- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes the Natural Graph Diffusion Solver (NGD-solver), an inference-time modification for pretrained graph diffusion models. The method starts from the observation that uniform reverse-time steps need not produce uniform changes in the induced transition distributions. For continuous SDE samplers, it uses a local Fisher-Rao metric for Gaussian transitions to set the magnitude of each drift increment while retaining the direction suggested by the model.
Critical strengths
1.The paper focuses on a practical part of generative modeling: the sampling procedure can limit output quality even when the pretrained model is fixed. NGD-solver targets this stage directly and does not require retraining or changing the model architecture. 2.The proposed correction has a clear geometric motivation. The derivation links drift changes in a Gaussian reverse transition to a local Fisher-Rao length, and the implementation is simple enough to integrate into existing samplers. 3.The experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method.
Critical weaknesses
1.The proposed diffusion methods are limited. These more representative methods of discrete diffusion, such as DiGress, cannot be used. This significantly limits the application value of the proposed method. 2.The direction of each corrected drift is taken from the difference between the current model prediction and the previously applied drift, then normalized. The paper should discuss edge cases where this difference is zero or very small and whether normalization becomes unstable. 3.The methodological novelty of NGD-solver appears limited relative to prior information-geometric sampling work. [1] already applies the Fisher–Rao metric to graph diffusion and enforces approximately constant information-geometric progress along the sampling trajectory. NGD-solver’s main distinction appears to be how this constraint is implemented: it rescales drift magnitudes on a fixed time grid, whereas [1] adapts the time discretization. The connection to [2] further suggests that Fisher–Rao geometry has already been used to shape diffusion trajectories outside graph generation. The paper should more clearly establish what theoretical or practical advantage the fixed-grid drift correction offers over these alternatives, and compare directly with [1] under matched models, sampling budgets, and tuning protocols. [1] Information-Geometric Adaptive Sampling for Graph Diffusion. [2] Geodesic Diffusion Models for Efficient Medical Image Enhancement.
4.Following Weakness 3, there is no relevant baseline for comparison. And all the author's analyses before Eq.8 have nothing to do with graph diffusion and can be applied to any SDE field. Therefore, theoretically, the accelerated solver method in the image domain can also be applied for comparison.
Questions for authors
See Weakness