- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes the BEPS-Net, a visible-infrared object detection framework. In this method, it designs a Primary-Complementary Bidirectional Enhancement (PCBE) strategy to treat one modality enhancement by the other modality, preserving modality-specific discriminative cues while exploiting cross-modal complementarity. Moreover, it introduces a Query-wise Modality Preference Selection (QMPS) scheme to integrate query initialization from both modality feature representations with modality preference routing. Experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of proposed BEPS-Net.
Critical strengths
There are some Critical Strengths in this paper, including
- A visible-infrared object detection framework is proposed to address the potential attenuation of modality-specific discriminative cues.
- Primary-Complementary Bidirectional Enhancement scheme is designed to complementarily enhance one modality by the other modality.
- Query-wise Modality Preference Selection scheme is designed to decide which modality is prefered prefered in visible-infrared object detection.
- This paper is with clear organization structure and completed presentation, and extensive experiments are done to demonstrate the effectiveness of BEPS-Net.
Critical weaknesses
This paper has some Critical Weaknesses:
- The main ideas in BEPS-Net, including Primary-Complementary Bidirectional Enhancement and Modality Preference Selection, are not new. For example, the former has been widely explored in DEYOLO (2024), DRPFNet (2026), LDFE (2026), etc. This paper combines existing schemes to construct BEPS-Net framework, with a-little weak scheme novelty.
- In the explanation to BEPS-Net, only the mathematical formula of module-level input-ouput is presented. The novelty deepth seems coarse and weak. Moreover, the necessary loss function is not defined.
- In experiments, only mAP is used for perforamnce evaluation comparison. More performance metrics could be adopted. Moreover, only the feature responses before and after PCBE are shown. Besides resultant evidenes, more visualization evidences of intermediate process are not reported to compare BEPS-Net with other methods.
Questions for authors
Similar to the "Critical Weaknesses", I only have three concern points, including:
1.The novelty and contribution
The main ideas in BEPS-Net, including Primary-Complementary Bidirectional Enhancement and Modality Preference Selection, are not new. For example, the former has been widely explored in DEYOLO (2024), DRPFNet (2026), LDFE (2026), etc. This paper combines existing schemes to construct BEPS-Net framework, with a-little weak scheme novelty.
2.Weak theory analysis and explanation
In the explanation to BEPS-Net, only the mathematical formula of module-level input-ouput is presented. The novelty deepth seems coarse and weak. Moreover, the necessary loss function is not defined.
3.Performance Metrics and visualization evidences
In experiments, only mAP is used for perforamnce evaluation comparison. More performance metrics could be adopted. Moreover, only the feature responses before and after PCBE are shown. Besides resultant evidenes, more visualization evidences of intermediate process are not reported to compare BEPS-Net with other methods.
Dear Reviewers,
The authors have posted their rebuttal responses. I would kindly encourage you to review the authors' responses and continue the discussion by providing follow-up comments where appropriate. In particular, please indicate whether the authors' responses have adequately addressed your concerns and update your assessment if necessary.
Thank you for your time and continued efforts!
Your AC