- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper introduces a novel charge density prediction model, AIDEN, and evaluates it against the state-of-the-art on crystal and molecular benchmarks. The new architecture is constructed via a combination of Cartesian atomic cluster expansion and tensor edge cluster expansion message passing, as well as a physically motivated split between atomic and (chemical) environment density contributions. The model is then first evaluated on the ECD and QM9 benchmarks, beating SOTA on the crystal benchmark and achieving second place on the molecular one. Further testing is conducted via non-SCF calculations from the predicted charge density, showing that AIDEN generally matches or outperforms ChargE3Net on density and downstream energy/force accuracy. The model also demonstrates faster inference than ChargE3Net.
Critical strengths
Density split and physical interpretations:
The authors' decision to split the density is both intuitive and well argued for throughout the paper. The ablation performed to test the individual contributions of the architecture shows that GTOs from the local, atomic embeddings provide a useful bias that the chemical environment GTOs cannot capture. This, and other architectural choices, are well discussed from a physical perspective, giving the reader a clear understanding of why certain choices were made.
Inference efficiency:
The inference speedups over ChargE3Net are meaningful, but not novel in themselves (see below)
Critical weaknesses
Overall, the main weakness of the paper is the limited significance given the current state of the field. Marginal improvements in benchmark accuracy is not a sufficiently compelling contribution, particularly when density reconstruction and measurable SCF acceleration have already been demonstrated more convincingly in other work. At this point, new methods should instead demonstrate either substantially new capabilities or meaningful improvements in practical electronic-structure workflows, rather than primarily optimizing benchmark accuracy. This paper does not convincingly establish either, making its practical value and significance difficult to justify.
Lacking evaluations:
While the authors test on both ECD & QM9 and perform some non-SCF calculations, the results as presented are not entirely convincing. AIDEN is shown to outperform ChargE3Net by around 10–20% on PBE & HSE, but testing the models on Materials Project data, possibly even on the new r2SCAN data, would have provided more substantial evidence that AIDEN is a stronger model. This is compounded by the fact that ELECTRAFI [1] reports an HSE NMAE of 1.35%, outperforming AIDEN when trained from scratch (1.4307%). AIDEN does achieve a better result through PBE fine-tuning (1.3012%), but these are different training protocols and should be distinguished when discussing SOTA performance.
Furthermore, the OOD comparison uses the public Materials Project PBE-trained ChargE3Net checkpoint, whereas AIDEN is trained on the ECD PBE data. As the models have been trained on different datasets, this is not a controlled comparison of the two architectures, making it difficult to attribute the observed improvements to AIDEN itself.
The non-SCF experiments help, but they are also limited to a few structure types and are not a very applicable benchmark. Earlier models such as ChargE3Net and ELECTRA/ELECTRAFI studied the SCF savings when using the model initialization, a test lacking in this paper. While it is not the only density application, it is still one of the main motivations of charge density prediction for large-scale DFT applications. An experimental study of SCF iterations and total wall-clock savings, including inference time, would have allowed the reader to understand the practical impact of AIDEN.
Therefore, as the model is not tested broadly enough on different materials or in end-to-end DFT workflows, it is difficult for a potential user to justify using AIDEN over well-established and broadly tested models such as ChargE3Net.
Limited practical novelty or usefulness:
The paper's contribution is primarily architectural, improving density prediction accuracy and inference efficiency without substantially extending the applications enabled by previous models. Neither spin-difference densities nor augmentation occupancies are modeled, which limits the practical impact.
While most previous papers have done the same (ChargE3Net or ELECTRA), both mentioned quantities are known limitations of density models, and this is now a known limitation which has been mentioned in prior work [1,2]. In particular, the authors state in Appendix C.4.2 that the remaining VASP restart quantities are taken from the matched PBE-SCF reference calculation. This means that the downstream results still rely on information from a previously converged calculation. Adding augmentation occupancies would have enabled non-spin-polarized PAW calculations without requiring reference occupancies, making the model significantly more useful as an independent electronic-structure initialization.
