- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents GD-Mamba, a graph generation framework that alternates denoising between the graph domain and a continuous latent space. A graph-latent mapping module (GLMM) encodes node and edge features into latent representations and decodes them back into graphs. The framework uses a graph-domain Mamba denoiser (G-Mamba) and a latent-space diffusion model with selective state-space blocks (S-Mamba/SSDM); intermediate latent features are used to condition graph denoising. The authors also introduce multiscale wavelet positional encoding (MSW-PE) in the GLMM attention layers.
Critical strengths
1.The paper addresses a relevant challenge in graph generation: combining discrete structure topology and attributes with continuous representations 2. The overall structure of the paper is quite clear.
Critical weaknesses
1.This paper is extremely poorly written and disorganized. For instance, "where changes occur as discrete jumps between entities" The internal "entity" is usually used for kg nodes rather than graph nodes. Moreover, the term "discret jump" is very confusing. I understand it to refer to a kind of edge that is more like a discrete transition probability. However, they often represent regular changes rather than sudden mutations. Additionally, DDPM_reverse does not mention citing the DDPM paper, but the author only states that it is the inverse process of the diffusion model. However, there are many different versions of diffusion model. Therefore, this is not rigorous. Also, S-Mamba/SSDM appear multiple times, making it difficult to determine exactly what they should be called. For models, a mathematical symbol rather than a name is usually used to represent them, and the author's use of symbols is also very poor. 2.The figures in the paper are difficult to read. For instance, in Fig. 1, the font size of the formula on the left side is too small, and the color combination on the right side is very unclear. 3.The baselines compared in the paper are all extremely outdated. They are mainly published before 2024. All related papers for graph generation published at 2025 and 2026 did not make any comparisons. Overall, I think there are very serious problems in all aspects of this paper and it does not meet the standards of ICLR.
Questions for authors
See Weakness.