- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents UMA-DOS, which adapts pretrained atomistic models to predict total DOS using a spectral decoder and separate shape and amplitude predictions. My main questions are listed below.
Critical strengths
See Questions
Critical weaknesses
See Questions
Questions for authors
-
How does DOSTransformer perform with the same shape–amplitude factorization and training losses? The current comparison mixes changes to the encoder, target, and loss, so the source of the improvement is unclear.
-
The low-data experiments should also include UMA-DOS trained from scratch at each training fraction.
-
Were any test structures, or similar structures, included in UMA’s pretraining data? Overlap would not necessarily mean DOS-label leakage, but it would change how we interpret the results. A split by composition or structure type would be useful.
-
I could not tell whether DOS is reported per atom or per cell. If a cell is duplicated, DOS per cell should double in amplitude, while DOS per atom should stay the same. Mean pooling and normalized weighted pooling can give the same representation for both cells. How would the amplitude head distinguish them? Is atom count used elsewhere?