- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes TrajRing, a training-free method for improving the fidelity of Tree-Ring watermarked images. The authors observe that perturbations introduced into the initial latent noise can propagate during denoising, causing the watermarked generation to deviate from its clean counterpart. To address this, they propose a combination of trajectory-aware spectral projection and clean-reference query-key injection to preserve the watermark while keeping the generated image close to the unwatermarked output. The paper reports improvements in paired fidelity while maintaining comparable watermark detection performance and avoiding per-image optimization.
Critical strengths
The paper does not require additional training or per-image optimization, making it computationally efficient.
Critical weaknesses
-
My main concern is why a watermarked generation needs to be highly similar to its clean counterpart in the first place (which is the main motivation of the paper). As long as the generated image is realistic, consistent with the prompt, and contains an imperceptible watermark, that is enough in most cases where the user has no idea what the clean image would look like. Building on this, I don't think the reported PSNR, SSIM, and LPIPS against paired clean generations are fair to Tree-Ring, since Tree-Ring produces a different but equally valid image. Additionally, given that the main benefit is preserving similarity to a particular clean generation, while watermark detection remains largely unchanged, I am not convinced that the paper establishes sufficiently important improvements over stronger fidelity-preserving baselines such as PT-Mark.
-
Several previous works have demonstrated targeted removal and forgery attacks against Tree-Ring. Since TrajRing retains the original Tree-Ring watermark construction and detector, it is important to understand whether these vulnerabilities are also inherited. The current evaluation does not establish robustness against such targeted attacks.
Questions for authors
-
Can you please provide a scenario in which the watermarked and clean images should look the same? This will raise the practical significance of the proposed method. More precisely, please provide your threat model.
-
How does TrajRing compare with simpler approaches? I am asking this because the novelty of the proposed method is limited. The observation that perturbations in the initial noise propagate and cause deviations during denoising seems expected given the nonlinear nature of diffusion models. Similarly, it combines spectral replacement with clean-reference attention guidance, both of which are conceptually straightforward and related to existing reference-guided generation techniques. Therefore, you need to establish why the proposed approach is preferable to simpler alternatives, such as one-time spectral correction or latent blending using the same clean reference.