acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Breaking the Environment Wall: A Unified Framework for Preparing and Evolving Agent-Native Environments

Abstract

Many real-world tasks (e.g., office workflows, scientific experimentation) require LLM agents to interact repeatedly with their environments for context-dependent operations. However, such environments are often not agent-ready. First, information is often scattered and fragmented across the environment. Second, relevant evidence in the environment is often mixed with misleading information and conflicting versions. Third, environments evolve over time, introducing new noise and more challenging tasks. These challenges can substantially degrade performance for state-of-the-art AI agents (e.g., from 83.9% to 57.6%). To address these challenges, we propose Env-Rethink (a system with 27B post-trained model) that supports three main capabilities: (1) It adaptively builds Collection Maps (for organizing related files) and Event Logs (for contextualizing cross-data relationships) to supplement necessary context; (2) It further leverages the post-trained model (through offline trajectory learning) to identify underlying noise issues in the environment; (3) It ultimately evolves environments through virtual event histories that alter environmental states and evidence relationships, producing more tricky ones for further agent improvement. Experiments show that Env-Rethink can effectively improve downstream task performance (with a 15.1 percentage-point increase in mean rubric pass rate across nine models on 30 tasks).

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
LLM agents, Agent-Native Environments, Environment Preparation, Environment Evolution

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 30%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.67 over 3 reviews, above 70% of the others.
Reviewer_D2dvOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies how fragmented, conflicting, and misleading file evidence affects LLM agents. ENV-RETHINK organizes files through Collection Maps and evidence-reviewed synthetic Event Logs, learns file verification from tool-use trajectories, and evolves environments by changing their states together with reference outcomes and evaluation checks while preserving the user request. Separate studies evaluate organization, learned preparation, and evolution. The preparation model improves mean downstream rubric pass rate from 57.6% to 72.7% across nine models on 30 tasks adapted from Workspace-Bench. The evolution study shows reduced agent success on a subset of paired Terminal-Bench environments.

Critical strengths
  1. An important practical problem. Agents working with persistent files must establish which evidence remains valid, beyond finding relevant-looking content. The paper addresses concrete failures involving conflicting versions and withdrawal records. Preparing the environment for this kind of evidence judgment is a useful direction.

  2. Positive evidence for the preparation approach. The learned verifier improves held-out file-partition accuracy, and the prepared environments improve aggregate downstream performance across nine models. The file-selection results also show improved retention of standard files while admitting fewer noise files. These findings support the system's practical potential.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Generalization and attribution of the downstream gains remain insufficiently resolved. The paper reports held-out file classification, but Table 7 pools downstream results over all 30 tasks, including 15 training-source tasks. It therefore does not show how much final-task benefit transfers to the 15 held-out tasks. The preparation conditions also need clarification: Appendix B.5 generally states that the preparation model supplies an evidence report, whereas B.6 describes the unadapted condition as selected files and explicitly mentions an evidence report only for ENV-RETHINK. This wording leaves unclear whether the comparison holds the report interface constant. These gaps limit the interpretation of the gains as transferable improvements from the learned verifier. (Appendix A.3, lines 684–691; B.4, lines 819–832; B.5, line 836; B.6, lines 852–860; Table 7.)

  2. The incremental technical contribution over existing evidence processing is not sufficiently isolated. Related approaches already address conflicting evidence: MADAM-RAG, Section 4 uses document-based agents and debate, while ArbGraph, Section 3 performs evidence arbitration over support and contradiction relations before generation. These are not identical to a file-workspace verifier, but they make the specific benefit of the proposed representation and verification process important to establish. Table 8 provides useful removal ablations under TGS, yet does not establish the benefit of synthetic Event Logs over a simpler evidence-linked index of file relationships. Since TGS also uses task-specific supervision, the information conditions matter for this comparison. (Lines 212–236; Appendix B.7, lines 883–897; Table 8.)

Questions for authors
  1. Held-out downstream performance: The paper already reports held-out file-classification results. Could you additionally break down the downstream results in Table 7 between the 15 training-source tasks and the 15 held-out tasks, and report the retention rate of standard files on the held-out tasks? This would clarify whether the verifier's generalization translates into improvements in final task execution. (Appendix A.3, lines 684–691; B.4, lines 819–832; Table 6, lines 841–847; B.6, lines 852–860; Table 7.)

