- Rating
- 1(−1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes MCGD, whose core idea is to introduce multiview contrastive learning into the standard denoising training of graph diffusion models. By constructing two augmented views from the same predicted graph and enforcing consistency at both the graph-structure level and the high-level semantic level. Experimental results show that this method improves generation quality on both general graph generation and molecular graph generation tasks, demonstrating the effectiveness of the proposed mtehod.
Critical strengths
- Introducing auxiliary representation-level constraints into diffusion training is a reasonable idea.
- MCGD achieves strong results across several evaluation metrics.
Critical weaknesses
- Theoretical Analysis. In Eq. (3), is the entropy of the data distribution, so it is constant with respect to and provides no gradient signal. Eq. (4) only maximizes a lower bound on this constant, which does not show that becomes closer to . If the goal is to increase the entropy of the generated distribution, the authors should explain why this would improve fidelity rather than harm it.
- Methods. The edge encoder applies an MLP to a flattened, zero-padded adjacency matrix, making the representation dependent on node ordering. This weakens the claim that it captures high-order graph semantics. Its input size also scales as .
- Experiments. Prior work typically includes more datasets, such as Community-small, Grid, and MOSES. The paper should report additional results on these benchmarks. The ablation results do not fully support the conclusions. On QM9, adding the regularizers reduces validity (99.79 → 99.61). Both single-loss variants also outperform full MCGD on scaffold similarity.
Questions for authors
Please see the Weaknesses.
Reply to Authors
Dear Authors,
Thank you for your rebuttal. I will keep my current score because the reply still doesn't address some of the concerns raised. First, the authors are still working on bigger datasets, which is not currently ready. Second, my second weakness point is still there where the improvements are very small. Because of that, I will keep my current score.