- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2(+1)
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2(+1)
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies whether LLM-based terminal agents can adapt when environmental changes break their previously successful strategies. The authors introduce AGNI, a pipeline that automatically generates controlled base–novel task pairs by identifying implicit assumptions in successful trajectories and invalidating one such assumption while preserving task solvability.
Critical strengths
-
The problem of environmental novelty in terminal agents is well motivated, grounded in realistic software-evolution scenarios where implicit assumptions routinely break.
-
The formalization and the AGNI pipeline are described clearly.
Critical weaknesses
-
AGNI and the post-training interventions combine existing LLM capabilities and known techniques into a pipeline, making the trajectory-derived versus predefined-perturbation distinction an engineering improvement rather than a new algorithmic or theoretical contribution.
-
AGNI partitions environmental novelty into certain categories without justifying why these four dimensions are sufficient or characterizing what classes of real-world environment changes fall outside this taxonomy.
-
The formalization invalidates exactly one assumption per task pair, but real software changes often break multiple interdependent assumptions at once, and the paper does not establish whether the bidirectional oracle validation remains sound when correlated assumptions fail together or whether it may accept pairs whose success depends on an unintended secondary violation.
-
The pipeline is conditioned on the analyzer model's extraction of trajectory-relative assumptions, yet no precision estimate or error taxonomy is reported for this step, so if the analyzer systematically over-generalizes or misattributes assumptions the oracle check cannot detect the misalignment.
Questions for authors
-
AGNI partitions environmental novelty into four categories without justifying why these dimensions are sufficient. Could the authors clarify whether this taxonomy is derived from a prior framework or induced empirically, and characterize what classes of real-world environment changes fall outside it?
-
The formalization invalidates exactly one assumption per task pair, but real software changes often break multiple interdependent assumptions at once. Could the authors clarify whether the oracle validation remains sound when correlated assumptions fail together?
-
The entire pipeline is conditioned on the analyzer model's extraction of trajectory-relative assumptions, yet no precision estimate or error taxonomy is reported for this step.
-
The reported gains in novel pass@1 are difficult to attribute to a genuine capability for diagnosing environmental changes and revising strategy, since both the training and evaluation novelties are constructed by the same GPT-5.5 analyzer over similar task distributions. The trained model may instead be acquiring shortcuts that memorize AGNI-style novelty patterns or produce meta-action labels as a formatting artifact, rather than learning general adaptation.
4 comments
C4: Generalization of Adaptation Improvements
C4. The reported gains in novel pass@1 are difficult to attribute to a genuine capability for diagnosing environmental changes and revising strategy, since both the training and evaluation novelties are constructed by the same GPT-5.5 analyzer over similar task distributions. The trained model may instead be acquiring shortcuts that memorize AGNI-style novelty patterns or produce meta-action labels as a formatting artifact, rather than learning general adaptation.
We agree that training and evaluation using the same AGNI pipeline could introduce shared novelty mechanisms. However, our experiments provide evidence that address both of your concerns:
(i) AGNI-specific shortcut learning: First, AGNI generates novelties based on assumptions underlying successful task-solving trajectories, rather than from a predefined set of perturbations. These assumptions depend on the tasks, environments, and agent strategies. Since our training and evaluation tasks are disjoint, the novelties implemented in the training and evaluation splits are also implicitly different. Despite this difference, novel pass@1 improves from 11.1% to 29.5% on ET-eval and from 2.7% to 5.0% on TB-Lite (Figure 5). This shows that training improves agents' ability to adapt to unseen tasks, environments, and the novelties introduced in them. Second, we evaluate models on paired base and novel tasks with unchanged prompt and graders. Since the novelty is not disclosed in the prompt, agents can only discover the environmental change through interaction and then revise their strategies to succeed, rather than simply replaying a memorized shortcut. Together, these observations suggest that training improvements extend to implicitly different novelties and improve agents' ability to adapt through interaction, rather than merely memorizing shortcuts.
(ii) Meta-action labels as formatting artifacts: We include controlled ablations in training-improvements to distinguish the effects of novelty-augmented training, META prompting, and META training (Section 6, Q6.2–Q6.3). First, novelty-augmented GRPO improves novel pass@1 from 11.1% to 29.5% without meta-action labels (Figure 5). Second, adding the META prompt during inference improves novel pass@1 from 29.46% to 32.59%, while training with META prompt further increases it to 37.86% (Table 3). These results demonstrate that META training provides additional gains beyond novelty-augmented training, rather than merely improving meta-action label formatting.
We acknowledge that we do not study generalization to independently constructed novelties that are explicitly different from those generated by AGNI. We leave this for future work and will clarify this limitation in the revised paper.