  2. Added capability and the role of Event Logs: What technical capability does ENV-RETHINK add relative to conflict-aware RAG or evidence-arbitration approaches such as MADAM-RAG and ArbGraph? In particular, what additional value do synthetic Event Logs provide over an evidence-linked index that directly records support, replacement, and withdrawal relationships? A comparison under matched input access, models, and call budgets would help establish this difference. For the organization component, an EGS comparison would avoid the additional labels and rubrics available under TGS. The existing TGS removal ablations are useful, but do not answer this substitution question. (Lines 212–236; Appendix B.7, lines 883–897; Table 8; external sources linked above.)

  3. Matched preparation conditions and cost: Do the unadapted and fine-tuned preparation models use the same tools, evidence-report format, call budget, and downstream interface? Could you also report the time or model-call cost of environment preparation? Specifically, B.5 states that the preparation model supplies an evidence report, while B.6 describes Qwen3.8-27B as using selected files and explicitly describes ENV-RETHINK as using files plus an evidence report. Please clarify whether both conditions supply comparable reports; if their report access differs, a matched-report comparison would help separate the effect of fine-tuning from that of additional context. This is an ambiguity in the description, not evidence that the baseline actually lacks a report. (Appendix B.5, lines 835–839; B.6, lines 852–855.)

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to W1/Q1 · Held-Out Downstream Performance

Thank you for your thoughtful comment. While preparing this split, we found that the downstream runs behind the original Table 7 used a different evaluation version from the one used in the TGS/EGS experiments (Section 5.2, Table 1). We have aligned the evaluation version with the TGS/EGS experiments and re-run the downstream evaluation on all 30 Environment-Hard tasks.

The re-run uses the Claude Code harness with DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash, HY3, and HY4 as downstream models. Environment conditions follow Appendix B.6: Full retains all files in the original environment, while Qwen3.8-27B and Env-Rethink provide files and an evidence report prepared by the unadapted and the trained model, respectively. Following Appendix B.4, the 30 tasks are split into 15 training-source tasks and 15 held-out tasks.

Each condition is repeated three times, and all numbers below are three-trial means. On held-out tasks, Env-Rethink raises the mean rubric pass rate from 78.4% (Full) to 85.8%, 7.4 points above Full and 11.3 points above Qwen3.8-27B (74.5%). Qwen3.8-27B falls below Full (74.5% vs. 78.4%), and it does so for both stronger downstream models (HY4 83.9% → 75.5%, DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash 82.1% → 78.2%). Table 8 shows that Qwen3.8-27B retained fewer standard files than Env-Rethink. This pattern is consistent with false rejection of standard files outweighing the benefit of noise removal. Both preparation conditions supply an evidence report, so the comparison supports the benefit of learned preparation under a shared report interface. Training-source tasks were selected under the criteria in Appendix A.3 (Clean ≥90%; a Noise−Clean contrast of 38–75 percentage points), so their Full baseline is lower and leaves more room for improvement; we therefore compare gains rather than absolute rates across splits. Env-Rethink exceeds Full on held-out tasks in every downstream model (+14.5, +2.6, and +5.2 points for HY3, HY4, and DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash) and exceeds Qwen3.8-27B by 9.1–13.8 points. These results show that improvements in file selection translate into end-task gains on held-out tasks.

The held-out split covers 15 tasks and 617 files. File-partition accuracy on held-out environments rises from 56.2% (Qwen3.8-27B) to 76.5% (Env-Rethink), and joint partition, category, and stage accuracy rises from 19.4% to 32.4%. On the 15 held-out tasks, Env-Rethink retains 93 of 105 standard files (88.6% recall), versus 71 of 105 (67.6%) for Qwen3.8-27B. Precision among files predicted as standard is 41.2% (93/226) versus 27.2% (71/261), respectively. On the 15 training-source tasks, retention is 77.0% (67/87) versus 54.0% (47/87). Files without a model judgment are excluded from these selection metrics.

We have updated the corresponding numbers in the abstract, the downstream results in Table 3 and Appendix Table 9, and the file-selection results in Appendix Table 8. The split-level results appear in Section 5.3 and Appendices B.5–B.6 of the revised manuscript.

