- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Separate to Restore (STR), a dual-branch framework for image dehazing that separately models scene content and haze-related residuals. The proposed method incorporates Haar wavelet decomposition for frequency-based guidance and introduces a Haze-guided Feature Exchange Block (HFEB) to facilitate information exchange between the two branches. Additionally, a Haze Evidence Routing Block (HERB) is designed to guide feature interactions using haze-related priors. Experimental results on several dehazing benchmarks demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed framework, particularly on O-HAZE.
Critical strengths
Clear motivation: This work provides a reasonable motivation for separating scene content and haze-related information into two branches to improve image dehazing.
Well-designed framework: The proposed method integrates frequency-based guidance, feature exchange, and haze-related priors into a unified framework. The overall architecture is clearly presented and easy to understand.
Critical weaknesses
-
Limited performance across benchmarks: The PSNR results on Dense-HAZE, I-HAZE, and NH-HAZE are lower than those of previous works. Further analysis of these inconsistent dehazing results is needed.
-
Limited novelty: This work seems to be a combination of existing techniques, including wavelet decomposition, frequency-based guidance, and gated feature fusion. A clearer description of the differences between this work and existing techniques should be added to the Introduction.
Questions for authors
This work assigns low-frequency information to the content path and high-frequency information to the haze path. In my opinion, haze patterns tend to be low-frequency due to their low contrast, while background patterns (content) tend to be high-frequency due to their complex details. Therefore, why does this work feed low-frequency information into the content path and high-frequency information into the haze path?