The architectural improvements are interesting, but without demonstrating additional practical capabilities or end-to-end computational savings, the contribution is incremental, and recent work such as [1] and [2] have discussed these issues. I also find it generally concerning that [1] is omitted from citations in the related work and experimental comparisons. Particularly because ELECTRAFI has already demonstrated extremely fast full-grid periodic density reconstruction on its reported benchmarks (in the hundreths of a second), as well as end-to-end DFT wall-clock savings when used for SCF initialization. In contrast, AIDEN reports full-grid inference times of 4.34-23.70 seconds on its OOD systems. Faster inference relative to ChargE3Net alone is therefore insufficient to establish an advance or enough applicable novelty over the current state of the art in efficient density prediction.
[1] Elsborg, Jonas, et al. "Global Plane Waves From Local Gaussians: Periodic Charge Densities in a Blink." (ICML 2026), arXiv preprint arXiv:2601.19966 (2026).
[2] Li, Xiwen, et al. "Efficient E (3)-equivariant framework for universal charge density prediction." arXiv preprint arXiv:2510.00788 (2025).
Questions for authors
-
Appendix C.4.2 states that the remaining VASP restart quantities are taken from the matched PBE-SCF reference calculation. Does this include the PAW augmentation occupancies? Could you clarify exactly which reference quantities are reused, and whether the non-SCF results could be reproduced without them?
-
Have you evaluated the SCF iteration savings and total wall-clock savings when using AIDEN as an initialization, compared with SAD and ChargE3Net? Given the substantial inference speedups, this would be particularly interesting for establishing the practical value of the model.
5 comments
Comment #6: AIDEN does not predict spin-difference densities or augmentation occupancies.
Reply: We regard spin densities and PAW augmentation occupancies as interesting future directions, but they are not the current focus or main bottleneck of this work. The first issue is the data and the physical calculations used to generate them. These labels depend on the DFT settings: changing Hubbard-U for the same structure can substantially alter its calculated spin density, while there is still no unified way to determine appropriate U values across different materials. The key issue therefore lies in the physical calculations and label definitions; changing the network architecture alone does not resolve it.
Existing studies have already explored learning these quantities. Earlier spin-density studies mainly focused on specific systems, such as fcc Fe [J. Chem. Theory Comput. 22, 4813–4821 (2026)] and [Energy Storage Materials 63, 103023 (2023)]. More recently, AugNet arXiv:2609.21759 has extended prediction of spin densities and PAW augmentation occupancies to a broader range of materials, while EdenGNN also learns PAW augmentation occupancies . This direction is still new, so we do not include these latest methods in our quantitative comparisons in this revision; the ICLR reviewer guidelines also do not require comparisons with contemporaneous work or works available only as preprints. We will continue to follow these developments and explore their integration with AIDEN.
Finally, smooth pseudo-charge densities themselves have clear physical and computational value. Beyond the fixed-density energy, force, and band calculations and SCF initialization demonstrated here, they support electrostatic dipole calculations, electron-transfer analysis, and bonding analysis [J. Phys. Chem. C (2023) 127 (48): 23459–23466]. Improving their prediction accuracy and reconstruction efficiency directly serves these practical applications, which are central to AIDEN's current work.
Comment #7: ELECTRAFI demonstrates faster inference than AIDEN.
Reply: ELECTRAFI is a valuable contribution. We have reproduced the model and evaluated its performance; see Appendix C.4. However, we also find that ELECTRAFI's KeOps version is indeed substantially faster. This probably reflects better engineering optimization and a more efficient computational-library implementation. We therefore do not directly compare it with Torch-based AIDEN to assess architectural efficiency. Instead, we reproduce its architecture with Torch, ensuring a forward-pass discrepancy below 1e-7, and analyze the models under the same computational library. Under this setting, ELECTRAFI appears less efficient than AIDEN, with inference cost growing more rapidly as the number of atoms increases. Most systems used for inference in the ELECTRAFI study are relatively small. Its engineering optimization is informative, and our own attempt to reconstruct AIDEN with KeOps did not yield a substantial efficiency improvement. We therefore cite and discuss ELECTRAFI in both the main text and the appendix as a useful reference for future work.