Rubric pass rate (%): Full / Qwen3.8-27B / Env-Rethink; Δ in percentage points (three-trial mean)

ModelSplitFullQwen3.8-27BEnv-RethinkΔ vs QwenΔ vs Full
DeepSeek-V4.1-FlashHeld-out82.178.287.3+9.1+5.2
Training-source79.792.596.3+3.8+16.6
All 3080.786.592.5+6.0+11.8
HY3Held-out69.370.083.8+13.8+14.5
Training-source28.857.986.7+28.8+57.9
All 3045.763.085.5+22.5+39.8
HY4Held-out83.975.586.5+11.0+2.6
Training-source91.193.297.2+4.0+6.1
All 3088.185.892.7+6.9+4.6
MeanHeld-out78.474.585.8+11.3+7.4
Training-source66.581.293.4+12.2+26.9
All 3071.578.490.2+11.8+18.7
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to W2/Q2 · Event Logs and Conflict-Aware Baselines

ENV-RETHINK adds source-scoped workspace understanding that connects evidence assessment to file-task execution. The agent can locate related files, determine which sources apply to the requested purpose, and carry that decision into the actual deliverable. Collection Maps, source-grounded histories, and path-triggered retrieval make this context available throughout execution. The learned verifier in A2 further assesses file validity from supporting evidence.

An evidence-linked index can already preserve citations, applicability conditions, and uncertainty. Our Event Log adds an operation-centered interface to workspace history. It exposes file reads, writes, copies, exports, and path changes, together with their observations, referenced objects, and ordering. The agent can therefore trace how an artifact was obtained or changed and revisit intermediate observations, including activities that do not themselves establish a support, replacement, or withdrawal relation. In our benchmark construction, these histories are evidence-reviewed simulations with explicit provenance and synthetic-ordering markers.

We also evaluated a baseline that directly provides evidence-linked relationship judgments. It explicitly examines document versions, authority, purpose, applicability, conflicts, and withdrawals, and presents its conclusions in a source-cited report. Across all 30 tasks, this baseline achieves 77.19% Micro and 73.66% Macro, while EGS achieves 85.63% and 79.46%, respectively, improving by 8.44 and 5.80 percentage points. The baseline passes 988 of 1,280 rubric items, and EGS passes 1,096 of 1,280. We have added this comparison to Section 5.2.2 and documented the preparation prompts and evaluation protocol in Appendix B.8.

In another comparison, we evaluated EGS alongside file indexing, hierarchical summaries, and workspace review. Preparation uses workspace materials, the working agent receives the task request, and rubrics are reserved for evaluation. Across all 30 tasks, EGS achieves 79.77/71.94 Micro/Macro with DeepSeek-V4-Flash and 85.63/79.46 with DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash, exceeding file indexing, hierarchical summaries, and workspace review on both metrics in both settings. Within each downstream-model setting, the methods share original-file access, execution budgets, the Claude Code version, and the evaluator.

We also evaluated adaptations of the two suggested conflict-aware methods. MADAM-RAG retains document-agent discussion and answer aggregation. Our ArbGraph workspace adaptation uses multilingual semantic candidate selection, relation verification, and arbitration before delivery. Generation and evaluation use DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash.

Evaluation scopeMethodPassed / totalMicroMacro
All 30 tasksMADAM-RAG adaptation917 / 128071.6466.38
All 30 tasksEGS1096 / 128085.6379.46
ArbGraph completed-task subset, 9 tasksArbGraph adaptation207 / 30368.3261.53
The same 9 tasksEGS232 / 30376.5774.67

ArbGraph's original setting focuses on question answering over a small set of retrieved Wikipedia texts, with support/contradiction arbitration before answer generation. Our setting involves Chinese, multi-format file workspaces and tasks that require source applicability checks, document-version and scope resolution, procedural completeness, and actual file delivery or operations. These additional demands on workspace discovery and evidence access make direct transfer of the original configuration challenging. Our workspace adaptation completed evaluation on nine tasks. All nine are included in the comparison, alongside EGS on exactly the same tasks.

The nine completed ArbGraph graphs contain 40,951 candidate pairs, of which 94.89% were classified as unrelated. We have added these statistics to Appendix B.8 alongside the adaptation settings and matched-task results.

The component ablation shows that under TGS, adding Event Logs to the Map-and-hook condition increases the pass rate from 84.84% to 87.27%. The new EGS comparisons, conflict-aware method adaptations, concrete index examples, and component evidence together clarify the contribution of an executable, source-grounded environment layer.

We have added an explanation of Event Log semantics, evidence provenance, and its distinction from a relationship index to Section 4.1. We have added the EGS baseline gains and matched-task comparison results to Section 5.2.2, and introduced Appendix B.8 with the full comparison tables, preparation prompts, runtime and source-access settings, adaptation details, graph statistics, and per-task scores. In Section 6, we have added an explicit comparison with MADAM-RAG and ArbGraph. In Appendix B.7, we have retained the TGS component ablations and added a cross-reference to the new EGS comparisons.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Q3 · Matched Preparation Conditions and Cost

First, both of the conditions are met. Qwen3.8-27B and Env-Rethink use the same tool set, report format, call budget, and downstream interface, and both supply selected files plus an evidence report. Appendix B.6 mentioned only file selection for Qwen3.8-27B and omitted that this condition also supplies an evidence report. We have corrected this omission in the revised manuscript.

