- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3(+1)
Read review
Paper summary
The paper builds on the pretrained GigaWorld-Policy-0.5 WAM [1], adapting its action interface for whole-body control and adding auxiliary language supervision. A frozen model describes task progress and anticipated changes from current and future training frames, and the resulting text embeddings supervise intermediate future-visual features. Evaluation includes simulation and real-robot tasks.
Critical strengths
The experiments show improvements, including on real world robot. The ablations provide evidence that the correspondence and content of the language targets matter.
Critical weaknesses
Novelty is limited. The method builds on an existing pretrained WAM, and mainly adds an auxiliary language alignment loss. The contribution appears to be an incremental adaptation of established representation-alignment techniques [1–3].
[1] GigaWorld-Policy-0.5 — GigaWorld Team et al.
Questions for authors
Under the same backbone and training budget, how does the method compare with other semantic-alignment methods?
Is Language Forcing compatible with other WAM improvements, and does combining them yield additional gains beyond either method alone?
Beyond using existing humanoid control and benchmarking frameworks, which aspects of Language Forcing itself are specifically designed for humanoid whole-body control, and how do they differ from related alignment methods in robot arm manipulation or VLN?
3 comments
Thank you for your responses to my three questions, which have addressed my concerns, particularly the clarifications regarding the novelty and boundary of the work. I recommend that the authors strengthen the clarification of the boundary in the main text to better highlight the novelty.
In addition, the results of LF on different backbones demonstrate the generalizability of the proposed method.
I consider this a simple but meaningful direction for improving humanoid WAM, and I will raise my score accordingly.
Thank you for the response
We thank Reviewer 6AFM for your encouraging feedback and for recognizing the value of Language-Forcing for humanoid WAMs. We are glad that our responses addressed your concerns and clarified the contribution. Thank you again for your time, careful review, and helpful suggestions.
Comment for Reviewer 6AFM
We thank Reviewer 6AFM for asking where the method differs from established alignment techniques and whether it transfers across WAM improvements. These are important questions for defining the contribution precisely.
As also explained in our response to Reviewer 8hce, the matched visual-target control gives the following comparison. We include the result here for readability. only the alignment target changes.
Giga-World-Policy-0.5We thank Reviewer 6AFM for pointing us to WorldScape Policy 2.0, an important related direction. The methods address different learning targets: WorldScape uses event-caption supervision for planning representations, whereas Language-Forcing uses paired current/future observations to provide transition-specific progress and next-state supervision for action-conditioned future-visual features. This difference in target, representation, and use of the action trajectory is fundamental, so the two methods should not be treated as interchangeable versions of the same method.
The compatibility results are:
The within-backbone comparisons show that LF adds a gain beyond the alternative WAM improvements, while the auxiliary head provides a separate compute-matched reference.
We thank the reviewer for asking us to make the whole-body design boundary explicit. Language-Forcing uses a 35D humanoid state/action interface and action-conditioned future-visual features. Its target describes posture, contact, object state, and likely next motion. This matters because humanoid loco-manipulation requires the robot to move and manipulate simultaneously. In many arm-manipulation scenes, the background and lighting are relatively stable and the main changes are the arm and object. A humanoid whole-body policy sees the background, lighting, texture, object, and the robot body change together; large low-value pixel changes can overwhelm the smaller but critical changes in contact, stance, and object state. Language provides a concise task-level regularizer for this imbalance.
VLN also encounters rapid background and lighting changes, so the same principle may transfer to navigation. Because the discussion phase was time-limited, we could not run a broader VLN extension experiment; we leave that study for future work. The tested contribution is a transition-specific language target for an action-conditioned WAM, demonstrated on coordinated humanoid whole-body control. It is not a claim that cosine feature alignment is new in isolation, and it adds no inference-time cost.