- Rating
- 2(−1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper addresses an emerging issue in the T2M field and attempts to resolve it effectively. While extensive experiments demonstrate the superiority of the proposed methodology, the experimental setup has some shortcomings. Overall, the paper is not particularly easy to read.
Critical strengths
- The problem formulation is good.
- Although the T2M field has become quite standardized and is currently seeing a flood of research papers, its practical application in the industry remains limited. This is because, while state-of-the-art models excel at generating relatively simple motions, there has been comparatively little research into generating the complex, long-duration motions required by the industry. This paper directly addresses this gap and makes a valuable contribution to the motion research community.
- The boundary-free event-wise semantic supervision methodology is intuitive.
- It effectively addresses an area within the T2M field that has not yet been extensively researched. The idea of identifying individual events without the need for labels—and then using them for supervision—is, in my view, highly practical.
- Including experiments on SnapMoGen is an good addition.
- While it is standard practice in the T2M field to evaluate models solely on HumanML3D and KIT-ML, expanding the benchmark suite is a positive step. This effectively demonstrates the model's generalization performance.
- Create additional event-specific metrics to effectively capture aspects that existing metrics fail to measure.
Critical weaknesses
-
Absence of videos and user studies. In the field of human motion, human evaluation is essential to determine whether the motion is truly "human-like." As it stands, no motion videos have been provided, making an accurate assessment difficult.
-
The paper is very difficult to read.
- It appears that all citations have been formatted using
\citep, which makes the text feel quite awkward. Please use\citetappropriately where needed. - Some terms appear suddenly without any explanation (e.g., "R@1"). Since readers unfamiliar with this specific field might find this confusing, please provide a brief explanation when a term is first introduced.
- Section 2.1 ("Related Work") is written in a rather perfunctory manner. It essentially just lists works in the T2M (Text-to-Motion) field, and the paper could be understood perfectly well even without this section. Either expand on it with more detail or merge it with Section 2.2.
- The presentation of mathematical formulas is not reader-friendly. Symbols are often introduced without clear definitions, forcing the reader to infer their meanings. (For instance, in Section 3.2, a symbol previously denoted as "T" suddenly appears as "L," and it is not at all clear what the distinction is—this issue persists throughout the paper.)
- Somewhat Incomplete Experimental Setup
- SnapMoGen does not include an experiment analyzing performance variations based on the number of events—a key claim of the paper. While the intention behind using diverse benchmarks with a higher number of multi-event sequences is clear, conducting a simple additional experiment—which would not require further training—would strengthen the validity of the paper. Furthermore, the study lacks a multi-modality component. It also omits results for the full KIT-ML dataset, as well as for subsets with more than 3 (E>3) or 4 (E>4) events.
Questions for authors
- Could you conduct a user study with at least 20 participants and provide statistical validation?
- Please include experiments regarding "events" (as in SnapMoGen).
- Please add the "MModality" metric.
- Please include performance results for "full," "E>3," and "E>4" on the KIT-ML dataset.
- It is my understanding that the feature extractor developed by Guo is biased. Could you re-evaluate the performance using the feature extractor from MARDM instead?
- Please include a comparison of latency and the number of model parameters.
3 comments
Response to Author
Thank you for your diligent efforts in the rebuttal process. I have reviewed the revised manuscript; however, as there were no indications or notes specifying where or how the changes were incorporated, it was quite difficult to locate each one. My responses are as follows:
- Videos
- There are discrepancies in the ✓/✗ classifications between the videos and the captions provided in the paper’s figures. For instance, in Fig. 3(a), the event "Does not touch toes" is labeled for Event-T2M, yet the corresponding video is marked with a ✓.
- User Study
- The requested statistical validation is missing. Consequently, it is impossible to determine whether the reported results are statistically significant.
- Readability
- The citation format and mathematical notation issues have been resolved.
- The term "R@1" appears early on without any explanation; adding a brief definition would improve readability.
- My comments regarding the "Related Works" section have not been addressed. The paragraph on text-to-motion still reads more like a simple list of methods.
- SnapMoGen Experiments
- The subset accounts for 99.78% (3,991/4,000) of the test set, yet the figures differ significantly from those in Table 2 (Full). An explanation is required.
- MModality
- MModality has addressed my concerns regarding diversity. Thank you.
- KIT-ML Experiments
- The values for the row differ between the table provided in your response (CMDM: 2.8303/0.5286) and Table 12 in the revised manuscript (2.940/0.601).
- Compared to Event-T2M, G2E-T2M shows significantly lower performance in terms of FID for the "Full," , and categories.
- MARDM Experiments
- Results from other comparative papers are missing.
- Only E≥2 is available.
- Efficiency
- I am curious whether the cost of LLM event decomposition during inference has been accounted for.
Although most of the requested experiments were conducted, several instances of discrepancies between the reported numerical values and the corresponding conclusions were identified in the additional results. This has, in fact, raised further concerns regarding the overall reliability of the experiments. Consequently, I am adjusting the score to "weak reject."
Response to Reviewer vqsR
Thank you for the careful review. We apologize for the annotation and reporting inconsistencies. We summarize the revisions below.
1. Videos and figure annotations.
Fig. 3 (p. 8) uses sparsely sampled mesh frames that may miss brief movements. For Event-T2M in Fig. 3(a), we replaced the 6.40 s frame with the 6.00 s pose from the same sequence and changed “Does not touch toes” to “Brief toe-directed reach,” without claiming toe contact. We also checked other main-paper visualizations against their videos and corrected affected frames and annotations.
