- Rating
- 4
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper revisits text-driven human motion generation directly in raw motion space rather than relying on some latent representations. The authors argue motion-space diffusion is bottlenecked by two redundancies: feature redundancy from over-parameterized representations, and state redundancy from invalid off-manifold states. They instantiate this in DirectMotion, a minimalist flow-matching baseline with a compact representation (root features plus joint rotations), probability paths constrained to the state manifold via SLERP on SO(3), and direct prediction of clean motion sequences. With a 9.2M-parameter DiT, DirectMotion reports state-of-the-art FID and R-precision on HumanML3D and competitive results on SnapMoGen, with ablations isolating each design choice.
Critical strengths
[Originality]
- The feature-redundancy vs. state-redundancy framing is a fresh lens on why latent compression has worked so well and where motion-space generation has left performance on the table. Casting the design choices as testable hypotheses makes the logic crisp.
[Quality]
- The results are striking: state-of-the-art FID on HumanML3D with a 9.2M-parameter backbone against baselines up to hundreds of millions of parameters, leading on all R-precision metrics too. The ablations are well constructed and the physical-plausibility evaluation goes beyond perceptual metrics. The results look plausible to me.
Critical weaknesses
n/a
Questions for authors
I don't have major questions. Overall this is a surprising and well-executed manuscript, so I lean towards accept.
We sincerely appreciate your recognition of our work. It is encouraging to know that you see value in our contribution. Thank you again for your positive feedback.