- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes a variant of Perturb CFR.
Critical strengths
Honest data reporting. Partial and unavailable runs are marked. The not good results are reported.
Critical weaknesses
- The paper's central contrast against prior work is factually incorrect, and its distinguishing idea is largely intrinsic to the EFPE framework. The following works are directly relevant and are not discussed or compared [1-4].
[1] Ren et al., Last-Iterate Convergence in Adaptive Regret Minimization for Approximate Extensive-Form Perfect Equilibrium, EC 2025. This is the closest work that exists to ALP-CFR's stated contribution, with a convergence guarantee ALP-CFR lacks, and it appeared more than a year before this submission.
[2] Čermák et al., Practical Performance of Refinements of Nash Equilibria in Extensive-Form Zero-Sum Games, ECAI 2014. An experimental comparison of refinements in exactly this setting; the paper's experimental mission largely repeats it a decade later without acknowledgment.
[3] Masaka et al., The Power of Perturbation under Sampling in Solving Extensive-Form Games, JSAI 2025. Perturbation under sampling, the exact setting of MC-ALP-CFR in the paper.
[4] Li et al., Efficient Online Pruning and Abstraction for Imperfect Information Extensive-Form Games, ICLR 2025. The paper's protection mechanism decides where to increase training effort; Pruning decide where to remove it. This is the same resource-allocation question and the connection is never discussed.
-
No theory supporting the paper's objective. Every theoretical result is conditional in a way that voids the objective. The paper actually has no progress in theory.
-
No empirical advantage; core claim never measured. Motivating narrative (low-reach information sets in large games) is untested: all games are tiny, and the largest has no result. The experiment shows ALP-CFR do not work well in small games.
-
The paper is written in a defensive register that prevents the reader from extracting any positive claim.
Questions for authors
-
How does ALP-CFR differ from [1], which already introduces an adaptive, information-set-level perturbation scheme for ε-EFPE with last-iterate convergence? Please provide a head-to-head comparison or a precise mechanism-level distinction.
-
What is the formal definition and provenance of "RTCFR+"? Why was SPCFR excluded from the whitelist while RTCFR+ was included?
-
Why is there no completed ALP-CFR run on Leduc-5, and no completed MC-ALP-CFR run outside Kuhn?