2. Statistical validation.
From the available means and SDs of participant-average ratings (n = 20), we derived conservative paired-t p-value bounds; the original paired records were unavailable. After Holm correction, the upper bounds are below 0.01 for all three criteria against Event-T2M, and 0.0203 (Fidelity), 2.46 × 10⁻⁶ (Order Alignment), and 0.1126 (Naturalness) against CMDM. These results depend on paired-t assumptions and do not establish a Naturalness advantage over CMDM (p. 31, lines 1640–1647 and footnote 1).
3. Readability and Related Work.
We defined R@1 at its first occurrence (p. 1, lines 48–49) and revised Sec. 2 (p. 3, lines 121–161) to compare generation strategies, event representations, and semantic supervision.
4. SnapMoGen.
Our previous response inadvertently included results from an experimental setting with randomly combined prompts and extended target motion lengths. The corrected results follow the evaluation protocol used in Table 2 (Table 11, p. 29). Full and E ≥ 2 differ by at most 0.1 percentage points in R@1 and 0.005 in FID.
| Subset | CMDM R@1 (%) | Ours R@1 (%) | CMDM FID | Ours FID |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Full | 82.4 | 85.3 | 15.008 | 13.972 |
| E ≥ 2 | 82.4 | 85.2 | 15.009 | 13.967 |
| E ≥ 3 | 82.1 | 85.1 | 15.206 | 14.136 |
| E ≥ 4 | 82.9 | 85.5 | 15.943 | 14.803 |
| E ≥ 5 | 82.2 | 85.3 | 16.668 | 15.714 |
5. KIT-ML.
Due to time and computational constraints, the additional KIT-ML evaluations used 10 repetitions, matching CMDM’s repetition count (Yu et al., CVPR 2026). CMDM’s previously reported MM-Dist/FID of 2.8303/0.5286 came from this evaluation. Table 12’s E ≥ 2 row reuses Table 1’s 20-repetition results (2.940/0.601); the other rows use 10 repetitions. The caption now specifies these counts (p. 29, lines 1548–1550).
We acknowledge higher FID than Event-T2M on Full, E ≥ 3, and E ≥ 4. Our best-window event loss does not explicitly supervise durations or transitions, but its contribution to the FID gap remains unverified. The E ≥ 3 and E ≥ 4 subsets contain only 80 and 10 samples, respectively, limiting FID interpretation without explaining the Full result. G2E-T2M has the lowest MM-Dist and FID on E ≥ 2 in both evaluations, but improvements are not uniform across subsets.
6. MARDM evaluation.
We added comparisons with ten baselines on HumanML3D and KIT-ML, reporting retrieval and event-level metrics, FID, MM-Dist, and Diversity with pointwise 95% CIs (Tables 16–17, p. 32). This MARDM-based analysis covers the complete E ≥ 2 subsets only.
7. Inference cost.
Table 18 reports motion-generation latency with precomputed event descriptions. Offline LLM decomposition is excluded; new prompts incur additional preprocessing cost (p. 33, lines 1753–1754).
We appreciate your consideration.
Response to Reviewer vqsR
We thank the reviewer for the constructive feedback.
Videos and Human Evaluation
We added continuous motion comparison videos of MDM, MoMask, Event-T2M, SALAD, and G2E-T2M to the supplementary material, with annotations showing which constituent events are realized.
Following Event-T2M's perceptual evaluation criteria, we conducted a study with 20 participants (10 male, 10 female) and 512 motion samples. We used a 7-point Likert scale for Fidelity, Order Alignment, and Naturalness and report means and standard deviations.
G2E-T2M achieves the highest mean ratings among the evaluated generators. Compared with CMDM, it improves Fidelity, Order Alignment, and Naturalness by 0.151, 0.354, and 0.114, respectively, supporting improved event realization and temporal consistency.
Citation Formatting
We revised citations throughout the manuscript, using
\citet{}for narrative citations and\citep{}for parenthetical citations to improve readability in Related Work and the method section.SnapMoGen
G2E-T2M improves R@1 and FID over CMDM (Base) on every event-count subset.
KIT-ML
We report MM-Dist and FID for the full cohort and event-count subsets. E≥4 has 10 samples, below the Guo evaluator's 32-candidate requirement for R-Precision. No samples have E≥5.
G2E-T2M achieves the lowest MM-Dist on the full cohort and the lowest MM-Dist and FID at E≥2. Both metrics trail the baselines at E≥3. At E≥4, G2E-T2M has the lowest MM-Dist and highest FID. The E≥4 distributional metrics should be interpreted with caution given the small sample.
Multimodality
MModality measures motion diversity for the same text description.
G2E-T2M remains competitive on all three benchmarks, suggesting that improved event alignment can coexist with diverse motions per prompt.
MARDM Evaluation
We re-evaluated CMDM and G2E-T2M with MARDM's 67-dimensional essential-feature evaluator (CVPR 2025), using its motion representation and normalization statistics. We kept the generated motions, captions, and retrieval pools fixed for the re-evaluation.
G2E-T2M gains 0.669 percentage points in R@1, lowers FID from 1.246 to 1.021, and slightly improves MM-Dist, Avg-E, and Worst-E, supporting gains beyond the Guo evaluator.
Efficiency
We tested CMDM and G2E-T2M under matched inference settings on an NVIDIA RTX 5090, using 196-frame motions with three constituent events.
G2E-T2M adds 4.21M trainable parameters (+10.9% generator, +2.3% total). Mean latency increases by about 1.5% and 1.6% at batch sizes 1 and 16, respectively.