C5: Human Validation of Assumption Extraction and Novelty Alignment
C5. The pipeline is conditioned on the analyzer model's extraction of trajectory-relative assumptions, yet no precision estimate or error taxonomy is reported for this step, so if the analyzer systematically over-generalizes or misattributes assumptions the oracle check cannot detect the misalignment.
We agree that errors in assumption extraction could lead to misalignment between the extracted assumption and the actual implemented change. To evaluate this, we conducted a human study with 50 randomly sampled accepted AGNI task pairs. For each pair, the annotator examined the original task, successful base-task trajectories, extracted assumptions and their supporting evidence, and implemented environmental changes. We evaluated two criteria: (i) assumption validity, whether the extracted assumption is actually used by the agent in its successful trajectory, and (ii) novelty alignment, whether the environmental change actually targeted the assumption used by the agent. Each criterion was labeled Yes, No, or Unclear.
We found that 49/50 (98%) assumptions were valid, while 46/50 (92%) environmental changes targeted the identified assumptions. Of the 4 non-yes examples, 3 involved failures caused by changes affecting a different dependency than the selected assumption (for example, creating a file-path conflict by placing a non-empty directory at the file path rather than changing file permissions), while 1 was unclear. Overall, 46/50 (92%) task pairs satisfied both criteria, suggesting high assumption validity and novelty alignment among accepted AGNI task pairs.
This also highlights that AGNI's validation pipeline may not always ensure direct alignment between the extracted assumption and the implemented environmental change. Despite this, the validation checks in pipeline ensure that the novel tasks require agents to diagnose unexpected environmental changes and revise their strategies, making them useful for studying adaptation. These findings also provide empirical evidence relevant to C3. We will incorporate these findings and clarifications into the revised paper.
We hope our clarifications and additional empirical evidence have addressed your concerns. If so, we would appreciate it if you could reconsider your assessment and reflect any resolved concerns in your scores.
I thank the authors for their response, which addresses most of my concerns. I have raised my score.
C1–C3: Methodological Contributions, Novelty Dimensions, and Validation Scope
Thank you for your thoughtful review and for raising several interesting points. We appreciate your recognition that the problem of environmental novelty in terminal agents is well motivated and that our formalization and AGNI pipeline are clearly described. We address your specific concerns below:
We agree that our work builds on existing techniques, but this does not diminish our methodological and empirical contributions, which are also recognized by the other reviewers.
Our primary contribution is a methodology to systematically study and improve adaptation in terminal agents. To this end, we introduce AGNI, which enables scalable construction of environmental novelties in heterogeneous, open-ended terminal tasks. Unlike predefined perturbations, AGNI derives novelties from assumptions underlying successful agent strategies, making them specific to the task and strategy (Section 4). We use this setup to evaluate adaptation across models, analyze failure modes, and investigate how post-training can improve adaptation (Sections 5–6).
Adaptation is critical to the reliability of autonomous coding agents. An agent that stops upon encountering an unexpected condition provides a worse user experience than one that identifies its cause, revises its strategy, and completes the task (Figure 1). Our methodology enables us to systematically study and improve this important capability.
Our four novelty dimensions are conceptually motivated by the POMDP formulation (Williams & Young, 2007). POMDPs model agent-environment interaction in terms of observations, actions, and state transitions. Motivated by this formulation, we organize novelties according to how they interfere with these components: changing what agents observe (perception), how they act (control), which actions are feasible (constraints), and how the environment responds to their actions (dynamics). These four dimensions are defined a priori and serve as broad, non-exhaustive categories for organizing and generating novelties (Algorithm 1, lines 4–7).
We will clarify this motivation and scope in the revised paper.
Williams & Young. Partially Observable Markov Decision Processes for Spoken Dialog Systems. Computer Speech & Language, 2007.
We deliberately target one trajectory-relative assumption per novel task pair to support a controlled study of adaptation, but this does not require that no other assumptions be affected.
AGNI's validation checks that the original oracle solution fails, an adapted oracle solution succeeds, and successful solver trajectories exhibit task-preserving adaptation (Algorithm 1). These checks establish that the original strategy is invalidated while the task remains solvable. However, they do not formally guarantee that no secondary assumptions are affected or that every observed failure is attributable solely to the targeted assumption (more on this in our response to C5). We will clarify this limitation in the revised paper.
As acknowledged in Section 7, systematically studying multiple interdependent novelties is beyond our current scope. AGNI could be extended by introducing novelties sequentially and applying Algorithm 1's validation after each change. We leave empirical evaluation of this extension to future work.