- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper studies held-out gene imputation in spatial transcriptomics, where part of the gene panel is masked during training and has to be predicted at every spot. The model is a multi-scale wavelet INR shared across genes. Each gene is decoded through weights produced by an amortizer from a fixed 68-d gene embedding, which consists of a truncated-SVD co-expression code plus Moran's I features. A negative-binomial deconvolution path ties the latent to a cell-type signature matrix. On eight HEST-1K domains, the method reports a mean Pearson correlation of 0.300, compared with 0.265 for SpaGE, the best of ten reproduced baselines.
Critical strengths
-
The idea of generating all per-gene decoding weights from a fixed gene embedding is simple and makes sense. The paper also explains clearly why existing INR methods such as STINR and SUICA cannot give a prediction for an unseen gene.
-
The multi-scale design is well supported by the ablation. The single-scale variant is worse on all eight domains (Table 2), and Fig. 4b shows that the loss is larger for the more spatially structured genes.
-
The evaluation is broad (8 domains, 90 Visium sections, two species), and all baselines are run through one driver with the same panels, splits and evaluator.
Critical weaknesses
-
My main concern is that the held-out genes are not really held out. In App. B, the code of gene is the -th row of from a truncated SVD over all slides and all genes, which includes the held-out columns and the scored slides. However, . In other words, the code is the held-out gene's own expression projected onto the 64 leading spot factors, so is already a rank-64 approximation of the column being predicted. Since is mostly determined by the observed genes, the model can largely recover the gene from its own measurements. The embedding also contains the gene's measured Moran's I (Sec. 3.1), which Sec. 4.3 shows is the main driver of accuracy. So I do not agree with the claim in Sec. 4.1 that the side information is "no more informative" than what the baselines receive, and this is not the cold-start setting described in Sec. 1 either. I don't see how this can be fixed without changing the problem itself.
-
The motivation and the baseline setup also do not fit well together. The paper argues that no paired single-cell data is available (Sec. 1). Yet is built from a single-cell reference of the same tissue (App. A), which is exactly the kind of unpaired reference that SpaGE, Tangram etc. are designed for. However, these baselines were given the remaining Visium slides instead. SpaDiT is negative on all eight domains (Table 1), which suggests that some of them do not work properly in this setup.
Besides, the ML novelty seems limited, since the method is mostly a wavelet INR combined with hypernetwork-style conditioning and STINR-style deconvolution.
Questions for authors
- Can the authors confirm that the held-out gene's column, including its values on the scored slides, enters the SVD that produces its code? If so, how does the full model compare with simply reading out the rank-64 reconstruction ?
- Why were the reference-based baselines not given the same-tissue single-cell reference that is used to build ?
Please check authors' rebuttal and participate in the discussion
Dear reviewer,
The discussion phase is coming to an end. Please read the authors’ rebuttal and post a brief follow-up in the discussion thread. Let us know which of your concerns the response addresses and which remain open.
Please post any follow-up questions in the thread visible to the author as soon as possible, so that the author has time to respond and provide clarification. I also encourage you to engage with one another’s assessments—especially where your perspectives differ—and to note whether any counterarguments or discussions lead you to revise your own assessment.
Thank you for your effort and thoughtful review. Thank you again!
AC