- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3(+1)
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a radial-basis-based method for time series forecasting. For each input window, the model predicts bounded adjustments to preset Gaussian basis centers and scales, together with input-adaptive coefficient vectors. The rendered representation is combined with local patch features and passed to a linear forecasting head. Experiments on seven benchmarks show its effectiveness.
Critical strengths
-
The method is intuitive and clearly formulated. Exploiting Gaussian bases and adapting their temporal location and extent offers a structured way to represent input-dependent variation while preserving a noise-filtering mechanism.
-
The design of the bounded adjustments to preset Gaussian basis is well-motivated.
-
ARBR achieves competitive results across several datasets with relatively low FLOPs and memory usage.
Critical weaknesses
My main concerns are about how well the paper's prior design choices and their actual effects align with its stated motivation.
-
The preset Gaussian basis centers and scales lack both experimental ablation and justification. By default, the scales of the Gaussian bases increase monotonically along the normalized time axis [0, 1], which implies that in the input sequence, positions far from the forecast point are covered by sharp (narrow) bases, while positions close to the forecast point are covered by flat (wide) bases. This seems inconsistent with the intuition that forecasting should extract long-range dependencies (or low-frequency information) from distant positions and short-range dependencies (or high-frequency information) from recent positions. Further justification for this design choice would be helpful.
-
Fig. 1 is only illustrative. The motivation it depicts has not been verified by any experiment that reconstructs the input sequence, nor has it been compared with other basis-based methods. As a result, it remains unverified whether the proposed method actually fits input patterns while suppressing noise in the way Fig. 1 suggests. It would be better to add an experiment that reconstructs/fits the input sequence from Z or G in Fig. 2, and compares the fitting quality and noise-filtering effects with other basis-based methods.
-
To better verify the role of the proposed ARBR, it would be desirable to add an ablation study that retains only the prediction head in Fig. 2(a).
After reading the rebuttal, I think the authors have addressed my concerns, so I have raised my rating to 3.
Questions for authors
See "Critical Weaknesses"
3 comments
Response to the Authors' Rebuttal
I would like to thank the authors for their response, which fully addressed my concerns in Q2 and Q3, and partially addressed my concern in Q1 by experimentally validating the effectiveness of ARBR's Gaussian-prior design.
Regarding Q1, I have one follow-up question. I agree that “increasing scales improve recent-noise robustness” makes sense for positions close to the forecast point, where flat/wide bases are used. However, using sharp/narrow bases at locations farther away from the prediction point still seems counterintuitive to me. I wonder whether there is a more intuitive explanation for this point.
Author Follow-up Response to Reviewer dmQY
Thank you for the thoughtful follow-up. We agree that our previous response did not sufficiently explain the role of narrower distant bases.
The key distinction is between a pattern’s temporal duration and its distance from the forecast point. For example, a brief event at a particular phase of an earlier cycle may inform future observations at a corresponding phase. In such a case, distinguishing that historical position from neighboring positions may be useful, even though the predictive dependency spans a long interval. This motivates retaining temporally localized components in the earlier part of the representation, rather than requiring every distant component to have broad temporal coverage.
In ARBR, a narrow basis distributes its input-conditioned coefficient over a more localized set of patch positions; it does not restrict which input positions can inform that coefficient or which future steps it can influence. Both geometry and coefficients are conditioned on the entire input window, and the forecasting head combines all patch representations. Thus, temporal localization in the rendered representation is compatible with long-range forecasting.
Our design intuition is to balance temporal specificity in earlier components with perturbation tolerance near the forecast origin. Narrower distant bases provide the former, while broader recent bases are intended to encourage the latter. The local residual pathway additionally provides access to patch-level details, including recent fine-scale information.
We do not claim that distant positions inherently require narrower bases. The increasing-scale scaffold is an empirically supported reference prior, with bounded input-adaptive adjustments, rather than a universal rule. Tables R1–R2 show that, compared with decreasing scales, increasing scales reduce recent-noise degradation from 5.9% to 3.1%, while increasing distant-noise degradation from 1.4% to 2.2%, and improve average forecasting MSE from 0.3034 to 0.3001. These results support the overall trade-off.
Author Response to Reviewer dmQY
Thank you for your careful review. We clarify the scaffold design and provide additional scaffold, reconstruction, and prediction-head controls.
W1/Q1. Uniform centers and increasing scales
Uniform centers provide a competitive simple prior, while increasing scales improve recent-noise robustness with a temporal trade-off.
Gaussian scales control temporal coverage, rather than explicitly decomposing high/low frequencies. Increasing scales target recent local perturbations.
We vary center layouts and scale ordering, retain input-adaptive geometry and the remaining architecture, and train all variants from scratch.
Table R1. Reference-scaffold ablation
L=512; Avg. MSE equally averages 7 datasets and 4 horizons; DeltaMSE is relative to ARBR. Increasing scales outperform constant/reversed scales. Recent-dense centers do not help.
We also inject equal-strength local noise into recent or distant history and measure degradation in frozen models.
Table R2. Position-dependent perturbations
Increasing versus decreasing scales reduces recent degradation (5.9% to 3.1%) but increases distant degradation (1.4% to 2.2%).
W2/Q2. Signal fitting and noise suppression
In the controlled task, ARBR-G improves clean-signal recovery and noise robustness, while the local residual adds detail and noise sensitivity.
We add controlled synthetic reconstruction with clean ground truth. Fixed Gaussian, Global Learned Gaussian, Cosine, and ARBR retain the same encoder/coefficient-generator architectures, latent dimension, and prediction head; only basis functions and geometry generation differ.
After future-MSE training, predictors are frozen. Separate equal-capacity linear readouts reconstruct histories and are trained only on clean inputs, without noisy-to-clean denoising supervision. ARBR-G and ARBR-Z evaluate the radial representation and its fusion with the local residual. Readouts are patch-shared 128-to-24 linear maps (3,096 parameters), selected by clean-validation reconstruction MSE, without noisy-test selection.
Table R3. Frozen-representation reconstruction
L=512, H=96, K=8, D=128; SNR=10 dB. Values are mean ± SD across three independent training seeds. Clean-fit NMSE measures clean-input reconstruction error; Noisy-input NMSE compares noisy-input reconstructions against clean truth. Noise Transfer measures transmission of independent input-noise changes to reconstructed outputs. Protocols, formulas, and visualizations are in Appendix E.8.
Versus Global Gaussian-G, ARBR-G lowers Clean-fit NMSE from 0.049 to 0.038, Noisy-input NMSE from 0.076 to 0.054 (28.9%), and Noise Transfer from 0.26 to 0.19 (26.9%). Adding the local residual improves clean reconstruction to 0.031, but increases Noise Transfer to 0.37. These results support Fig. 1's motivation within this task.
W3/Q3. Prediction-head-only controls
ARBR outperforms linear and parameter-matched nonlinear direct predictors on all seven datasets.
Linear-Only uses a single linear head; Matched-MLP uses a nonlinear predictor matched to full ARBR's parameter count separately for each horizon. Both remove the sequence encoder, radial geometry, coefficient generator, and local branch, retain RevIN, and train from scratch.
Table R4. Direct-prediction controls
L=512; MSE equally averages H={96,192,336,720}; Avg. equally weights seven datasets. Average MSE falls by 8.3%/5.9% versus Linear-Only/Matched-MLP. Added nonlinear capacity does not close the gap; together with the original ablations, these results support structured representations.