM, especially for a method positioned as downstream adaptation. For a post-training method on top of a pretrained WAM, the key question is whether it preserves and exploits the pretrained prior. In particular:

    (a) The progress coordinate is built by aligning successful demonstrations of the same task. By construction, it therefore does not extend to a new task without new demonstrations and a re-run of Stage I. Task-specific adaptation is a reasonable setting in itself, but the authors should then at least characterize in-task OOD behavior, and apart from the environment shift in CALVIN ABC→D, the paper contains no such test. I suggest adding a perturbation benchmark such as LIBERO-Plus, which varies object layout, camera viewpoint, lighting and initial state.

    (b) History conditioning is known to induce spurious correlations in behavior cloning, and PTM conditions on executed history, including past actions (Eq. 9). This makes OOD and generalization tests all the more necessary.

    (c) For reference only (concurrent arXiv work, not a factor in my rating): ProWAM (arXiv 2609.06578), which also conditions WAM future utilization on estimated progress, evaluates on LIBERO and RoboTwin 2.0, among other benchmarks. I do not expect a comparison with it, but it illustrates the level of evaluation expected for this kind of claim.

    (d) Relatedly, MemoryVLA appears only in the real-robot comparison (Table 4), not in simulation. Since multi-scale history is a core component, a memory-dependent benchmark such as MIKASA-Robo would be informative (optional, and also not a factor in my rating).

  3. Hyperparameter sensitivity. Table 9 contains 11 non-default settings. Six of them fall below LaWAM's 81.8, and two more match it exactly. In other words, moving a single hyperparameter to a neighboring value often removes the entire gain.

W2. Mechanism of PTM and BPDC

The predicted future itself is not analyzed, so it remains unclear whether BPDC actually learns a task-progress-aware future representation.

The paper's core claim is that constraining the latent future with progress consistency yields a predicted future that is not only close to the true future in representation space but also encodes more task-progress information. However, the paper offers almost no analysis of the predicted future itself. The appendix provides qualitative execution examples, but these do not show the model's internal future predictions, its progress readouts, or how the two relate.

Moreover, Soft-DTW fundamentally solves a trajectory-alignment problem. The aligned coordinate may carry progress information, but it does not necessarily correspond to semantically meaningful task stages. The authors acknowledge this: the coordinate "retains the reference demonstration's temporal allocation" (Section 4.1) and represents "relative temporal position rather than the completion ratio of equally sized subtasks" (Section 3). A concurrent controlled study (arXiv 2609.24048) finds that generated futures influence WAM actions mainly through their temporal structure. My concern is therefore that a substantial part of the observed gain may come from better modeling of temporal structure rather than from a genuine task-level understanding of semantic progress. The Linear Progress ablation (82.3 vs. 84.3) shows that alignment helps compared with per-demonstration normalized time, but it does not show that the model learns stage semantics.

I am therefore not convinced that BPDC achieves the claimed progress-aware future modeling rather than acting mainly as an indirect regularizer. This matters because the paper's original motivation is precisely that ordinary latent reconstruction error does not reliably reflect task progress. If the progress target ultimately remains largely a heuristic temporal alignment, the original claim should be narrowed accordingly.

Questions for authors

For a work on task adaptation of a pretrained WAM, I consider the following necessary:

  1. In-task OOD robustness evaluation, e.g., on a perturbation benchmark such as LIBERO-Plus, to show how the progress constraint behaves out of distribution.
  2. A second backbone, such as Fast-WAM or Motus, to show that the method is not specific to one architecture.

To better support the core claim, I also consider the following necessary:

  1. Mechanism analyses or representative case studies of PTM and BPDC, as described in W2, that more directly examine the relationship between the progress coordinate, real task-stage transitions, and the predicted future.

Additional results that would strengthen the paper: RoboTwin 2.0, a memory-dependent benchmark, like MIKASA-Robo(the one that MemoryVLA used)

Overall, the idea is reasonable and well motivated, but the current evidence does not yet show that the gains come from task-progress information in the predicted future, or that they hold beyond the training distribution.

Reviewer_zXqkOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This work proposes PA-WAM for long-horizon robotic manipulation, addressing the problem that more accurate future-state predictions do not necessarily lead to task progress. The method first aligns successful demonstrations to construct a continuous progress coordinate, then combines current observations with multiscale history to predict feasible progress over a fixed time horizon. This progress target both conditions future-state generation and constrains the predictions through a frozen progress readout module. The model is trained jointly with state reconstruction and action imitation objectives.

Critical strengths

This work identifies a specific problem in future-state prediction: lower representation error does not necessarily mean that the robot is closer to completing the task. For example, after placing an object, the model may predict a visually plausible future state without correctly transitioning to the next operation. By explicitly incorporating such stage deviations into the training objective, the paper presents a clear motivation that reflects practical challenges in long-horizon manipulation.

The construction of progress labels accounts for differences in execution speed across demonstrations. The same operation may take different amounts of time in different trajectories, so directly using normalized time as progress can assign different labels to the same stage. The paper first aligns successful demonstrations using Soft-DTW and then applies a monotonic projection. It also reduces supervision weights at positions where the alignment is less concentrated. These steps provide a more nuanced approach than directly using time-based labels.

The progress target both conditions future-state generation and evaluates the generated results, providing a more comprehensive constraint. The model first adjusts latent queries according to the target progress, and a progress readout module then checks whether the generated future reflects the intended change. The loss function thus provides feedback on whether the model actually uses the progress condition, rather than simply supplying it as an additional input and leaving the model to learn how to use it.

Critical weaknesses

The aligned progress coordinate remains influenced by the reference demonstration’s allocation of time. The end of Section 4.1 states that this construction retains the reference trajectory’s temporal allocation as the coordinate scale. Thus, if the reference demonstration spends more time on a particular step, that step may occupy a larger portion of the progress interval even if it is not more important. Soft-DTW mitigates differences in execution speed across demonstrations but does not fully eliminate the progress coordinate’s dependence on the pacing of a particular demonstration. The paper does not report how changing the reference trajectory affects the labels or final performance.

The progress module learns exclusively from successful demonstrations, and its behavior in states resulting from execution failures is not specifically evaluated. Sections 3 and 4 construct progress and transition targets from successful trajectories. During deployment, however, the robot may miss a grasp, drop an object, or undo a previously completed placement. In such cases, the amount of progress expected next in a successful demonstration may no longer be an appropriate target. The real-robot experiments evaluate overall task success rates but do not separately test recovery after perturbations. This issue is distinct from whether the task follows a fixed sequence: even with a fixed step order, execution can deviate from successful trajectories.

Some of the most closely related methods are absent from the experimental comparisons. The related work section describes DiM-WAM as combining historical memory with auxiliary task-progress supervision, while StageWAM uses next-stage representations to guide future modeling. Both are directly relevant to assessing the distinct contributions of this paper, yet neither appears in the main experimental tables. The results demonstrate that PA-WAM outperforms the selected base models, but they do not establish how much additional benefit its fixed-horizon transition targets and progress readout constraints provide over other world–action models that already incorporate stage information.

The performance gap relative to ProgressVLA cannot be attributed entirely to the proposed progress design. Table 1 shows a 14.7-percentage-point difference in average success rate on LIBERO. Although the paper explicitly controls base-model initialization and training budgets for its internal comparisons, it does not provide equally detailed evidence of matched settings for external methods such as ProgressVLA. Differences in backbones, pretraining, and action-generation mechanisms may all affect performance. To compare matching feasible progress with other forms of progress guidance, a more convincing experiment would vary the training objective while keeping the base model fixed.

Questions for authors

see weaknesses

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.