Second, for preparation cost, per task the median preparation time is 1.04 hours and the median token use is 1.44M for the fine-tuned Env-Rethink model, compared with 1.07 hours and 1.19M tokens for the unadapted Qwen3.8-27B.

We have clarified the matched preparation conditions in Appendices B.5 and B.6 of the revised manuscript.

Reviewer_5G49OpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper first shows that environment reorganization through Collection Maps and Event Logs can improve agent performance by making files and their relationships easier to understand. It then constructs subenvironments and distills file verification capabilities from teacher models into ENV-RETHINK. By filtering noise while retaining useful evidence, the preparation model improves downstream task performance. The paper also explores environment evolution to generate more challenging tasks.

Critical strengths
  1. The motivation is interesting. Agents need to understand how files support, revise, or invalidate one another. How agents handle information in complex environments is an important research direction.

  2. The framework covers several aspects of environment preparation and evolution, including file reorganization, evidence verification, and challenge generation. The experiments are extensive and examine both preparation quality and downstream performance.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The paper contains many components, but the presentation does not clearly connect them into a unified framework. The environment evolution section feels somewhat disconnected from the earlier discussion of reorganization and evidence verification. For example, it remains unclear whether the evolved environments can help train better file organization and filtering capabilities. Demonstrating this connection would make the overall contribution more coherent.

  2. The design involves multiple agents and several processing stages, but comparisons with simpler alternatives are limited. Useful baselines would include a strong model directly reviewing the full environment, hierarchical summaries tailored to the task, or a file index. These comparisons would help establish whether the complexity of the proposed design is necessary.

  3. The downstream evaluation contains only 30 tasks, with multiple rubric checks within each task. Reporting uncertainty at the task level and repeating the evaluations would help assess the stability of the gains.

  4. The paper does not report the additional cost of environment organization and preprocessing. If these stages require substantial computation or repeated model calls, the gains may come at a considerable cost. Reporting preparation time, token usage, and how often the prepared environment can be reused would help assess its practical value.

Questions for authors

See weaknesses.

5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to W1 · How Preparation Informs Environment Evolution

Thank you for pointing this out. We agree that the previous presentation did not clearly distinguish the roles of the three components. Reorganization and cleansing prepare existing environments for reliable task execution, whereas evolution generates complex, realistic environments for training the task-solving model. They are unified by the same objective: improving task completion in complex real-world environments. We do not use evolved environments to update the environment-preparation model.

Preparation provides transferable environment knowledge for evolution. Reorganization reveals how files are connected through dependencies, revisions, and causal events. Cleansing identifies recurring noise patterns and learns how authority, version applicability, and contradictory evidence affect source validity. These findings inform which relationships and evidence conflicts should be introduced during evolution. They also provide criteria for validating that an evolved environment remains realistic and solvable: it should contain plausible misleading choices together with sufficient resolving evidence, and its reference outcome and evaluator must be updated consistently with the changed state. Thus, preparation helps evolution construct meaningful complexity rather than arbitrary perturbations.

Evolution, in turn, supplies training environments for the task model. Each validated evolved environment preserves the original task request while providing changed environmental states, an updated reference outcome, and evaluation checks. Training on these environments allows the task model to practice completing tasks despite fragmented information, conflicting versions, and misleading evidence. Although this process does not train the file-verification model in the cleansing module, the task model may itself acquire better evidence-organization and filtering behaviors because these behaviors are necessary for completing the evolved tasks.

We have revised Sections 3 and 4.2 to clarify this relationship and distinguish the two training targets. We are running a controlled comparison in which task agents train on original or evolved tasks under the same budget and are evaluated on the same independent test set. Completing both training runs and the independent evaluation requires additional time. We aim to share the results on OpenReview before the discussion period ends.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to W2 · Comparison with Simpler Baselines

Thank you for these concrete baseline suggestions. We tested the simpler alternatives you suggested to assess the value of the additional organization stages. Across all 30 tasks, EGS outperformed the simpler baselines on both Micro and Macro rubric pass rates with both downstream models. We believe these gains justify the additional organization stages for tasks that require agents to find and verify evidence across files.

We have added a strong-model workspace review, hierarchical summaries, and a file index, and evaluated them alongside EGS on all 30 tasks with two downstream models. We also include direct task execution as a control with both downstream models.

