- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes SKAB, a supervised adaptive basis-learning method for functional data classification. A coordinate-input Spline-Wavelet KAN generates shared basis functions, with edge functions combining compactly supported wavelet atoms with learnable centers and scales and a SiLU branch. The proposed CSDS procedure initializes the first-layer atom dictionary using coordinate-wise Fisher scores computed from the training data. Each curve is converted into coefficients through a differentiable ridge least-squares projection, followed by an MLP classifier. The basis generator and classifier are trained jointly using the classification objective. Evaluation includes a synthetic task constructed from localized atoms, six real datasets, and ablations of the parameterization, initialization, and dictionary size.
Critical strengths
-
The motivation is clear. When class differences are concentrated in narrow regions, adapting the location and scale of the representation using supervision is a reasonable alternative to retaining only dominant global variation. SKAB implements this idea through trainable local atoms and shared functional representations.
-
The paper includes targeted component comparisons. Beyond final classification accuracy, it replaces the basis-generator parameterization, removes supervised initialization, and visualizes localized responses. These analyses help characterize the model's behavior rather than reporting predictive scores alone.
Critical weaknesses
-
The central performance advantage is not established through sufficiently fair and relevant comparisons. The paper emphasizes the large improvement on EthanolLevel, but Appendix B reports that simple supervised db4 coefficient selection with the same MLP already achieves at , compared with for SKAB. The protocols differ, as the authors acknowledge, so these numbers do not establish statistical equivalence. Nevertheless, they substantially weaken the attribution of the main-table improvement to the proposed KAN basis-learning mechanism. Fixing representation-based methods at also does not establish their relative performance after appropriate capacity selection. In the preliminary Phoneme sweep, B-splines at already match SKAB's mean accuracy in that table. More importantly, Appendix A defers principled center-scale dictionary-size selection to future work while reporting substantial configuration sensitivity. For a method whose current performance depends on this choice, a reproducible validation-based selection procedure and corresponding fair baseline comparisons are necessary evidence for the present claims, rather than an optional future extension.
-
The mathematical properties of individual atoms are insufficiently connected to the locality and interpretability of the final representation. Compact support and vanishing moments belong to the mother wavelet and its translated and scaled atoms. Subsequent layers operate on hidden representations, and the network retains global SiLU branches. These properties therefore do not automatically establish locality of the final basis functions in the original functional coordinate or suppression of local linear backgrounds by the resulting coefficients. The coefficient computation additionally involves the inverse basis Gram matrix, which can mix information across components. Energy and component-contribution plots describe particular fitted representations, but do not establish stable recovery of discriminative regions. Conditioning of the basis matrix, redundancy among learned functions, and localization stability across random seeds are insufficiently assessed. The evidence therefore supports an empirical inductive bias from localized atoms, but not stronger conclusions about structural recovery or interpretability.
Questions for authors
-
Under identical data splits, random seeds, prediction heads, and validation-based model selection, does SKAB significantly outperform supervised db4 coefficient selection? Please include validation-selected and computational cost, rather than restricting the comparison to six-dimensional representations.
-
How were the number of centers , number of scales , and representation dimension selected in the main experiments? In particular, what justified the different center count for EthanolLevel? Under a common search procedure using training and validation data only, how much of SKAB's advantage over appropriately tuned fixed-basis methods remains?
-
Which properties of the final basis functions or coefficients follow from the mother wavelet's compact support and vanishing moments after multilayer nonlinear composition, global SiLU branches, and ridge projection? Please distinguish atom-level properties, empirical localization, and mathematical guarantees for the final representation.
-
Can the authors report the spectrum or condition number of the learned Gram matrix and the consistency of identified regions across random seeds? On the synthetic task, can localization recovery be evaluated quantitatively against the known ground truth to establish whether the interpretations suggested by the energy maps are stable?