Comment #8: Regarding SCF acceleration and practical computational savings, have the authors evaluated how many SCF iterations and how much total wall-clock time can be saved by using AIDEN as an initial guess, relative to SAD and ChargE3Net? Given AIDEN's substantial inference speedup, such experiments would be particularly useful for demonstrating its practical value.
Reply: We thank the reviewer for this insightful question. We have added a subsection, "Deep-learning charge densities as initial guesses for SCF," to systematically evaluate SCF iteration counts and end-to-end computational costs. We consider 97 conventional materials containing 1–132 atoms from ECD-PBE (three of the 100 selected structures are excluded due to convergence failures) and three TBG systems containing 28, 76, and 148 atoms. We compare SAD, converged self-consistent (SC) densities, AIDEN, ChargE3Net, and ELECTRAFI (Torch and KeOps), recording model loading, density inference, PAW merging, VASP execution, and SCF iterations. Across all 100 evaluated systems, AIDEN achieves the lowest aggregate computational cost among the predictive models, reducing total time by 6.51% relative to SAD, whereas ChargE3Net and ELECTRAFI-KeOps increase it by 7.02% and 13.91%, respectively.
Average computational costs for the 97 conventional materials:
| Initial guess | Load [s] | Infer. [s] | PAW merge [s] | VASP [s] | Total [s] | vs. SAD |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SAD | 0.000 | 0.000 | 0.000 | 812.381 | 812.381 | 0.00% |
| SC | 0.000 | 0.000 | 0.181 | 469.155 | 469.336 | -42.23% |
| AIDEN | 0.606 | 2.799 | 0.399 | 730.423 | 734.226 | -9.62% |
| ChargE3Net | 14.287 | 161.765 | 0.395 | 700.649 | 877.096 | +7.97% |
| ELECTRAFI-Torch | 1.884 | 4.424 | 0.407 | 721.753 | 728.467 | -10.33% |
| ELECTRAFI-KeOps | 1.677 | 0.423 | 0.407 | 721.753 | 724.260 | -10.85% |
Average computational costs for the three TBG systems:
| Initial guess | Load [s] | Infer. [s] | PAW merge [s] | VASP [s] | Total [s] | vs. SAD |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SAD | 0.000 | 0.000 | 0.000 | 11185.667 | 11185.667 | 0.00% |
| SC | 0.000 | 0.000 | 0.373 | 7015.333 | 7015.706 | -37.28% |
| AIDEN | 0.606 | 6.659 | 1.284 | 11265.667 | 11274.216 | +0.79% |
| ChargE3Net | 14.287 | 305.971 | 1.228 | 11401.000 | 11722.485 | +4.80% |
| ELECTRAFI-Torch | 1.884 | 19.241 | 1.339 | 19241.667 | 19264.131 | +72.22% |
| ELECTRAFI-KeOps | 1.677 | 1.159 | 1.339 | 19241.667 | 19245.842 | +72.06% |
On conventional materials, AIDEN reduces total time by 9.62%, close to ELECTRAFI-KeOps at 10.85%, whereas ChargE3Net incurs a 7.97% slowdown due to its higher inference cost. On TBG, none of the predictive models achieves a net speedup, but AIDEN shows the smallest overhead (+0.79%), compared with ChargE3Net (+4.80%) and ELECTRAFI (+72%). Notably, ELECTRAFI's slowdown arises primarily from VASP execution rather than inference, illustrating that fast density prediction alone does not guarantee SCF acceleration.
