- Rating
- 4
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents SupraTITO, an implicit transfer operator for generating trajectories of supramolecular systems, especially peptide self-assembly. Conditioned on the peptide sequence, molecular topology, and periodic geometry, the model predicts the minimum-image site displacements of molecules over a large time lag, from which the current state can be recursively updated. On the dipeptide benchmark consisting of 400 systems, SupraTITO generalizes well to held-out systems and even diverse peptide concentrations unseen during training.
Critical strengths
- Compared with prior work that primarily focuses on single-molecule MD, peptide-assembly dynamics represent a relatively novel and important direction. SupraTITO provides a simple yet effective modeling approach to this problem, and the experimental results are also quite promising.
- The overall experimental setup is reasonable and comprehensive, including evaluations of generalization across peptide sequences, a broad set of metrics, and appropriate baseline comparisons. I am particularly interested in the model's generalization to peptide concentrations that are unseen during training, as this provides strong evidence that the model has learned intermolecular interactions rather than merely memorizing the training data.
Critical weaknesses
None
Questions for authors
- I think the manuscript could be reorganized to improve readability. Currently, the Conclusion section is crowded with several figures and tables, which makes the layout somewhat cluttered. In particular, some less essential details in the Methods section, such as Eqs. (15–17), could be moved to the Appendix.
- Lines 190–193 state that the method adopts a two-site-per-molecule representation. It is feasible because the dipeptide system can be coarse-grained into two CA atoms. If the method is extended to peptide sequences containing three or more residues, however, the current representation may no longer be directly applicable. This therefore seems to limit the generalizability of the representation. Please correct me if my understanding is inaccurate.
- The experiments appear to focus exclusively on peptide self-assembly systems. I would like to know whether the current model can also be applied to cross-assembly systems, for example, mixtures of two or more different dipeptides at varying concentrations.
- The current experiments appear to model systems with implicit solvent. I would also like to know whether the model can support systems with explicit water molecules. I understand that running additional experiments may require more time than is available during the rebuttal period, so a feasibility analysis alone would also be helpful.
4 comments
Response to Reviewer emsb, Part 2/3
Coassembly of different dipeptides
Question 3
We agree that coassembly is a very interesting test and thank the reviewer for bringing this up. Our architecture already supports inference for mixtures: each site carries its own amino acid and molecular role features, while pair features describe connectivity and geometry across all peptides. Different peptide species can therefore be included in the same configuration. The original experiments focused on self-assembly because training used only homogeneous systems, but we were keen to test this extension directly.
We prepared 11 external coassembly tests at the training concentration and peptide number, isolating transfer to new compositions. The test cases cover different mixing ratios, binary and ternary mixtures of peptides with contrasting assembly tendencies, differences in peptide chemistry, and reversed residue order. The test scenarios and compositions list these cases and the training membership of their component sequences.
The coassembly table and mean and variability comparison summarize late SASA across these mixtures. Using the frozen submitted model trained only on self-assembly, the blue curves in the SASA comparison for all 11 mixtures show close agreement for several mixture families, including FF/YY, FF/FI, and FG/GF. The main differences occur in mixtures containing GG: the final snapshots show more GG incorporated into the aggregate than in MD, consistent with the lower predicted SASA. A plausible explanation is that homogeneous training does not expose the model to the mixed molecular environments that determine whether GG joins an aggregate or remains dispersed.
We therefore trained a separate model on the original 320 self-assembly trajectories together with 20 mixtures of ten peptide species each, without changing the architecture. The mixture species were selected from the original training partition to cover diverse peptide pairings and chemical environments; the full training mixture list gives their compositions. None of the 11 test compositions are included in training. The orange curves in the same SASA comparison show substantially improved agreement for the GG mixtures, bringing their solvent exposure close to MD. In the snapshot comparison, more GG remains outside the aggregate, closer to the balance between assembled and dispersed peptides in MD. These results extend the demonstrated scope of SupraTITO beyond homogeneous self-assembly to multicomponent peptide systems.
