- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes PDD-Fusion, a physics-guided degradation-decoupled framework for low-light infrared-visible image fusion. It constructs seven imaging-inspired priors to characterize visible exposure, high-frequency reliability, and infrared thermal properties. These priors are encoded into spatial and global prompts to guide three specialized fusion branches. Experiments on LLVIP, M3FD, and MSRS demonstrate strong fusion performance and promising cross-dataset generalization without fine-tuning.
Critical strengths
- The paper introduces a coherent degradation-aware fusion strategy that explicitly associates heterogeneous degradation cues with specialized frequency-aware operations. This design provides an interpretable and practically meaningful alternative to conventional feature aggregation, forming the main methodological contribution that supports my positive assessment.
- The method demonstrates strong quantitative performance across three public datasets, with promising cross-dataset generalization without fine-tuning. Combined with its compact architecture of only 0.90M parameters and reported inference latency of 9.68 ms, these results provide compelling evidence of practical effectiveness.
Critical weaknesses
- The methodological novelty could be more clearly distinguished from existing degradation-aware and frequency-based fusion methods. Although the proposed correspondence between degradation cues and specialized fusion operations is meaningful, a more explicit comparison with closely related approaches would help better establish the contribution.
- The evaluation relies on randomly sampled subsets from the three datasets, and the reported results are primarily based on conventional fusion metrics. Providing more details about subset selection and, if feasible, additional evaluations on larger or repeated test subsets would strengthen the reliability of the empirical conclusions.
Questions for authors
- Could the authors clarify the key methodological differences between PDD-Fusion and existing degradation-aware or frequency-based fusion methods, particularly the novelty of the specialized fusion operations?
- Could the authors explain the discrepancy between the spatial-prompt ablation results in Tables 2 and 4? Were the corresponding experimental configurations identical?
- Could the authors clarify how the evaluation subsets were selected and whether all compared methods used consistent preprocessing and evaluation protocols?
8 comments
Response to the Authors' Rebuttal
-
To my understanding, CDDFuse is a general image fusion method and does not specifically address image degradation. Therefore, it may not be appropriate to include it as a comparison method for degradation-aware image fusion. In addition, I would like to better understand how the authors handle the joint degradation and fusion problem, and what advantages their approach offers over existing fusion methods designed to address image degradation. This aspect should be further clarified. The current explanation mainly focuses on describing the proposed method itself, without sufficiently highlighting its advantages over existing approaches.
-
Moreover, although the authors have added comparison methods, the corresponding explanations and descriptions have not been updated in the main text. For example, the introduction of comparison methods at the beginning of Section 4.2 remains unchanged.
-
Furthermore, in the revised manuscript, the fusion results of CDDFuse in Fig. 3 appear to preserve the human regions better. I would like to know how the authors interpret this observation.
Thank you for taking the time to review our revision and for sharing your follow-up questions.
Q1. Relation to general-purpose and degradation-aware fusion methods.
We include CDDFuse as a general-purpose baseline because both methods separate and fuse low- and high-frequency information. PDD-Fusion addresses an additional question: when the visible image is degraded, which information should still contribute to the fused result? It uses local exposure to adjust the balance between visible and infrared intensity, and estimates detail reliability separately to decide how much visible texture to retain.
DIVFusion separates scene content from illumination, while LENFusion uses feedback to couple brightness adjustment with fusion. The advantage of PDD-Fusion is that it can make different decisions within the same scene. For example, it can rely more on infrared information in a deep shadow, reduce the influence of visible intensity near a headlight, and still retain useful visible texture in a nearby well-exposed region. It can also preserve useful brightness in a noisy region while reducing the influence of unreliable fine detail. On LLVIP, PDD-Fusion achieves a of 0.526, compared with 0.505 for CDDFuse, 0.396 for DIVFusion, and 0.393 for LENFusion.
Q2. Description of the comparison methods in Sec. 4.2.
The opening paragraph of Sec. 4.2 (p. 8, lines 410–414) in the revised manuscript lists the comparison methods as follows.
We compare PDD-Fusion with nine representative fusion methods: LRRNet, DDFM, U2Fusion, CDDFuse, Text-IF, LENFusion, DIVFusion, ReCoFuse, and PhyFusion. Table 1 reports the quantitative results on LLVIP, M³FD, and MSRS.
Both added methods are cited in this paragraph.
Q3. Pedestrian visibility in Fig. 3.
We agree that CDDFuse makes the pedestrian stand out more clearly against the background in the second LLVIP example. In the same scene, the road surface and crosswalk markings are easier to see in the PDD-Fusion result. In the last MSRS example, PDD-Fusion also shows the roadway and roadside vegetation more clearly. Across the scenes shown in Fig. 3, PDD-Fusion gives a clearer and more consistent view of the surrounding scene under different lighting conditions.
Methodological Differences, Spatial-Prompt Ablation, and Evaluation Protocol
We thank the reviewer for the careful reading and constructive suggestions. The main additions in the revised manuscript are marked in blue.
Q1. What distinguishes the specialized fusion operations?
CDDFuse uses feature correlation to encourage shared low-frequency representations and modality-specific high-frequency representations. PhyFusion uses radiative-transfer and Retinex priors with physical consistency to guide cross-modal fusion. In PDD-Fusion, different degradation cues control different operations during fusion (Sec. 3.2). At the same image location, high relative visible brightness directly reduces the visible contribution to the low-frequency mixture, while a separate gate regulates visible high-frequency detail using visible reliability and infrared directional structure. Visible darkness and local infrared flatness jointly scale a Laplacian correction that enhances existing local infrared contrast.
Section 4.4 and Fig. 5(b) illustrate the exposure operation on one LLVIP scene. Under a 5× gain applied to the visible input, the mean low-frequency visible weight in the glare region fell from 0.059 to 0.016. Table 1 and Fig. 3 provide quantitative and visual comparisons with CDDFuse and PhyFusion.
Q2. Spatial-prompt ablation in Tables 2 and 4
“Module 3” (Table 2) and “Spatial Prompt” (Table 4) use the same configuration, with the degradation priors, specialized branches, and spatial prompt enabled and the global prompt disabled. A transcription error in supplementary Table 4 caused the discrepancy. Both tables now report the same results for this configuration.
Q3. Subset selection and evaluation protocol
For the comparisons in Table 1, we randomly selected 300 image pairs from the official LLVIP test split, 300 from MSRS, and 200 from M$^3$FD. Within each dataset, every method received exactly the same infrared–visible image pairs. We scored all fused outputs using the same evaluation pipeline and the same implementations of EN, MI, QAB/F, VIF, and QG. The LLVIP-trained PDD-Fusion model was evaluated directly on MSRS and M$^3$FD without fine-tuning.
Overall, the revision connects the fusion design to measured branch responses and documents cross-dataset transfer in terms of image-fusion quality. Larger or repeated test subsets would help assess sensitivity to sample selection. Downstream task performance remains open.