1. The main quantitative protocol does not validate the claimed novel-view / cross-view reconstruction quality.
All supplied source frames, including the frames used for the reported metrics, participate in scene optimization. The paper itself describes this as an observed-camera reconstruction protocol rather than a camera-disjoint novel-view benchmark.
This protocol is useful for measuring how well the method restores the observed cameras, but the paper motivates the method partly by arguing that independent 2D deblurring cannot guarantee cross-view consistency or geometrically correct novel views. Those claims are not directly validated by the current quantitative evaluation.
A held-out-camera evaluation would therefore be important. If geometry ground truth is available for the indoor datasets, geometry metrics would also help determine whether sharper appearance corresponds to a better 3D reconstruction.
2. The current ablation does not cleanly isolate the proposed contributions.
The cumulative ablation shows that M0-M3, which introduce the adaptive-supervision components, provide only small changes and sometimes reduce PSNR or SSIM. The largest jump occurs when the existing LeGS density controller is introduced in M4.
The comparison between M4 and M5 does support the blur-aware extension, but M5 also uses substantially more Gaussians: approximately 10.18M vs. 2.86M on ScanNet and 10.78M vs. 1.93M on TUM. Thus, the current experiment does not establish whether the improvement comes from better blur-aware density allocation or simply from a much larger representation.
A fixed-Gaussian-budget comparison between LeGS and the proposed blur-aware policy is needed. It would also be useful to separately ablate the additional blur-aware state, delayed reward, and structural checks.
A simple deblur-first baseline is also missing: use exactly the same pretrained deblurring model to process all input views, and then reconstruct the scene using the same underlying 3DGS optimizer/density controller. This would show how much is gained by the proposed adaptive confidence mechanism rather than simply by providing deblurred images.
3. The novelty should be positioned more narrowly, and several closely related works are missing.
Reconstructing sharp 3DGS from blurry multi-view images is not new. Unified handling of motion and defocus blur is also not new, and neither are 2D deblurring priors, blur-kernel estimation, or RL-based Gaussian density control individually.
The main novelty of SMART-GS appears to be more specific:
(1) dynamically adjusting the trust between the captured blurry observation and a deblurred image prior according to reconstruction progress; and
(2) injecting the same blur/recovery information into a LeGS-style density controller.
The related-work discussion should therefore include at least the following closely related methods:
-
Li Liu, Jing Duan, Xiaodong Fu, Wei Peng, and Lijun Liu. "Unified 3D Gaussian Splatting for Motion and Defocus Blur Reconstruction." Visual Informatics, 9(4):100270, 2025.
This work already studies a unified 3DGS framework for motion and defocus blur reconstruction.
-
Qida Cao, Jiajun Ding, Zhenyang Liu, Zhenzhong Kuang, Yijie Shao, and Yilan Shen. "VC-GS: View-Consistent Deblurring Gaussian Splatting via Alternating Branch Optimization." The Visual Computer, 41(10):7303-7317, 2025.
This work is particularly relevant because it also starts from 2D-deblurred multi-view inputs and explicitly addresses the inconsistency introduced by independent image deblurring.
The paper should clarify its novelty relative to these works rather than presenting unified motion/defocus handling itself as a primary contribution.
4. The external deblurring prior is insufficiently documented.
The manuscript cites Kong et al. (2025) for the single-image deblurring network, but the exact checkpoint and its training data are not specified.
This matters because the cited deblurring model is primarily evaluated on standard motion/real-world deblurring datasets, while SMART-GS also relies on its outputs for defocus-blurred images. Since the prior is central to the proposed supervision mechanism, the paper should report which checkpoint is used and how well the prior itself performs on the motion and defocus subsets.
The initial prior confidence is also based on several hand-designed cues and constants (color consistency, edge agreement, clipping, and Laplacian detail gain). The paper should show that this confidence formulation is useful compared with simpler alternatives such as fixed confidence or a simpler image-quality score.