Explicit solvent in the reference MD and learned model
Question 4
Thank you for raising this point. Our reference MD includes explicit Martini water and counterions, but SupraTITO learns only the peptide motion from these simulations, without generating solvent coordinates.
We suppose you are also asking whether SupraTITO could generate explicit water. We think this is possible with suitable training data and solvent features, but expensive with the current global attention, whose cost scales quadratically with the number of sites. A more targeted extension could generate water near peptide interfaces or within cavities, where hydration may influence assembly morphology, while treating bulk solvent separately. A practical alternative is to generate peptide configurations, reconstruct the omitted peptide beads, then solvate and run short MD simulations for relaxation.
A local architecture is a promising direction for joint peptide and water generation. For example, AquaGen (Bengio et al., 2026) uses graph message passing over nearby atoms to generate explicit solvent configurations under periodic boundaries, demonstrating this approach for equilibrium sampling. Extending local models to assembly dynamics is therefore worth exploring, although their accuracy and practical scalability for this task still need to be tested.
Response to Reviewer emsb, Part 3/3
Additional results: Architecture ablations and baselines
We also added architecture ablations in response to Reviewer 7Yyr. The ablation table supports the molecule-consistent displacement construction discussed above, together with explicit bond features and pair geometry evaluated from physical positions. These controls use the same training split and budget and provide further evidence for the design choices in SupraTITO. Details are provided in our response to Reviewer 7Yyr.
Following Reviewer A5mu's suggestion, we also added baselines including nearest sequence retrieval and observable prediction from residue descriptors and protein language model embeddings. The baseline comparison shows lower mean prediction error for SupraTITO. Further details are provided in our response to Reviewer A5mu.
I appreciate the authors' thorough experiments and detailed explanations, which have satisfactorily addressed my concerns. I will maintain my positive score and believe this paper deserves acceptance at the conference.
Response to Reviewer emsb, Part 1/3
Thank you for the positive assessment and helpful suggestions. We have added coassembly tests with the submitted model and a separate mixture-training experiment, and clarify below how the formulation relates to longer peptides and explicit solvent. We address your questions in order below.
Clearer presentation and figure placement
Question 1
We agree that the organization and layout can be improved. We are incorporating all reviewers' feedback and will upload a revised manuscript soon. With the additional page available for revision, we will improve figure placement around the Conclusion and move Eqs. (15-17) to the Appendix.
Extension beyond two sites per molecule
Question 2
We understand the confusion: the paper expresses the molecule-consistent displacement using a center shift and a change in a single bond vector, which is specific to dipeptides. The underlying idea is more general: choose the periodic image for the molecule as a whole, rather than independently for each site.
For example, a longer peptide crossing a box boundary can appear split between opposite sides of the box. Using its bonded connectivity, we first reconstruct the connected molecule at both ends of the transition. We then assign all sites the same displacement of the molecular center and add each site's change in position relative to that center. This avoids inconsistent box-length shifts between bonded sites while allowing the peptide to rotate and change conformation; it does not treat the molecule as rigid.
Let m index molecules and nm denote the number of sites in molecule m. Let yt,i(m) be the reconstructed coordinates of site i at time t and gt(m)=nm−1∑i=1nmyt,i(m) the molecular geometric center. The displacement target for each site i=1,…,nm is
dt,τ,i(m)=MICL(gt+τ(m)−gt(m))+(yt+τ,i(m)−gt+τ(m))−(yt,i(m)−gt(m)).
For a dipeptide, the two positions relative to the center are minus and plus half the bond vector, recovering the formula in the paper. For a longer peptide, we can use each site's position relative to the molecular center instead. This construction is not restricted to one bead per residue: sites can instead represent all backbone and side-chain beads defined by a coarse-grained force field such as Martini, or individual atoms when an all-atom force field is used. The shared networks can process the additional sites and their connections. We will clarify the construction in the revised manuscript.