Within each downstream-model setting, the methods share the original workspace, ordinary file tools, execution budget, Claude Code version, and evaluation procedure. We reuse prepared materials across downstream-model settings. Preparation uses workspace materials, while the task request is supplied to the downstream agent and the rubrics are reserved for the evaluator. The hierarchical baseline constructs file-level, group-level, and workspace-level summaries; the downstream agent accesses these summaries according to its task.

MethodDeepSeek-V4-Flash MicroDeepSeek-V4-Flash MacroDeepSeek-V4.1-Flash MicroDeepSeek-V4.1-Flash Macro
Direct execution61.8062.1672.1170.70
File index48.5954.2681.4874.70
Hierarchical summaries64.5362.8879.4573.39
Strong-model workspace review64.5366.3979.2275.87
EGS79.7771.9485.6379.46

Each entry covers 30 tasks and 1,280 rubric items. Micro aggregates rubric items; Macro weights tasks equally. The judge is DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash-1017 at maximum reasoning effort. All downstream conditions access the original files through the same ordinary file-tool interface, with method-specific auxiliary materials and retrieval where applicable.

EGS achieves the highest Micro and Macro in both model settings. Relative to the strongest simple baseline on each metric, the improvements are 15.23/5.55 percentage points with DeepSeek-V4-Flash and 4.14/3.58 points with DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash. With DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash, direct execution obtains 72.11 Micro and 70.70 Macro, compared with 85.63 and 79.46 for EGS. With DeepSeek-V4-Flash, direct execution obtains 61.80 Micro and 62.16 Macro, and EGS improves these by 17.97 and 9.78 percentage points, respectively.

These results support the practical value of the organization workflow: its gains persist across downstream model strengths and under both rubric-weighted and task-weighted evaluation. The Collection Map supports discovery across files, while source-linked histories provide context for checking how candidate materials apply to the requested task. We have added a summary of the two-model baseline comparison and its key gains to Section 5.2.2. We have also added Appendix B.8 with the complete comparison tables, preparation settings, downstream budgets, and per-task results.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to W3 · Stability of Downstream Gains

Thanks for your comments. Yes. Every condition is now repeated three times under the same harness and the same 1,280 rubric items, and the gains hold: the trial-to-trial standard deviation of the pooled 30-task rate is 0.4–3.2 points, and for each of the three downstream models Env-Rethink ranks first among the three conditions in all three trials (9 of 9). The table gives three-trial means, task-level 95% intervals from a paired bootstrap over tasks (10,000 resamples), and the number of individual tasks that rise or fall. We have reported the three-trial results and these task-level intervals in Section 5.3 and Appendix B.6 of the revised manuscript.

Stability of the downstream gains (three-trial mean; 95% CI from a paired bootstrap over tasks)

SplitFullQwen3.8-27BEnv-RethinkΔ vs Full [95% CI]Tasks ↑ / ↓
Held-out 1578.474.585.8+7.4 [+0.1, +16.2]12 / 3
Training-source 1566.581.293.4+26.9 [+21.6, +32.7]15 / 0
All 3071.578.490.2+18.7 [+12.4, +24.5]27 / 3
Reviewer_4QyPOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes ENV-RETHINK, which organizes cross-file information through Collection Maps and evidence-supported synthetic Event Logs. It fine-tunes a 27B model on tool-use trajectories to select files and generate evidence reports that assist downstream agents. The system also jointly modifies environments, reference answers, and evaluators while keeping user requests unchanged, producing more difficult task instances. The authors evaluate environment preparation on tasks adapted from Workspace-Bench and environment evolution on a subset of Terminal-Bench 2.1.

