- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
Aiming at the problem that the spatial reliability of visible infrared image fusion changes in the image, this paper proposes a decision-making centered fusion method DCFusion, which makes the idea of dual-mode alignment not only stay in an isolated stage of image fusion, but also play a role in the whole process. Based on CNN and other basic frameworks, the author uses a variety of visible and infrared datasets for experiments, and proposes System Decision Module, Zip-Alignment Module and Boundary-Aware Refiner, which achieve better experimental results and model distillation without too much performance loss under smaller conditions.
Critical strengths
1. The motivation and proposed solutions of the paper are highly consistent, and they basically solve the problems raised.
2. The experimental design is very complete. The comparison experiments, parameter experiments, detection experiments, and segmentation experiments all have clear descriptions of their settings.
3. The authors propose DCFusion, a lightweight model that ensures both fusion performance and a certain degree of robustness.
4. The experiments involve multiple datasets, and random seed experiments are conducted to demonstrate the transparency of the paper's results.
5. The proposed Zip-Alignment Module achieves sufficient modal information interaction while remaining lightweight.
Critical weaknesses
1. The paper is not clear enough in its expression. Some statements, such as “different modules may operate under different spatial reliability conditions,” generally emphasize that they will select appropriate modules under suitable spatial reliability conditions, but the paper as a whole does not convey this meaning.
2. The figures in the paper are not vector graphics. When presenting qualitative results, such figures are much less convincing.
3. The paper has some formatting issues. In the citation part, the author uses ~\cite{} throughout, but in the author’s context, these citations are not used as the subject, and ~\citep{} should be used for citation. There are also some missing spaces in the paper; some are caused by incorrect citations, and some may be caused by carelessness.
4. The high- and low-frequency decomposition used in Section 3.2 is mainly based on Avgpool. Such high- and low-frequency decomposition is too coarse and may affect the performance.
5. The textual description in Section 3.3 does not correspond to Figure 2, which causes some difficulty in understanding.
6. There are some problems with the explanation of the metrics in Section 4.2. Since metrics such as are reference-based image fusion metrics, visible and infrared images need to be provided during calculation. Under the author’s assumption, these data may already have some degradation. In this case, how the metrics calculated can prove that the proposed method has the ability to cope with degradation remains open to question.
7. This paper considers that degradation mainly exists in the visible modality, so when calculating , only visible-modality images are calculated. However, the paper also mentions that infrared images have some contrast insufficiency problems, and the expression on this issue needs to be strengthened.
8. In Section 3, this paper has a Degradation perception module, but the entire pipeline faces relatively clean datasets. We can only roughly perceive the role of this module in the ablation study. Apart from that, the capability of this Degradation perception module is difficult to quantify.
9. There is a clear conflict between the paper's main results and Table 11 in the appendix. On the FMB dataset, the main table reports for "Ours" as 18.03, as 1.59, and as 0.507, whereas Table 11 reports the mean over three random seeds as 17.703 ± 0.096, 1.562 ± 0.004, and 0.4707 ± 0.0010. If Table 11 summarizes the same FMB experiment, then 18.03 differs from 17.703 by about 3.4 reported standard deviations, 1.59 differs from 1.562 by about 7 reported standard deviations, and the mIoU difference between 0.507 and 0.4707 is even larger.
Questions for authors
1. I do not understand the meaning of the sentence “Different modules may operate under different spatial reliability conditions, even when the network is trained end-to-end.” In particular, I am not sure what “operate” specifically means here, and the authors may need to explain it further. This is because “different modules” generally emphasizes that we would select appropriate modules under suitable spatial reliability conditions, but the paper does not convey this meaning throughout.
2. The high- and low-frequency decomposition used in Section 3.2 mainly relies on AvgPool. Such a high-/low-frequency decomposition is too coarse and may affect the performance. The authors could consider replacing it with wavelet transform or high-/low-pass filters, etc., to demonstrate that the proposed module indeed works in different frequency bands.
3. The figures in the paper are not vector graphics. When presenting qualitative results, perhaps the authors could consider replacing them with vector graphics?
4. The textual description in Section 3.3 does not correspond to Figure 2, which causes some difficulty in understanding. How are and fused with ?
5. Given points 6 to 8 in the Critical Weaknesses, would the authors consider conducting tests on some degraded datasets, such as the EMS dataset[1] or the DeMMI-RF dataset[2], to fully demonstrate the effectiveness of the model?
6. In your citation, RealPortrait: Realistic Portrait Animation with Diffusion Transformers appears. Its subject is portrait animation and diffusion Transformers, rather than infrared-visible image fusion.
7. The conflict between the paper's main results and Table 11 in the appendix is confusing. Could the authors please clarify this discrepancy for me?
[1]: Yi X, Xu H, Zhang H, et al. Text-if: Leveraging semantic text guidance for degradation-aware and interactive image fusion[C]//2024 IEEE/CVF conference on computer vision and pattern recognition (CVPR). IEEE, 2024: 27016-27025.
[2]: Sun Y, Li X, Zhu P, et al. Task-gated multi-expert collaboration network for degraded multi-modal image fusion[C]//International Conference on Machine Learning. PMLR, 2025: 57571-57586.
Dear Reviewers, The authors have posted their rebuttal responses. I would kindly encourage you to review the authors' responses and continue the discussion by providing follow-up comments where appropriate. In particular, please indicate whether the authors' responses have adequately addressed your concerns and update your assessment if necessary. Thank you for your time and continued efforts! Your AC