We further compare the corresponding SCF iteration counts:
| Initial guess | Conventional: steps ↓ | ΔN | vs. SAD | TBG: steps ↓ | ΔN | vs. SAD |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SAD | 19.093 | 0.000 | 0.00% | 24.000 | 0.000 | 0.00% |
| SC | 10.608 | -8.485 | -44.44% | 13.333 | -10.667 | -44.44% |
| AIDEN | 17.454 | -1.639 | -8.59% | 22.667 | -1.333 | -5.56% |
| ChargE3Net | 16.866 | -2.227 | -11.66% | 22.000 | -2.000 | -8.33% |
| ELECTRAFI-Torch | 17.433 | -1.660 | -8.69% | 30.333 | +6.333 | +26.39% |
| ELECTRAFI-KeOps | 17.433 | -1.660 | -8.69% | 30.333 | +6.333 | +26.39% |
AIDEN reduces SCF iterations by 8.59% on conventional materials and 5.56% on TBG, compared with 11.66% and 8.33% for ChargE3Net. ELECTRAFI achieves an 8.69% reduction on conventional materials but a 26.39% increase on TBG, while converged SC densities reduce iterations by approximately 44.44% in both groups. These findings agree with previous observations that density accuracy and SCF convergence are not necessarily monotonically related (ELECTRAFI; Chen et al., 2026). SCF is a nonlinear fixed-point iteration rather than simple energy-gradient descent, and its convergence depends on electronic response, density mixing, and the underlying eigensolver. Our results therefore highlight two complementary applications of AIDEN: accelerating conventional SCF through efficient density initialization and directly predicting approximate ground-state densities for fixed-density NSCF calculations. The latter avoids dependence on SCF iteration trajectories, with its reliability assessed through the energy, force, and band-structure errors reported in our manuscript.
We thank the reviewer for carefully reading our work. We have added relevant experiments and address the comments below.
Comment #1: AIDEN's overall contribution is limited.
Reply: AIDEN's contributions span scientific insight, practical computational value, model design, and transferability:
Comment #2: AIDEN should be evaluated on the MP/r2SCAN datasets.
Reply: The MP dataset is also calculated using the PBE functional. We have added an evaluation of AIDEN on r2SCAN; see Appendix C.2. There, we briefly describe the different functional calculations and evaluate zero-shot inference using AIDEN's PBE-pretrained weights, training from scratch, and fine-tuning from the PBE weights on r2SCAN. Interestingly, the r2SCAN results follow a similar trend to HSE transfer learning: zero-shot inference directly using the PBE-pretrained weights has limited accuracy, while training from scratch and fine-tuning from PBE achieve best validation NMAEs of 0.8515% and 0.7855%, respectively. Fine-tuning gives the lower error, further demonstrating the value of transferring models pretrained on inexpensive functionals.
Comment #3: The HSE state-of-the-art claim should explicitly distinguish fine-tuning.
Reply: We thank the reviewer for their careful reading! In lines 367-369 of the revised manuscript, we explicitly state that the HSE state-of-the-art result is achieved through fine-tuning.
Comment #4: The OOD comparison uses a publicly released ChargE3Net checkpoint trained on Materials Project PBE data, whereas AIDEN is trained on ECD-PBE data.
Reply: The original description of the ChargE3Net weights' training source was incorrect. The weights used in the OOD experiments were also trained on ECD-PBE. We have clarified this in Appendix C.6.2, lines 2017-2018, of the revised manuscript.
Comment #5: The non-self-consistent-field experiments are useful, but they cover only a few types of structures and do not constitute a benchmark with broad practical applicability.
Reply: Our chosen test systems cover disordered molecular systems, an amorphous elemental material, an alloy, and twisted structures. Our choices of water, AlMg, and a-Si follow the examples in EAC-Net, while TBG is also widely used in electronic-structure studies. We first evaluate on general datasets with established benchmarks and then examine generalization to representative complex systems. These experiments demonstrate AIDEN's generalization capability and practical value in complex systems, including integration with MD as discussed above.