Critical strengths
  1. Scattered files, conflicting versions, and misleading evidence are practical obstacles for agents performing real-world tasks. The paper treats evidence organization and validity checks as a reusable environment-preparation step, allowing the same preparation model to serve different downstream agents.
  2. The experiments demonstrate the practical value of environment preparation. Across 30 tasks and nine downstream models, the mean rubric pass rate increases from 57.6% with the full environment to 72.7%, also exceeding the 59.4% obtained with the preparation model before fine-tuning. Environment evolution jointly updates answers and checks, and validates instances by executing reference solutions, accounting for task solvability.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Insufficient human validation. Environment evolution generates or modifies environments, reference answers, and evaluators, whose reliability directly affects difficulty assessment. Although Appendix A.4 reports human review of some file annotations, it does not clearly specify the scope or error rates of human review for evolved instances and evaluators. Having the new answer pass and the old answer fail does not rule out a shared semantic error in the answer and evaluator. It therefore remains difficult to establish whether reduced success rates reflect valid increases in difficulty rather than task ambiguity or evaluation errors.
  2. Insufficient benchmark coverage. Environment preparation is primarily evaluated on 30 difficult tasks adapted from Workspace-Bench, including 15 training-source tasks, while environment evolution is evaluated separately on a Terminal-Bench 2.1 subset. The results provide limited evidence of generalization to independent tasks and other interactive environments, particularly computer-use settings involving cross-app GUI operations or state changes during execution. Evaluation on independent benchmarks such as OSWorld and Windows Agent Arena, together with separate reporting of gains on unseen tasks, would strengthen the evidence.
  3. The training value of environment evolution remains unverified. The experiments show that evolved tasks are harder, but do not demonstrate whether training on them improves agent performance on an independent test set. Increasing difficulty does not necessarily produce useful learning signals, so the evidence for continual self-improvement remains limited.
Questions for authors
  1. Have the evolved environments, answers, and evaluators undergone independent human review? Please report its scope, criteria, and error rates, and explain how task ambiguity and shared errors in answers and evaluators are ruled out.
  2. Could you report downstream results separately for the 15 unseen tasks and evaluate applicability to cross-app evidence and dynamic states on independent computer-use benchmarks?
  3. Could you compare agents trained on original versus evolved tasks on an independent test set to establish the learning benefits of environment evolution?
5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to W1/Q1 · Human Audit of Evolved Tasks

Thank you for this valuable suggestion. To assess the reliability of evolved tasks, we have added a human-led, tool-assisted task-level audit examining consistency among the user request, agent-visible environment, reference result, and evaluation criteria. We also quantified the identified issues and their impact on the aggregate results.

1. Review scope

Review records cover all 55 retained tasks. Of these, 37 received further cross-checking: all 32 tasks supporting the original difficulty result and five additional tasks with runtime-validation concerns. Primary and cross-review assessments are retained, with differences resolved against specific evidence. The second reviewer has confirmed the final decisions for all 37 tasks through itemized responses. The records document reviews assignments, evidence paths, verification methods, and final decisions.

2. Review criteria and checks for shared errors

The audit starts from the original request and agent-visible materials and examines four aspects: (1) consistency of environmental changes with the task objective and explicit constraints; (2) effective dates, registrations, withdrawals, and handover evidence governing conflicting records; (3) the evidence and calculations supporting the reference result; and (4) evaluator treatment of valid equivalent answers and key errors. We combine source inspection, independent numerical calculations, and targeted counterexamples, documenting the methods and results for each task.

To check for shared errors in the answer and evaluator, we establish an explicit correspondence from the user request to visible evidence, the correct result, and the evaluation checks. For example, we recomputed match outcomes from the actual inputs, reconstructed merged data from effective records, and tested evaluator acceptance using valid alternative outputs. Additional conditions are checked for applicability to the current task, while conflicting materials are resolved through registration, withdrawal, and handover records.

3. Audit findings

Of the 37 cross-checked tasks, 32 passed content review and five were flagged for issues in evaluator acceptance or reference-workflow validation. The flagged tasks account for 13.5% of the 37 cross-checked instances:

TaskFinding
caffe-cifar-10Overly restrictive treatment of intermediate snapshots and insufficient separation of training and test accuracy.
git-leak-recoveryA fixed repository checksum restricts a valid cleanup that retains a sanitized archive.
nginx-request-loggingInconsistent acceptance of equivalent rate configurations, 10r/s and 600r/m.
prove-plus-commLiteral-form checks can reject an equivalent proof after renaming bound variables.
merge-diff-arc-agi-taskThe reference workflow resets to branch2 and omits the requested merge into branch1. The evaluator checks only the mapping output.

We document the provenance of each issue, covering inherited evaluation checks, added checks, and their use. For example, the Nginx limitation arises from an inherited literal check, while the Caffe snapshot issue concerns the added training-artifact consistency check. Each finding is linked to specific code, counterexamples, or verification results to support inspection and revision.

4. Impact on the aggregate result and revision

We have excluded these five tasks from both the seed and evolved sets and recomputed the aggregate statistics using the existing paired outcomes. Four of the flagged tasks belong to the original group of 32 positive tasks. Under the original screening criterion (a success-rate decrease of at least 20 percentage points in at least three models), the proportion meeting the criterion changes from 32/55 (58.2%) to 28/50 (56.0%).

