- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The modeling was conducted through part-level segmentation and the analysis of atomic motions. While this approach holds value by addressing a practical problem frequently explored in the field, the lack of a thorough review of existing literature leaves the research’s positioning unclear, making the problem formulation appear unoriginal. Furthermore, the models used for comparison are outdated, and the evaluation is incomplete.
Critical strengths
- Addresses a practical aspect within the field of Text-to-Motion.
- Although the field of Text-to-Motion has become quite stable and has seen a proliferation of research papers, it remains underutilized in the industry. I believe this is because, while current models can generate simple motions effectively, they struggle with motions derived from complex prompts. Research that tackles this challenge represents a valuable contribution to the community.
Critical weaknesses
- Lack of Prior Research and Novelty
- Although the proposed approach utilizes a part-level methodology, it fails to provide a comparison or analysis against existing part-level methods such as ParCo (ECCV 2024), LGTM (SIGGRAPH 2024), BiPO (WACV 2026), and ParTY (CVPR 2026).
- Furthermore, given that the problem formulation and methodology appear closely related to "events," the paper lacks a comparative analysis with existing methods in this domain, such as AToM (CVPR 2025) and Event-T2M (ICLR 2026). Consequently, the positioning of this paper remains unclear, and it appears to lack sufficient novelty.
- Evaluation Fails to Support Claims
- The FID performance is significantly worse than that of MoMask, which does not utilize an LLM.
- Multimodality performance is not reported.
- For non-LLM-based approaches, comparisons are limited to models from 2024, which are now outdated.
- Absence of User Study
- Evaluating human motion solely through metrics is often insufficient to capture the full picture; therefore, a user study is essential. However, no such evaluation is provided.
- Insufficient Demonstration of Model Efficiency
- The paper fails to demonstrate efficiency; it should provide a comparison of parameters and latency against both non-LLM and LLM-based methodologies.
Questions for authors
- The current comparative evaluation and analysis of existing literature are insufficient. Please provide a comparison and analysis against the papers mentioned above.
- To my understanding, R-Precision is a more robust metric than GT (Ground Truth); please clarify whether this metric can be used to substantiate superior performance. Additionally, given the significantly lower FID score, please provide an analysis of this result and demonstrate why the model still outperforms others despite this.
- Please demonstrate the model's diversity by showcasing its multimodality.
- Please include a user study.
- Please demonstrate the model's efficiency by comparing its FLOPs, parameter count, and latency against those of state-of-the-art models.