AnalysisTasks meeting the criterionProportion
Original paired set32/5558.2%
Excluding all five flagged tasks from both arms28/5056.0%

This sensitivity analysis shows that the observed aggregate pattern persists after excluding all flagged tasks. We have added a summary of the audit coverage, five flagged tasks, and the filtered result of 28/50 (56.0%) to Section 5.4. We have added a cross-reference to the filtered analysis in Appendix C.1 and introduced Appendix C.2 with the audit procedure, criteria, verification examples, per-task findings and evidence, and the paired-exclusion sensitivity table.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to W2/Q2 · Held-Out Performance and Cross-Application Evaluation

First, we have re-run the downstream evaluation on the 15 held-out Environment-Hard tasks, none of which was used to construct training data. The evaluation uses the Claude Code harness with DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash, HY3, and HY4 as downstream models, each scored on 536 rubric items, and every condition is repeated three times. The mean pass rate across the three models rises from 78.4% under Full (all original files retained) to 85.8% under Env-Rethink: 7.4 points above Full and 11.3 points above preparation by the untuned Qwen3.8-27B (74.5%). Per-model results are averaged over three trials and listed below; the per-condition standard deviation across trials is 0.4–3.2 points.

Rubric pass rate (%) on the 15 held-out tasks (mean of three trials)

ModelFullQwen3.8-27BEnv-Rethink
DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash82.178.287.3
HY369.370.083.8
HY483.975.586.5
Mean78.474.585.8

Second, we also report computer-use evidence, and we think it is worth being explicit about which half of the framework OSWorld can test. Preparation is defined for environments that already contain conflicting evidence: reorganization organizes scattered files, and cleansing removes misleading ones. The released OSWorld environments are near-saturated rather than noisy — across 30 tasks covering all 10 application domains, the original evaluators give a mean score of 0.80, with 24 of the 30 tasks at full marks. What these environments lack is not files but conflicting evidence, so a cleansing experiment on them would have almost nothing to reject and could not support any conclusion about preparation. This is the same environment wall the paper identifies.

We therefore use OSWorld to test the other half of the framework, environment evolution, which changes the environmental state while keeping the user request fixed. On the same 30 tasks we introduce (i) cross-surface decoys, in which a separate profile editor displays the target value while the active application keeps its original value; (ii) observation limits, including text scaling, window occlusion, and pre-selected adjacent scopes; and (iii) distractor materials, such as a same-named folder under another account or a near-duplicate slide. Each evolved task was checked by hand to retain a feasible recovery path.

The results across two models are summarized below. Environment evolution reduces the mean score for both models, with lower scores on 19/30 and 14/30 tasks for DeepSeek and GLM, respectively.

ModelOriginal meanEvolved meanLower / Same / Higher (tasks)
DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash0.80000.166719 / 11 / 0
GLM-5.3-Flash0.86670.433314 / 15 / 1

For DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash, full-mark tasks drop from 24/30 to 5/30: 19 of the 24 tasks that the agent solves completely drop to zero, while the 6 tasks that were already at zero stay at zero. These are cross-application GUI operations whose state changes during execution, i.e., the setting that Weakness 2 asks about. We have added this study to Section 5.4 and Appendix C of the revised manuscript; while leaving the evaluation under the same protocol on Windows Agent Arena for future work.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to W3/Q3 · Training on Evolved Tasks

Thank you for suggesting this comparison. We trained agents on original and evolved tasks under matched settings and evaluated them on 12 held-out tasks, three trials each.

Notation. For readability, we use three labels: Base = Qwen3.8-27B without task-specific training; Original-trained = the agent trained on original tasks; Evolved-trained = the agent trained on evolved (hardened) tasks.

Training data and control. The evolved-task corpus is built from hardened variants of 16 Terminal-Bench 2.1 training-side tasks. Qwen3.8-Max and HY4 produced teacher rollouts; we retained only the 43 episodes passing the evaluator. HY4 rewrites each retained trajectory into compressed, strategy-oriented reasoning (≤600 characters per turn). At conflicts, the trace names the competing sources, applies the task-specified authority, and verifies the delivered result. After removing four flagged tasks, the corpus contains 330 training and 21 validation episodes. Both trained agents use the same base model, data volume, and configuration: ms-swift LoRA (rank 64, alpha 128, all linear), ZeRO-3, maximum length 24,576, three epochs, learning rate 1e-4 with cosine decay, 8×H20 GPUs, and 33 optimization steps. The training task set is the only intended difference.

Results. Each cell reports passes out of 36 trials (12 tasks × 3); task counts require at least one passing trial.

AgentTraining dataEvolved-task evaluationOriginal-task evaluation
Basenone10/36 (27.8%), 5 tasks26/36 (72.2%), 10 tasks
Original-trainedoriginal tasks10/36 (27.8%), 4 tasks23/36 (63.9%), 9 tasks
Evolved-trainedevolved tasks14/36 (38.9%), 7 tasks27/36 (75.0%), 10 tasks
  1. Original-task training alone does not improve evolved-task performance. It remains 10/36, and task coverage falls from 5 to 4. Additional training or data therefore does not explain the result.
  2. Evolved-task training raises evolved-task performance to 14/36, four more passing trials than either control (+11.1 percentage points), and covers 7 rather than 5 or 4 tasks.

Case 1: deciding membership before counting (log-summary-date-ranges). The task asks the agent to count ERROR/WARNING/INFO events in /app/logs/YYYY-MM-DD_<source>.log across five date ranges and write a 15-row CSV relative to 2025-08-12. This is not primarily an arithmetic problem; the agent must first decide which files belong to the statistic. The pending/ subtree holds copies of root-level files, 2025-08-11_edge.log is a post-upgrade back-fill that the environment’s reader cannot match but the task requires, and closeout_recount_2025-08-14.log reports totals that include superseded copies while citing a verification source that does not exist. Naive recursive counting gives 613 or 1,105 instead of the correct today, ERROR = 497.

Base and Original-trained generally start from directory enumeration, so duplicate copies re-enter the count. Evolved-trained first establishes membership: it recognizes the pending/ subtree and re-ingested blocks as duplicates, checks the redelivery record showing that these copies were set aside, and only then performs the aggregation, producing 497. The learned behavior is source-membership and authority resolution before computation.

Case 2: validating committed state before reconstruction (sqlite-db-truncate). The task asks the agent to recover rows from a binary-truncated SQLite file and write recover.json. The surviving 4,096-byte page is not the newest state; the real history is in 11 WAL frames plus a carve window. Two records disagree on the final value (44.75 versus 23.5). The correct value, 57.5, requires reassembling file blocks in catalogue order and replaying the committed WAL frames.

Base and Original-trained decode the live page and typically recover eight rows with incorrect values because they do not establish which later changes were committed. Evolved-trained verifies the commit chain before assembling the rows: 86 Bash calls, 11 per-frame checksum checks, and 64 commit-boundary judgments, compared with 21/35 Bash calls and 0/2 checksum checks for the two controls. These calls verify the commit status of each WAL frame. It then recovers the correct values (57.5 / 62.75 / 14.75 …).

Together, the aggregate comparison and the two cases show the same effect: evolved-task training teaches the agent to establish evidence membership and committed state before producing an answer. This is the learning benefit that difficulty alone does not demonstrate, and it is consistent with the conflict-resolution strategies emphasized in the rewritten training trajectories. We will include the complete training protocol, per-task results, and case analyses in the revised manuscript and appendix.

Comments on the paper

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to the added question

We really appreciate your positive reassessment of our work and your continued constructive feedback.

We confirm that the relationship-review baseline uses the same preparation model and reasoning effort as EGS, with a same generous preparation budget to support thorough source examination and evidence-linked reasoning. Both conditions use path-triggered hooks with the same collection and auxiliary-context token limits; the rendering and retrieval interfaces follow their respective representations.

About the collection map, our initial comparison treated each baseline as a complete organization-and-access scheme. In EGS, the Collection Map and Event Log are designed to work together: the Map supports collection-level navigation, while the Log provides historical context. We therefore paired the evidence-linked relationship review with its own source-linked navigation and retrieval interface, rather than adding the EGS Collection Map.

We recognize that this design did not separately control for the contribution of the Collection Map, and we appreciate the opportunity to address this oversight. We have therefore added a comparison that reuses the same relationship reports together with the identical Collection Map used by EGS, under the same downstream process. However, We have to point out that the shared Collection Map already contains some information that overlaps with the Event Log, including document versions, purposes, applicability, and archival status. Both conditions therefore receive these cues.

Across all 30 tasks, EGS passes 1,096/1,280 rubric items (85.63% Micro; 79.46% Macro), compared with 1,078/1,280 (84.22% Micro; 78.34% Macro) for Collection Map + relationship review. EGS therefore improves Micro by 1.41 percentage points and Macro by 1.11 points. These results support the additional value of operation-centered history alongside the same collection navigation, beyond a source-cited review of document relationships.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.